The Trail of the Axeman of New Orleans

An elusive killer struck with unprecedented brutality

C.S. Voll
12 min readAug 29, 2020
Photo looking upriver on the 100 and 200 blocks of St. Charles Avenue, New Orleans, circa 1910. From Wikimedia (Public Domain). Axeman graphic by David Englund from Pixabay.

TThe murderer terrorizing the city of New Orleans during the 1910s was a shadowy figure, becoming even more so over time. Myths, urban legends, and lies attached themselves to the actual crimes that made so many people fearful whenever they saw the approach of darkness. These characteristics led to the killer becoming seen as something akin to a bloodthirsty fiend with supernatural powers. To remove the various fabrications, to arrive at a kernel of truth, these layers around the real events need to be wiped away, exposing the suspect’s true characteristics.

A Shocking Start

It was 13 August 1910 and New Orleans was sound asleep. Harriet Crutti did likewise, but around 3 AM something ripped her from her slumber (Davis 2017: 14). A stranger stood over her, waving a bloody meat cleaver while he demanded money. Coming to her senses, she saw her husband lying in a pool of blood, so she quickly gave the shadowy figure all the money in the box under her pillow. Satisfied with this, the man strode out of the room, took the Crutti’s caged mockingbird, and then made his way outside; he dropped the meat cleaver in the yard, jumped the fence, and then walked another block until he came to another stoop, where he freed the bird.

--

--

C.S. Voll

A scholar and writer wearing many ill-fitting hats, trying to do the best he can with what he has.