The Misunderstood Man

Akr
Predict
Published in
11 min readMar 2, 2024
Image created by Author

Chapter 1: The Land Within

1.1 The Mask He Wears

The sun isn’t nothing but a cruel yellow eye on days like this, burning down on a man already bent under too much weight. Tom swiped at the sweat stinging his eyes, the rhythm of his hoe a metronome in the thick heat. Wheat stalks shimmered gold all around him, a sea of plenty, and still, the hollow ache inside him gnawed deeper with every swing.

Folks in town, they thought him simple. A strong back, a weak mind. Tom could feel their sidelong glances when he’d walk Main Street, hear the whispers behind cupped hands. “Poor Tom, a bit slow in the head, isn’t he?" He’d clench his jaw, but the sting of it lingered. He wasn’t slow. Just… tangled up inside, like the wild blackberry vines that choked the edge of his field.

Sometimes, in the barn’s quiet, with only the soft snuffles of the horses, thoughts tumbled out of him. Not the kind you could say aloud, not to another soul. Thoughts about the way sunlight dappled through the leaves, or that crick in his neck that ached like lost love, or how some days felt like drowning even while standing on dry land. But out there, in the world? He wore a mask of hardened indifference, just like his Pa taught him. Men didn’t speak such things.

Image created by Author

1.2 The Dog That Understands

Only the old hound, Rusty, saw the truth behind the mask. Rusty, with his rheumy eyes and tail that still thumped a greeting even when his joints ached. Tom would hunker down beside the barn, hands buried In that coarse fur, and tell Rusty things he wouldn’t dare breathe to another living being.

“It’s like hauling a wagon with a busted wheel, Rusty,” he’d mutter, watching Rusty’s floppy ears twitch. “All lopsided, and the weight just drags me down.” Rusty’d whine low and lick at Tom’s hand, a sandpaper tongue that somehow felt like comfort.

There were nights when Tom wouldn’t sleep a wink. He’d lie on his threadbare cot, the moon casting long shadows through the broken window, and the words would roil in his belly like a summer storm. Words he yearned to say to someone, anyone. To explain the ache in his chest that wasn’t from the hard labor, the tightness in his throat that wasn’t just dust from the fields.

But the words never came. They tangled and twisted, thorns instead of petals. Rusty would nudge his head under Tom’s arm then, and the warmth of that old dog was the only thing keeping the hollowness at bay.

Image created by Author

1.3 Town Talk

Evenings, sometimes, Tom ventured to the tavern. Not for the raucous laughter or the bitter sting of cheap whiskey, but for a slice of life beyond the silent stretch of his fields. He’d nurse a single beer, a ghost at the end of the bar, and listen.

Folks thought him too dull to pay mind, their voices buzzing around him like flies. They’d spin tales of deals struck and sweethearts wooed, of politics and weather, and all the things Tom felt a world away from. And their gossip, well, it curled around him too.

“Saw Tom at the feed store today,” Millie, the baker’s wife, would titter to her cronies. “Lord, that man couldn’t count change to save his life.” They’d cluck their tongues, and Tom’s knuckles would whiten on his beer mug. Numbers tangled in his head like barbed wire sometimes, but there was a kind of counting he was achingly good at – the counting of lonely days, of unspoken regrets.

One night, fueled by a fiery knot in his gut, he spoke. A hotheaded argument about who had the best hunting dog, and Tom’s voice, rough and rarely heard, cut through the din. His words weren’t fancy, but they were sharp, surprising even him. The room went quiet for a split second, and in that silence, he saw a flicker of something… not pity, not scorn, but a hint of reassessment. Before he could grab hold of that feeling, it was gone, swallowed by mocking laughter. Yet, on his walk home, the sting of humiliation was mixed with a strange, fleeting warmth.

Image created by Author

1.4 The Woman at the Well

It was a day like any other, the monotony broken only by the relentless sun. Tom was hauling buckets from the well, sweat dripping to mingle with the cool water, when something shifted in the heavy air. A sound, soft and sweet as birdsong, that didn’t belong to the creak of cicadas and the rustle of dry leaves.

He lifted his gaze, squinting against the glare. By the well stood a woman. New in town, he figured, with pale city skin and eyes the color of the sky just before a storm. A widow, he’d heard, carrying her own kind of quiet sorrow.

“Can I spare a cup?” she asked, her voice hesitantly polite.

He nodded, wordless, and fumbled to pass her a brimming bucket. Their fingers brushed for a fleeting second, sending a shiver through him he didn’t understand. She sipped, then smiled, a small thing that bloomed in the parched landscape of Tom’s life.

“Thank you. The walk from town… it’s hotter than I bargained for.”

There it was. That familiar tightness in his throat, locking up all the words he wished to say. A simple “You’re welcome” felt like a boulder he couldn’t budge.

She must have sensed the struggle in him, because her smile widened just a touch. “It’s a beautiful farm you have.”

Something jolted within him. Not about the land, but the way she said it, seeing something others missed. A flicker of recognition that felt more precious than gold.

Image created by Author

1.5 Night’s Bitter Harvest

Nights, they were the worst. After the sun sank, leaving Tom swallowed by a darkness that mirrored his own, his mind would churn. It was more than just loneliness, it was a bone-deep ache for something he couldn’t name. Like a hunger no amount of bread could satisfy.

He’d take to the fields, the moonlight making the wheat shimmer like a ghost-sea. The only sound was the rasp of his own breath and the distant hoot of an owl. Sometimes, he’d howl at the moon himself, a ragged, wordless cry that echoed back his own emptiness.

One night, the image of the widow by the well kept him restless. Her eyes, that storm-sky blue. The gentle way she’d smiled, like she could see a piece of him that even he’d kept hidden. Could she be the one to understand? The one to soothe this ceaseless aching?

Hope bloomed in him, a fragile thing in such barren soil. But with it came a fear sharper than any plow blade. The fear that his clumsy hands would somehow break this woman, that his fumbling words would taint the kindness she showed him.

The night stretched long and thin, filled with longing and a terror so deep it made his knees tremble. When dawn finally crept in, painting the sky in streaks of weak light, all that remained was despair. It settled over him, heavy as a shroud.

Image created by Author

Chapter 2: When the Levee Breaks

2.1 A Spark of Connection

The widow, her name was Sarah, became a faint light on the horizon for Tom. He’d catch sight of her in town, her slender figure a beacon in the bustling crowd. A simple exchange at the general store – a plea about a broken wheelbarrow, a quiet offer of help - would send his pulse thrumming for hours.

She brought out something in him he hadn’t felt in years. Not just a spark of hope, but a flicker of defiance. The whispers in the tavern, the pitying stares, they seemed to matter a little less. It fueled a recklessness in him, a need to prove them all wrong.

One sticky afternoon, Sarah appeared at his farm, hesitancy in her eyes. “I… I heard you fix things,” she stammered. “My porch swing, it’s broken.”

The simple task, repairing those broken slats, became a labor of love. Tom worked with a focus he usually reserved for harvest time, the scent of sawdust and Sarah’s faint lilac perfume swirling in his head. As they sat side-by-side on the mended swing, the setting sun glinting off their faces, Tom felt a lightness he hadn’t known in years. The conversation flowed awkwardly at first, then smoother. He dared to tell her about his old hound Rusty, a funny story about his stubborn goat, Millie. Sarah laughed, a melody that soothed the ragged edges of his soul.

Image created by Author

2.2 The Town Bully

But the good moments, the flickers of light, were always tempered with a gut-wrenching fear. That if anyone saw, if anyone knew about his growing connection with Sarah, it would all crumble to dust. Especially if that ‘anyone’ was Harlan.

Harlan, the town bully, wide as an ox with eyes that held more malice than warmth. Tom had crossed paths with Harlan since childhood, an undercurrent of resentment simmering between them. Their fathers had been rivals, and somehow, that rivalry passed down to the sons. Harlan found every excuse to chip away at Tom: a sneer at the market, a shove on Main Street.

One evening in the tavern, Harlan and his cronies were louder, crueler than usual. The whiskey fueling their laughter, their insults aimed at easy targets. Then, Harlan’s gaze settled on Tom, a twisted grin spreading across his face.

“Well, look who it is,” Harlan drawled, “Slow Tom come out to play? Or you hear they got a new picture book at the library?”

A wave of heat washed over Tom. The old, familiar retreat, the swallowing of his anger, choked him instead. The fragile connection he’d built with Sarah bloomed in his mind, and a surge of unfamiliar protectiveness coursed through him.

“Leave me be, Harlan,” he growled, the words clumsy but strong in their intent.

And then, it happened. Faster than thought. The first punch was Harlan’s, the aftermath was a blur. Fists flying, the crash of a table, grunts, swearing. In minutes, it was done. Tom stood, winded, a cut above his eye, but with Harlan sprawled on the tavern floor. Silence descended, broken by a gasp from somewhere in the crowd. Tom wasn’t a fighter, but when fueled by rage and desperation, his strength was surprising, even to him.

Image created by Author

2.3 The Price of Silence

The fight was the talk of the town. But the story warped as it spread. It wasn’t Tom defending himself, defending the flicker of hope he’d found in Sarah. It was Tom, the brute, finally revealing his true colors.

When Sarah confronted him, worry furrowing her brow, he couldn’t find the words to explain. It wasn’t shame that stopped him, it was the tangled mess in his head – the fear that he was too rough, too damaged, too much of what everyone always thought he was.

“Why, Tom?” she asked, her voice soft but laced with hurt. “Don’t you know violence fixes nothing?”

His hands, calloused and clumsy, hovered in the air, reaching for her, then dropped. It was useless. He could mend a broken fence easier than he could string together a heart-felt apology. The silence between them stretched into an abyss.

That was how the town won. Not through fists, but the poison of his own tongue-tied spirit. Sarah vanished from his life, leaving an emptiness that echoed louder than any bar brawl ever could.

Image created by Author

2.4 Betrayal

The flicker of hope that Sarah had kindled, withered and died in the barren soil of Tom’s isolation. Every day became a monotonous march – work, eat, sleep, repeat. But the hurt had curdled into a bitter anger. Not just at Harlan, not even at the whole town, but at himself.

He took too long, reckless walks. Past the golden wheat, deeper into the wilder brush where thorns scratched his hands and the wind howled in his ears. The old hound Rusty, sensing his master’s turmoil, struggled to keep pace.

One evening, he stumbled upon Sarah’s cottage, lit warmly against the dusk. A longing, sharp as hunger, seized him. He should turn, walk away, but his feet had a mind of their own. He crept closer, peering through an unshuttered window. Sarah sat by the fireplace, not alone, but with a stranger, a man from the next town over. Something in the way they leaned towards each other, in their gentle laughter, pierced him right through.

A foolish voice inside him whispered, “She never cared about you, never really saw you.” It mixed with the darker voice that told him, “You’re nothing, worthless, always will be.” It was the voice that echoed the bullies’ taunts, his own doubts, and the weight of all the unspoken words. In that moment, something inside Tom snapped cleanly in two.

The next morning, news rippled through town: Sarah’s prized mare was found loose, having broken through her fence during the night. Whispers turned to accusations, and the accusing eyes landed on Tom. It didn’t matter that it was foolish, that he gained nothing from the act. They already had their villain.

Image created by Author

2.5 The Breaking Point

They didn’t come with torches and pitchforks, not like in the old stories. They came in a tidy group: the sheriff, Harlan with a fresh bruise under his eye, and a few of the town elders. Tom stood on his porch, Rusty slumped with resignation at his feet, and felt a strange hollowness within. It wasn’t fear, nor defiance, just the exhaustion of having fought a battle he was destined to lose.

“Tom, we aren’t going to mince words,” Sheriff Bill said, his voice flat. “You got a history with Sarah, a grudge. Mare turns up loose… well, folks are talking.”

He tried to protest, but the words lodged in his throat, coming out as strangled pleas of innocence no one believed. Each denial was met with a tightening of lips, a hardening of eyes. The levee holding back his desperation crumbled, the floodgates crashing open.

“You think I’m stupid? Worthless?” he roared, surprising himself with the fury in his voice, “You been saying it my whole life! You don’t know me, none of you do!”

His hands balled Into fists, a lifetime of misunderstood rage trembling at the edge of violence. And then, just as quickly, it was gone. Replaced by a weariness so heavy that his shoulders slumped. He knew then, with absolute certainty, that it was over.

That evening, with a few belongings stuffed in a worn rucksack and Rusty trailing heartbroken behind him, Tom left. He walked towards the train tracks, towards anywhere but here. The wheat fields, once a symbol of his life, were now a suffocating reminder of all he’d lost. Perhaps out there, in the vastness of the world, he could finally, finally find a way to breathe.

--

--

Akr
Predict

Mental Health Writer and Everything in Between