Our Ghost

What happens to the hopes that don’t happen? The ones that we put all of our heart into, the ones that we spend our wish-upon-a-star wishes on, the ones that we are so sure will happen, but — for better or for worse or for some reason we’ll never really know and yet will keep questioning for months and months until we finally start to forget about, one heartstring at a time — never come to be?

Hopes, like humans, turn into ghosts. And the promise of something that you thought you were supposed to look forward to becomes something that you, every once in awhile, look back at. The turn your head over your shoulder when you are just about cross the street look. The cock your head to side when you are waiting for the train and you think you just saw someone you knew look. The do a double take because wait was that just the past version of yourself you saw in a cab? look.

The things that don’t happen, the ones that we once so desperately hoped one day would, they all dissolve into the air and come back to haunt us. And it seems that ghosts always reappear in the strangest of ways.


I dreamt about our son last night. The one that never came into existence, but the one that we had birthed together so many times.

Remember? Let me take you back there.

You are in your bed, and I am in mine. And yet, our voices are tangled together, as though the two of us were as tightly intertwined as the telephone cables that ran beneath our two houses and connected our words, twisting them up into a knot of innocent conversation.

To be seventeen, and desperately break out from your own bed, but have nowhere that you can escape to.

We lay there, together but apart, falling asleep to the sounds, to the whispers of our future. You and me, all grown up, with big dreams in a big city, as if that were all that we needed to keep us together: another place, somewhere, anywhere but the one we were in at that very moment, and then — then, everything would work out perfectly.

So our son was, of course, made up of the stuff of dreams. Because that’s what his parents knew how to do: to imagine something miles and miles away beyond the horizon, something that they couldn’t see but could make out in the November night sky’s darkness.

He came to life in my dreams. I can’t be sure, so tell me now: did you dream about him too?

Our son looked like us. Olive skin that was a mix between yours and mine, my coffee eyes and your copper hair, but just a little bit more muted from my dark, thick locks. I worked journalist hours during the day, and you took the night shift as a jazz band musician at night, and our son grew up reading abridged Shakespeare and listening to Illinois. You took him to school and I took him to your concerts, and that was seemingly all the parenting we thought we needed to do. To be seventeen and think that the rest of your life that lays there before you will be ever so simple.

Tell me now: how could I be haunted by something that never came to be? Something that never happened? Someone that never existed?

Our son never grew up. We, his parents, dreamed him up. But we couldn’t ever imagine him to be any taller than us. He remained a tiny thing, always reaching up for our hands, and us always scooping him up onto our hips. In my teenage dreams, we walked with him on sidewalks, on boardwalks, held his hand as the three of us crossed the street.

And I wonder, did he die? Or fade away? Fade away as we both grew up, grew apart, grew into ourselves and separated our voices from one another so that eventually we stopped talking every night, stop talking every week, stopped talking altogether in a way that the truth is that I don’t even know what your life is like now?

We both moved on, but what — whom — did we leave behind? What did we do, abandoning him in another universe all alone on a sidewalk somewhere, waiting for his parents to come back and pick up their joint dream where they left it off?

Even the potential of love, the promise of something that we could have built together — even when it dies, it doesn’t disappear. It lives on, half alive by all the love you poured into it, but decrepit, mostly gone, an outline of something that was once filled in with color. I know this because when I walk down the street, I sometimes see it. When I listen to that John Mellencamp song that reminds you of me, I sometimes hear it. When I wake up to the sun shining in from the window and remember your voice in my ear all those years ago, I sometimes feel it.

So tell me now, how do I stop seeing ghosts of things that were never mine?


I walk down 5th Avenue in the morning, wondering if I will see you. We both grew up, both moved out, both came to this big city with big dreams. How strange that what we hoped would happen did happen, in it’s own way.

I wait for the man to pour me a shot of espresso in this Park Slope coffee shop, leaning against a stool by the window. From the corner of my eye, I see someone with copper hair and a little toddler on a scooter by his side.

I pause. It couldn’t be. Could it?

I look again, this time turning my entire body to face the window. I lean forward, my entire body pressing up against the window. The glass is warm from the unforgiving July sunshine. I peer down the street, the tip of my nose on the window so that I can see the entire sidewalk in front of me.

But there is no one. Perhaps there never was.

So why don’t you tell me now: what happens to ghosts once we finally start to forget about them?