Top Stories published by Rethinking Security in September of 2015

A Further Reflection on Killing and Breaking Things

EDIT: see this entry for an apology to the Major. I don’t feel that this was my best hour.

Beyond Maj. Cavanaugh’s distaste for violence and the notion of being seen as a killer and a breaker, he makes another…


The Purpose of the Military

EDIT: see this apology to the Major. I do not think that this was my best hour, and I’m sorry for that.

Critics will counter with Clausewitz, dismissing my argument as the naïve, “kind-hearted” words of someone that misguidedly believes there is “some…

One Last Take On The WOTR Piece

Both of the prior blogs struck a nerve and the Major had a rather surprising response for me online. At the Major’s request I have accepted his apology for his reaction and deleted my screenshot of the reaction from this blog post. Obviously, nothing on the Internet ever…


Power, Realism, and Romanticism

Niall Ferguson, in a (paywalled) piece, argues we need to relearn the lost arts of war and strategy. Readers may find this line of reasoning similar to that of my own here. I will dissent, however. There is a recent piece in Jacobin that I (for the first time) will…


The Denial of Destruction

I don’t really agree with Bruce Hoffman that ISIS/ISIL is “winning” but there is a lot here that makes profound sense.

It must start with the recognition that ISIL’s appeal will not diminish nor its allure end until this movement is militarily defeated and…

Punishment and Its Perils

At Marginal Revolution, there is an intriguing retrospective on the failure of “Broken Windows” crime policies:

Why did the experiment fail? Longer sentences didn’t reduce crime as much as expected because criminals aren’t good at thinking about the future…

Relentless Strike: Early Review

I got this book as a book on tape to listen to for the long commutes to GMU and back. I later heard of the controversy surrounding it only after beginning to listen to it. It has been very interesting, mostly for its no-frills presentation of the bureaucratic problems of…


Proxies and Operational Control

Good stuff at SWJ. In my opinion, this also depends a great deal on how much the patron’s aims are served by varying degrees of control and autonomy.

The US strategy of selecting reliable proxies against the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS)…

Early Review: The Last Warrior

Despite what I’ve said about Andrew Marshall hagiography, I do believe that the guy truly was a genius. So I’m going to recommend picking up this new biography of Marshall’s intellectual journey. A full review may come later, but for now just do it The book is a great tour…

About
Rethinking Security
Rethinking Security is a blog on states, communities, and organizations in conflict by Adam Elkus. Older content can be found at rethinkingsecurity.tumblr.com, this blog’s last incarnation. Header image is trademark of Introversion/Ambrosia software (DEFCON game).
More information
Tags
Editors