Scene on Dag Hammerskjold Plaza, #womensmarchnyc (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

Laughing Through Pain, New York Style. Photo Story of a March.

At the 2017 #womensmarchnyc, New Yorkers were deadly serious about protecting civil rights. But that didn’t stop them from being humorously and artistically themselves.

Carol Papper
Published in
5 min readJan 22, 2017

--

By Carol Schatz Papper

It was so important, even the introverts came out.

Inspired by the unity principles behind the Women’s March on January 21, 2017, an estimated 400,000 people — introverts, extroverts, the overtly and the newly political — came together to march as one teeming mass from Dag Hammarskjold Plaza to Trump Tower. Or, as a New Yorker might put it, U.N.-ish to Tiffany.

Even the skyscrapers seemed in agreement.

Skyscrapers near Dag Hammarskjold Plaza point middle fingers at the sky in solidarity? (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

Though no official poll was done, marchers seemed to be overwhelmingly New Yorkers or New York-area (New York, New Jersey and Connecticut) residents. Characteristically, New York wit and style was fully on display. Stand-up merged with standing up.

Pussies for grizzlies in NYC (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

Many New Yorkers showed up to support their neighbors’ rights. Allies were everywhere. Even dogs came out to support the cat-inspired pussyhats.

Seen-it-all chihuahua (credit: Carol Schatz Papper

And gay men made unusual declarations.

A boundary-crossing poster for this guy? (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

What some people call rude, New Yorkers call honest. So it went with posters and buttons expressing frank opinions about the election.

A button brigade gives the New Yorker President a Bronx cheer (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

Plus girls who just wanna have pun:

Helpful to remember that good hair shall lead the resistance (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

It was a day of thinking about the common good. Protesters weren’t only concerned with their own issues. Some urged “Free Melania.” Others asked voters to have a “Positive Menstrual Attitude.” Both well and little-known organizations were represented with placards advocating for women’s and human rights. Like who knew before about the Lady Parts Justice League?

The LPJL website mandates “laughter, dancing and sexy time in your revolution” (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

But it wasn’t only trademark New York wit on display. As befits a fashion capital, there were also rainbow hats, gold sneakers, feathers, glitter beards and fancy plumes decking out the concrete canyon citizens.

Ready for the style revolution (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)
Fantastic plumage at the #womensmarchnyc (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

People came dressed to express. Rainbow hats joined pink ones.

Knits of all stripes and persuasions spoke volumes about craft (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

Sneakers with a heart of gold lit up the sidewalk.

Shining in solidarity at the @womensmarchnyc 2017 (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

And the wearer of this polished vest was ready to let people hear him roar.

An homage to the power of the strongest cat (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

Not all gold statements spoke loudly. Some compelled by being circumspect, personal, even enigmatic. As with the holder of this single-stem golden rose.

Marcher holding gold rose with flag and ribbon bow checks his phone (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

Along with fashion, New Yorkers’ shared love of art, music, theater and literature was prominent. A “Confederacy of Dunces” cabinet poster and a “We Should All be Feminists” sandwich board showed readers care. What’s a NYC march without musical theater references? Here, an angry lyricist rewrote the Mary Poppins song, “Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious.”

The writer of “Super Callous Fascist Racist” got the rhythm down perfectly (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

And here, a shout-out to New York favorite Lin-Manuel Miranda and his touching Shakespeare-inspired “love is love is love” sonnet at the Tony’s.

Despite the huge crowd, peace and “love is love is love” prevail (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

Typical type A personalities couldn’t resist getting just a little competitive. Like saying they had the “best sign.” So New York.

In a sea of hundred-thousands, one sign stands out (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

Or wearing the chunkiest knits.

These magenta mega-knits were New-York size (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

And getting the best shot.

An agile photographer shoots from scaffolding in NYC (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

Or the best view. Which required a real sense of balance.

Boots on the postbox (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

And a willingness to climb.

Surveying the march from atop a bus shelter (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

Meanwhile, the band played on at street level. Patriotically and tunefully helping the crowd stay strong.

A patriotic band of wind players lifted spirits along the route (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

Beating the drum of equality for all.

Marching with drum in NYC (photo: Carol Schatz Papper)

The Women’s March on New York City proved yet again that diverse citizens of a diverse city can peacefully unite in the service of shared goals. Being New Yorkers, they will: laugh, cry, shout, whisper, cheer, chant, kvetch, smile, frown, dress up, dress down, sing, talk fast and nonstop in many languages and make bad puns along the way. They will be angry and funny, alarmed and resolute. They may even stop for bagels if they get hungry.

But throughout they will model a trait so quintessentially New York it’s even in the city’s lowliest insect, the cockroach.

What, exactly?

Resilience. In the face of obstacles, reSisters plow on.

photo: Carol Schatz Papper

If you like this post, please heart it below so others can see it.

--

--

Carol Papper
Papper and Pen

Award-winning design writer and former @CondeNast features editor. Believes in people, art, nature, travel and problem-solving. @carolpapper www.carolpapper.com