N. David Mermin: A Physicist’s Perspective

Some offbeat approaches to traditional physics concepts

Sunny Labh
Physics In History
5 min readJan 10, 2024

--

A man who looks at a chunk of crystal or a wisp of quantum particles and sees a story waiting to be told. David Mermin is that guy. Dr. Mermin is a renowned physicist who has made significant contributions to various fields of physics, such as solid state physics, quantum foundations, and topological defects. He’s spent his life not just in the lab, but also in the classroom and at his desk, turning the complex world of physics into engaging and thought-provoking narratives.

This isn’t a tale of dry formulas; it’s about a man with a passion for unraveling the universe’s secrets and a knack for explaining them in a way that lights up your imagination.

Early Years and Education

David Mermin came into the world in 1935, hailing from New Haven, Connecticut. His father was an engineer and his mother was a school teacher, as he mentions in his personal memoir. He went to Harvard University, where he majored in physics and graduated summa cum laude in 1956. He continued his studies at Harvard, where he obtained his PhD in physics in 1961.

His doctoral thesis was on “the thermal properties of the inhomogeneous electron gas.

Academic Career and Research

After completing his Ph.D., Mermin joined the faculty of Cornell University, where he remained until his retirement in 2006. He became a full professor in 1968 and a Horace White Professor of Physics in 1984. He also held visiting positions at various institutions, such as the Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton University, the University of Cambridge, and the Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics.

Mermin’s research spanned a wide range of topics in physics, from condensed matter physics to quantum information theory. He is best known for his collaboration with Neil Ashcroft on the textbook Solid State Physics, which is widely used as a standard reference in the field.

“The happiest years of my professional life were 1968–76 when Neil and I wrote our book and saw it into print.”

he says in an autobiographical memoir published in Cornell repository arXiv. He adds,

“We named it Solid State Physics, but today it is known throughout the scientific world as Ashcroft & Mermin. Neil was fascinated with materials. Each was like a personal friend. I had little interest in or knowledge of particular materials, but I was fascinated by the conceptual structure that encompassed them all.”

Graphics by the author/physinhistory

He is also famous for his work on quantum foundations, where he introduced several concepts and results that challenged the conventional understanding of quantum mechanics. Mermin-Wagner theorem, for example, is one such theory which states that there is no spontaneous symmetry breaking in one- or two-dimensional isotropic systems; the Mermin device, which is a gedanken experiment that demonstrates the non-locality of quantum mechanics; and the GHZ-Mermin state, which is a three-qubit entangled state that violates the Bell inequalities.

He also wrote several influential papers and books on the interpretation and philosophy of quantum mechanics, such as “Is the moon there when nobody looks?”, “What’s wrong with these elements of reality?, and Quantum Computer Science: An Introduction.

“I have published about 140 technical physics papers over a 63 year span from 1959 to 2022. A little over two a year — not many for a contemporary theorist. I would characterize most of them as clarifications, refinements, or illustrations of existing theories.,” he says in the paper.

Dr. Mermin was much more than a researcher; he was a storyteller of science and a mentor who brought the wonders of physics to life. Picture him in the classrooms of Cornell, where he wasn’t just a professor but a guide, leading students through the labyrinth of physics, from the fundamentals to the dizzying heights of advanced graduate studies.

Mermin has a special gift: he can take the dense forest of physics and carve a clear path through it, making it accessible and fascinating not just for his students but for anyone with a curious mind.

His articles and essays, featured in well-known publications like Physics Today and American Journal of Physics, weren’t just informative; they were windows into the soul of physics, revealing its history and beauty.

His unique talent for teaching and writing didn’t go unnoticed; he was adorned with accolades like the Julius Edgar Lilienfeld Prize, the Oersted Medal, and the Andrew Gemant Award.

David Mermin photographed in a lecture hall. Source.

Personal Views and Reflections

In his paper “Autobiographical Notes of a Physicist”, Mermin describes some of the personal aspects of his life and career, such as the origin of his name, the physicists he admires and interacts with, and his involvement in the quantum foundations community.

He also expresses his opinions and perspectives on physics and quantum mechanics, in particular. He emphasizes the importance of curiosity and creativity in physics, as well as the need for clarity and rigor in its presentation. He advocates for a pluralistic and pragmatic approach to the interpretation of quantum mechanics, where he endorses the QBism framework.

Mermin also criticizes the misuse and abuse of physics in pseudoscience and politics, and urges physicists to be more aware and responsible for the social and ethical implications of their work.

Mermin’s paper is a valuable and insightful account of his life and work, as well as a testament to his passion and enthusiasm for physics. ‘A letter from Richard Feynman,’ he says, ‘is what I am most proud of, along with another letter from Freeman Dyson.’

Letter extracted from arXiv. https://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.04711.pdf

Thank you so much for reading. If you liked this story don’t forget to press that clap icon as many times as you want. If you like my work and want to support me then you can Buy me a coffee ☕️. Keep following for more such stories!

--

--

Sunny Labh
Physics In History

Science writer and communicator majoring in Quantum Mechanics. Curator of @PhysInHistory on twitter. Twitter: @thePiggsBoson