How Unreliable Memories of Your Past Shape Your Present

Memories are unreliable, but that’s what makes them so useful

More To That
Aug 26 · 9 min read
Illustrations: More To That

Sometimes a moment feels so significant that you’re acutely aware of its importance as it’s happening.

Maybe you’re celebrating the start of a relationship:

Or you’re grieving the end of a long one:

Perhaps you just got an offer call from your dream job:

Or you’re devastated by the news that you’re being laid off from one:

These types of events carry strong emotional charges, and the power of those emotions can seem blinding. That excitement you feel when you first meet a potential partner can color your days and weeks, while the sadness you experience from a break-up feels all-encompassing as well.

When life moments are blanketed by the texture of these emotions, it can seem like they will persist forever. No matter how many times you’re told “all things shall pass,” the strength of those feelings is so powerful that it’s difficult to imagine them ever becoming a distant memory.

But, inevitably, the constant of time breaks the illusion of permanence.

Time is powerful, not just because it distances the present from the past.

Time’s greatest power lies in its ability to turn us into historians of our lives.

History is largely an exercise in reflection, and reflection is an exercise in zooming out to see the broader landscape. With the aid of time, we can survey any given event from our past objectively, without the intense emotional charge that originally accompanied it.

So what was once an emotionally blinding event…

…becomes a fainter dome of light…

…revealing itself to be one small node…

in a vast landscape of connected nodes, all leading to the present moment:

From this distance, you can start viewing your life as a series of jagged ups and downs connected by various events that were once emotionally poignant. Approaching your life as a historian makes it easier to be an observer of these events rather than getting caught up in them. Sometimes more time is required before you can zoom out — and some events, particularly deep trauma, might never disconnect from the emotions that accompanied them — but for most memories, there will come a point where you can start reflecting on even the most difficult ones with some kind of objectivity.

What you will then notice is that, in this trail of light, certain nodes shine brighter than others. Sometimes these nodes represent the point in which a downward trend shifted upward — or vice versa — or they might just show up in seemingly random places along your path.

I call these bright lights your pivotal nodes. They represent the events that were critical in shaping the narrative of your existence.

Many things have happened in your life but, chances are, the number of pivotal nodes is small. Having a life with 50 pivotal nodes is like watching a film with 50 plotlines; it’s trying so hard to be cool but ultimately makes little sense. Humans are story-driven creatures, and the telltale sign of a sensible story is that it keeps the crucial details and discards the rest. The hardest part of making a documentary is not collecting the endless hours of footage, but how it’s all pieced together to tell a compelling 90-minute narrative.

Our lives are defined by our pivotal nodes, and when we zoom out to see them all in one place, we can see the shared anatomy between them.

What you’ll find is that each pivotal node has two components:

  1. The circular core, which represents the factual detail of the event.
  2. The surrounding light, which embodies the feeling associated with it.

Each pivotal node is imbued with both fact and feeling, and one cannot exist without the other.

The core of the node (the facts of an experience) are the objective details of what happened. A core may be formed because you were fired from your job, or your partner said that thing to you, or you performed a song for the first time, etc. These facts are the nucleus around which feelings and emotions accumulate. Given enough resonance and impact, they can become a pivotal node.

The thing about these facts, however, is that they have to be recalled via working memory. And if there’s anything we know about memory, it’s that it’s terrible. An event that was so lucid and clear a few days ago can become a forgotten shadow in a matter of weeks, months, or years.

On the day of a gut-wrenching break-up, you may have been able to recount every single detail of it to a friend:

Only to find that, a decade later, you’ve forgotten almost everything about how it happened:

Because the passage of time makes memory unclear, in order to recall these facts, we tend to direct our attention to its emotional texture instead. The echo of emotion produced from the memory ends up becoming a surrogate for the memory itself. You may have forgotten that hurtful thing your aunt said to you years ago, but you sure as hell remember how upset you felt upon hearing it.

This feeling associated with an event is represented by the light surrounding the core of the node. Some lights shine brighter than others, but not because the event itself was more surprising, intense, or life-changing. It’s because we assign higher degrees of emotional weight to some events, and not to others. Getting that job at a dream company may be a life-changing event for one person, and a humdrum one for another.

It’s our interpretation of the event that gives it its impact, and allows it to direct the trail of subsequent events.

But, just like our recollection of facts, our recollection of feelings is also ever-changing. When you’ve zoomed out far enough, you’ll notice that some pivotal nodes with an initially negative texture ended up creating a path that trended upward (positively). That layoff you experienced felt horrible when it happened, but it may have led you to a different line of work that you are so passionate about today.

