Said Differently

Said Differently is a home for unorthodox thinking that challenges lazy consensus views. Are you a careful observer and a clear thinker? You can help cut through the confusion by pointing out what the experts get wrong.

Member-only story

GOVERNMENT AS MARKETING

No Soda For Poors

The current push to eliminate soda from SNAP benefits isn’t for anyone’s benefit except Big Food and Beverage companies

8 min readMar 26, 2025

--

overweight woman in an armchair drinking soda and eating chips
Overweight woman in armchair by Ljupco Smokovski, licensed from Adobe Stock

There’s been a recent flurry of right-wing politicians and influencers calling for soda to be banned for purchase by people who use SNAP benefits, more commonly called “Food Stamps.”

This seems like a clear case of a marketing campaign and consumer ripoff concealed as contempt for poor people.

Left-wing influencers say that SNAP recipients, aka poor people, should be allowed to purchase foods and beverages of their choice with their benefits, while right-wingers say that “the taxpayer dollar shouldn’t pay for non-essentials for aid recipients.”

The lone libertarian representative, ultra right-winger Thomas Massie, joined in on the chorus. Libertarians believe in their personal rights above all else. In this case, Massie believes that taxpayers should have a “say” in how recipients spend “their” tax dollars. Ordinarily, one might think that libertarians would say that people should be able to buy anything they want with their money. But Massie apparently doesn’t consider SNAP benefits to belong to the individual recipient, but rather to the “taxpayer.”

--

--

Said Differently
Said Differently

Published in Said Differently

Said Differently is a home for unorthodox thinking that challenges lazy consensus views. Are you a careful observer and a clear thinker? You can help cut through the confusion by pointing out what the experts get wrong.

Amy Sterling Casil
Amy Sterling Casil

Written by Amy Sterling Casil

Over 500 million views and 5 million published words, top writer in health and social media. Author of 50 books, former exec, Nebula nominee.

Responses (3)