What is Loving-Kindness?

And how to practice it in an era of intolerance

Sharon Salzberg
Feb 28, 2018 · 6 min read
Photo by Soroush Karimi on Unsplash

Listen to this story



It seems that now more than ever, we’re living in the era of “us vs. them,” primed to think of others — especially those who are different or who disagree with us — as separate from and alien to us, as “other.”

We are born into communities of race, language, ethnicity, state/country/region, gender, religion…the list goes on. It is powerful to reflect upon where we anchor our sense of belonging, and whether that has largely been imposed upon us by stories others tell about us or is something we ourselves utilize for courage and self-respect. And it is powerful to look at where security fits into this reflection and risk-taking, willingness, or interest in stretching the boundaries of our identifications.

If we look at ourselves through the lens of various outward and social categories, we can also look at intersectionality and the multifaceted lives we each deal with every day. The Buddha said, “Within this fathom long body, lies the entire universe.” I certainly resonate with that statement as I look at my own life — one made up of both privilege and vulnerabilities, manifold gifts and terrible losses — my life has encompassed so much, and every aspect of my experience plays a part in who I know myself to be. This is a doorway to a truth of belonging to a bigger picture of life that doesn’t come from or fit on any single label, though each can be recognized.

Without this larger picture of life, we often tumble into the loneliness that our society so readily fosters. There are currently 42.6 million Americans over the age of 45 who report suffering from loneliness, a situation that’s verging on a health epidemic. Consumer culture is part of the cause, for we are inundated with messages that not only should we want more things — better things — but also that we need them and that what we have is who we are. As we are learning, brands are literally designing their products to require replacement and to fuel revenue. We have been tricked by advertising to think things can bring us happiness, that our homes need to look a certain way or have certain décor for us to be worthy. So instead of connecting on a personal level, we form our most meaningful connections with screens and numbers that represent our worth.

Children aren’t immune to this suffering, either. According to a November 2017 study, children who have more toys have a lesser quality of play, are less creative, and more distracted (cue ADD). Millennials are raised to nourish virtual “friendships” on social media with people they never talk to — or with whom, when they do get together in person, they are hooked to their phones the whole time. The very nature of friendship has changed from one of connection to one of transaction.

Yet at the same time, none of this is new. Thinking of our world and immediate surroundings in terms of “me vs. you” or “us vs. them” isn’t unique to any particular political or cultural context. It’s evolutionary, as well as a byproduct of powerful and ongoing conditioning. As kids, we’re raised in an individualistic culture that teaches us to think of survival as triumphing over others because “there’s not enough to go around.” We often even think of our own pain and suffering as “other” — something to repress or turn away from. And ironically, we often end up feeling further alienated, compartmentalized, and disconnected as a result.

We have the chance, though, to step beyond the strictures of habit and see ourselves as fundamentally interdependent with all beings. This takes time, and intentionality brings us back to conditioning. A major reason for this is that we’re often conditioned to see kindness as a soft virtue, rather than as a powerful force.

I think back to when I published my first book, Lovingkindness, in 1995. I remember feeling a deep sense of worry that people would misjudge the book as being “sweet” or “sentimental,” because those are definitely qualities we associate with words like “loving” and “kindness.” But in reality, the practice of loving-kindness is about cultivating love as a strength, a muscle, a tool that challenges our tendency to see people (including ourselves) as disconnected, statically and rigidly isolated from one another. Loving-kindness is about opening ourselves up to others with compassion and equanimity, which is a challenging exercise, requiring us to push back against assumptions, prejudices, and labels that most of us have internalized. That’s why I’ve been teaching loving-kindness for all of these years.

A study examined in a New York Times article from 2008 entitled “Tolerance Over Race Can Spread” showed that mutual trust can catch on and spread between racial groups just as quickly as suspicion can. How amazing to think that our minds can become conditioned to trust others as much as they have been to veer toward hatred.