The same holds true the other way around: A pivotal node with an initially positive feeling may have created a path that trended downward (negatively). That dream job you always wanted may have morphed into your worst nightmare, requiring all your attention and separating you from your family in the process.

What this reveals is that the emotions we assign to events in the moment are often unreliable. While we think we desire certain outcomes, it’s impossible for us to know whether they will create a trail of nodes that ultimately lead the “right” way. When we live a results-driven life, we are focused solely on what we think we want now, ignoring what hindsight will likely reveal to us later.

Deathbed regrets are the embodiment of this shortsightedness, and sadly, they are much too commonplace:

Reviewing our personal histories shows that our recollection of facts can be shaky, and our assessment of our feelings is always changing. However, so many of the narratives we create about ourselves rely upon these two crude intuitions.

Many of your earliest memories lay the foundation of who you are today, and how you act toward others. Perhaps you have a pleasant memory of your grandmother smiling warmly at you, feeding you a snack that you’ve loved ever since. This may have become a cornerstone moment that shaped how you treat elders.

Or conversely, you may have a difficult memory where you recall your second-grade classmates laughing at you for bringing food from your culture for lunch. This may have made you feel ashamed of your cultural upbringing, and caused you to bend away from it.

These pivotal nodes guide so many of the subsequent perspectives in your life, but it’s quite possible that they’re neither as accurate or poignant as you thought they were. Maybe your grandma was actually annoyed at you for crying so much, and flashed you a strained smile to get you to eat that snack. Or those second-grade classmates were actually jealous that their lunches weren’t as interesting, and wanted to make you feel bad to mask their insecurities.

However, even if you knew that the facts weren’t accurate, the light of the emotion can still remain. The pivotal node can continue to shine, even if its core has revealed itself to be a shadow of what you thought it was.

This is where the depth of feeling can supersede the reality of fact. While this can be helpful in some cases (the example of the smiling grandma being just one of them), there are many moments where it can be harmful. Holding onto the emotional texture of memories can lead you towards some destructive behaviors or decisions. You might hold that grudge against your sister for something she said years ago, even if you no longer remember what exactly it was. Or you might be scared to put your art out there because one critic said you sucked, even though that critic thinks that everything sucks.

It’s convenient when our pivotal nodes line up in such a way that a nice narrative arc can be drawn, but drawing this arc means that we’re committing to a story anchored by shaky facts and feelings. We might end up holding onto a life story with all our might, even if many of the details are faulty and no longer serve our continued growth.

Observing the landscape of experiences allows you to see that some pivotal nodes have a shaded core, kept relevant only by the light surrounding it. As the core of the node — the factual details — fade, it leaves behind an artifact of feeling that takes its place, allowing the memory to hold its ground.

But as you live your life, it’s important to observe which of these artifacts you’re still letting drive the decisions you make today. Knowing that the feelings associated with memories are in flux, are you okay with constructing a worldview based on ever-changing inputs? Which nodes no longer contribute to the way you view yourself and others today?

Being a historian of your life isn’t just about reflection, it’s also about reframing. Surveying the landscape of your life experiences is just the prologue to the main exercise, which is deciding which nodes to highlight and which ones to reevaluate. Some memories that were once so crucial and pivotal to your development may no longer serve you, but only you can dim them.

This applies to the present moment as well. Whether you’re currently going through a rough patch or having the time of your life, you can take a minute to pause and reflect on the texture of this experience. There’s a power in knowing that, one day, the details of this event will fade and the emotions associated with it may change. This awareness allows you to choose which moments are to be held closely, and which ones can slowly fade away into the crevasses of the mind.

Written by

Join the More To That email list and never miss a post: https://moretothat.com/subscribe

More To That
More To That
More To That

About this Collection

More To That

Each member of humanity carries a unique story — a one-of-a-kind fingerprint with a narrative that simply cannot be replicated. But when you take over 7.5 billion of these stories and cram them all into this blue and green rock called Earth, you are bound to get some shared patterns and themes that emerge. More To That is an exploration into some of these connected themes, using odd illustrations and characters to delve into the root of what makes humanity so fascinating. Life as a human is a weird experience, so let's take some time to dive into it together.

Each member of humanity carries a unique story — a one-of-a-kind fingerprint with a narrative that simply cannot be replicated. But when you take over 7.5 billion of these stories and cram them all into this blue and green rock called Earth, you are bound to get some shared patterns and themes that emerge. More To That is an exploration into some of these connected themes, using odd illustrations and characters to delve into the root of what makes humanity so fascinating. Life as a human is a weird experience, so let's take some time to dive into it together.

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade