Review of Some People Need Killing
Unmasking the True Cost of the Language of Populist Violence
In “Some People Need Killing,” Patricia Evangelista presents a harrowing narrative centered on the Philippines’ brutal crackdown on drugs, a policy driven more by populist rhetoric than by pragmatic considerations. Evangelista’s book is not just a tale of a nation’s struggle, but a broader commentary on the allure of simplistic solutions to complex problems, the fragility of democratic institutions under populist pressures, and the tragic human cost of political manipulation.
The book unfolds against the backdrop of the Philippine president’s decision to address the drug problem, possibly exaggerated for political gain, through extreme measures. Duterte centered his presidency in the issue, casting himself almost as a figure straight out of the Wild West era of Hollywood, where only violence could end the anarchy. This creates a culture of death, glorified and celebrated, painting a stark picture of the country’s descent into violence. The major themes include the dangerous sway of populism, the simplistic belief in violence as a solution, and the stark revelation of a nation’s institutional fragility.
My own experiences living in Myanmar, a nation in the throes of a decades long brutal dictatorship, resonated deeply with Evangelista’s portrayal of the Philippines. The contrast between a military state-dominated society and one swayed by populist passions provides a unique lens through which to view the narrative. The book serves as a poignant reminder of the ease with which societies can slip into cycles of violence, regardless of how free and fair they may seem, highlighting the importance of creativity and peaceful solutions in the face of seemingly intractable issues.
The narrative echoes themes from Walter Wink’s Powers Trilogy, particularly the critique of the “myth of redemptive violence.” The inner workings of the Domination System are evident here, and once it is triggered by Duterte, it seems to spread like rapid fire through the police and the broader public, where collateral damage is accepted as necessary. However, Evangelista’s less optimistic view of the situation offers a stark contrast to Wink’s advocacy for creativity and self-sacrifice as solutions. This juxtaposition emphasizes the unique position of Evangelista’s work in its exploration of the complexities surrounding populist-driven violence.
As a piece of investigative journalism, the book excels in shedding light on injustice, making it an essential read. Evangelista’s patient and thorough account is commendable, though it is short on suggestions for moving forward. However, this absence is not a weakness but rather a strength, inviting readers to reflect on their passive acceptance of violent solutions proposed by leaders.
I rate “Some People Need Killing” with 5 stars. I find it an absolute must-read, especially for those who wonder if they have trusted the language of violence from our leaders, whether metaphorical or material. The book’s impact lies in its ability to provoke thought and challenge beliefs, making it a significant contribution to the discussion on political and societal dynamics.
Patricia Evangelista’s “Some People Need Killing” is a compelling, insightful examination of the consequences of populist rhetoric and the myth of violence as a redemptive force. It is an impactful narrative that urges readers to question, reflect, and seek more humane and creative solutions to societal challenges.
