Blog Post #1

In the selected chapters from the books Hal and Me by Nicholas Carr and The Rise of the Centaurs by Clive Thompson, both authors put an emphasis on the impact that modern technology, specifically computers, has on society and more importantly their individual thought processes. Both begin with stories related to the societal effect of computer developments, Carr choosing to focus on a chess tournament while Thompson summarizing the ending of a famed science fiction movie. However, they take up opposing viewpoints through the rest of their excerpts. Thompson explains how computers have enhanced life in that external memory allows for better and more recording of memories; increased creativity; and more connections between people and other technology. Contradicting Thompson, Carr lists all of the negative impacts he has noticed from technology, most notably a shortened attention span and a lowered savings account balance. He describes, “when I mention my troubles with reading to my friends, many say they’re suffering from similar afflictions” (Hal and Me) in order to broaden his research. Similarly, both authors incorporate a combination of in-text quotes and scarce word quotes, though Thompson tends to include more academic-themed references while Carr’s supporting quotes come more from his peers’ personal experiences. Thompson finishes his chapter with the conclusion that when we’re augmenting ourselves, we can be smarter” (The Rise of the Centaurs) to affirm his belief that technology has had a positive impact on our culture. On the opposite end of the spectrum, Thompson rounds out his section with a reference back to a pre-technology dominated time by saying “I miss my old brain” (Hal and Me). Together, these authors use a similar layout and structure to prove their opposing viewpoints to the intended audience.