Thucydides 431 BCE

When Words Fail: The Breakdown of Dialogue and The Rise of Violence

From Corcyra to Capitol Hill: Political Violence Through the Ages

Walter Bowne
Publishous
Published in
12 min readOct 13, 2024

--

January 6th Capitol Attack and The Peloponnesian War (link). CanvaPro.

Civil War, Extremism, and the Lessons We Refuse to Learn

When a Country or an Empire is on the Cusp of Collapse, few ever realize what has happened in the past is happening, or will happen, now.

“That civil war happened in Greece! It’s nothing like the bombing of Fort Sumter. What bad could happen?”

In the midst of political fever, cooler heads rarely prevail. The fever, it seems, does not break until cities smolder in rubble with countless graves.

In Book Three of History of the Peloponnesian War (431 BCE), Thucydides, an Athenian general and historian, also considered “the father of the school of political realism,” considered the Civil War in Corcyra (now Corfu, an island off Greece’s northwest coast in the Ionian Sea) as a cautionary tale about the destructive nature of political extremism and factionalism.

After Herodotus, he is considered the Western world’s first historian. While many critics may question the veracity of Herodotus, few question the pin-point accuracy of Thucydides — an eyewitness…

--

--

Walter Bowne
Walter Bowne

Written by Walter Bowne

This “trophy husband” writes fiction, poetry, narrative non-fiction, travel essays, music essays, book reviews, and essays about his belly button.