As scientist Emma Seppala puts it, our valuing of experience, especially shared experience with nourishing people, has been lost; we’ve forgotten the simple fact that “altruistic acts, in addition to making this world a better place for those you serve, also lead to the greatest levels of fulfillment. Not just for yourself but observers are inspired. They, in turn, are more likely to help others.” This becomes a virtuous cycle that helps remake our own lives and truly can affect the world.

Loving-kindness Meditation

Loving-kindness meditation is a practice that can help dissolve the rigid labels of “us vs. them.” It requires a willingness to stretch our attention and cultivate curiosity around our habitual ways of looking at ourselves and others.

Rather than use the breath as an anchor for our attention, loving-kindness practices uses the repetition of certain phrases to express our wish that we — ourselves and all beings — be happy, peaceful, healthy and strong. Traditionally, phrases like “May I be safe,” “be happy,” “be healthy,” and “live with ease” are used, but feel free to experiment with these phrases or replace them altogether. Some common alternatives are “May I be peaceful,” or “May I be filled with loving-kindness,” or “May I have ease of heart.” Do keep in mind that the phrases must be general and open enough to be universal blessings or offerings. Loving-kindness isn’t about goal-setting (“May I win a fellowship” or “get a raise”), but about practicing what it would feel like to have an unconditional generosity of spirit with wishes that are enduring and deep.

The traditional progression of loving-kindness practice is that you begin by offering phrases of loving-kindness to yourself, and then move outward to others with whom you have varying degrees of separation and difficulty. After ourselves, we offer loving-kindness to someone we respect, admire, or are grateful for; then to a friend; then to a “neutral” person, such as a shop clerk or stranger in the grocery line; then to a person who we find challenging; and finally, all beings.

Below are more detailed instructions for the practice. Loving-kindness has been scientifically proven to help us be less hard on ourselves while at the same time increasing our capacity for empathy. We have more choice than we think, and we can be authors of new stories about ourselves and how we relate to others and the world.

Guidelines for Loving-Kindness Meditation

  1. Sit comfortably, with eyes closed or in a soft gaze — however you feel most at ease. Set a timer, using an app or alarm, for how long you plan to sit. If you are newer to meditation, I suggest five to 10 minutes. Choose three to four loving-kindness phrases, and begin to repeat them silently to yourself.
  2. Repeat the phrases slowly to create a calm, steady rhythm. This is a practice of paying attention in a deep way, so gather your attention on one phrase at a time. You may find it helpful to coordinate your breaths with the silent repetition of the phrases you’ve chosen, or simply rest your attention on the phrases.
  3. Note that there are no “shoulds” — there is no right way to feel and no need to generate a special feeling. The power of the practice is about being present with each phrase and willing to pay attention to ourselves in new, though perhaps challenging ways.
  4. Remember that this is a practice of generosity and openness — not one of insistence or affirmation. If you notice your attention wandering or your mind becoming fixated on a thought, try letting the distraction go and returning to the repetition of phrases. Try not to worry if it happens a lot.
  5. When you feel ready, you can open your eyes.

Sharon Salzberg

Written by

Sharon Salzberg is a central figure in the field of meditation, a world-renowned teacher and New York Times bestselling author. www.SharonSalzberg.com

Redefining Real Love
Redefining Real Love
Redefining Real Love

About this Collection

Redefining Real Love

What happens when we see love as a capacity within ourselves, rather than in the hands of someone else to bestow upon or take away from us? What happens as we experience love as a powerful force, rather than the weakening, sentimental, compliant quality many of us have been taught? This series will contain practical, thoughtful recommendations for owning your path to Real Love.

What happens when we see love as a capacity within ourselves, rather than in the hands of someone else to bestow upon or take away from us? What happens as we experience love as a powerful force, rather than the weakening, sentimental, compliant quality many of us have been taught? This series will contain practical, thoughtful recommendations for owning your path to Real Love.

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade