People sometimes claim that the web and native apps are converging. I disagree. I think the process is more like chiasmus in the sense that we will end up with an app-like web and a web-like app ecosystem but they’ll still be different from each other. The two ecosystems will cross over but the results will have surprising new capabilities and unlock new metaphors for thinking about them.
In the meantime we are stuck in an uncanny valley where a lot of the PWAs people know are designed like Android apps rather than trying to be native to the web. One of my colleagues even wrote an article arguing that you should “start by forgetting everything you know about conventional web design, and instead imagine you’re actually designing a native app.”
That conceptual model would focus on the uniquely universal reach of the web rather than just what’s possible on high-end mobile devices. That’s because the first time the user visits your site may be on a desktop and if they get a bad experience they’re not going to click on links to your site when they turn up in search results or in a social media context. Even if the first visit happens on a mobile device it may be a low end device or on a flakey network so if they get a bad experience there they definitely won’t return in other contexts.
That conceptual model would emphasise URLs, linking to other people’s sites and reusing rather than reinventing browser features. For example native apps get Chrome Custom Tabs or SFSafariViewController which are great experiences that encourage linking to the rest of the web. Consequently their developers don’t have to worry about harming retention metrics because it’s just one click to get back. But we don’t yet have the equivalent for PWAs.
So, what do we call this new model? I think Jeremy Keith was right when he coined the phrase Progressive Web Sites because I believe that the best thing about PWAs is that they are part of the web. The trick is that they need to be good websites. This means that a good PWS should:
- use the PRPL pattern to ensure the fastest possible initial experience.
- take advantage of PWA techniques and technologies to give the user the best possible experience.
- be responsive so that any user on any device can access the site and get a good experience.
- be progressively enhanced because the set of capabilities that will be available on the user’s device are unknowable.
- link liberally and rely on the browser to provide features like sharing, window management and navigation.
- default to web-like design tropes and only make the effort to be app-like when it provides a clear benefit.
- focus on their own branding (whilst still being responsive to the constraints of the user’s context) rather than trying to fit into any given operating system’s guidelines.
In conclusion I think that most people should be building web-like websites rather than app-like websites. That’s because few sites are compelling enough that people will benefit from having instant access via their home screen. If you’re Twitter.com then a PWA is the right choice because millions of people want your icon on their homescreen, will launch it every day and want to use device capabilities (like the camera or notifications). However if you’re Oshineye.com then a PWS makes much more sense because even I don’t want it on my homescreen. Don’t think of this as a binary choice. Instead it’s a spectrum and you should choose your place on it based on:
- the nature of your traffic. If you depend on traffic from external links, have high bounce rates and low session-depth then you should be leaning towards PWS. If you have lots of direct traffic, low bounce rates and high session-depth then you should be leaning towards a PWA.
- the amount of resources you’re willing to invest. The less resource-constrained you are the more you should skew towards a PWA.
- the incremental ROI: If your incremental ROI is small then it doesn’t make sense to invest a lot. Given that a PWA is a bigger investment than a PWS you should default to PWS and only make the extra investment to build a PWA if you can clearly articulate the additional benefits you’ll get from it.
Originally published at blog.oshineye.com on June 18, 2017.