Science and Critical Thinking

In the post-truth age, we are awash with many dubious claims; gods, ghosts, aliens, conspiracies, and other mysterious things. Here we strive to work out what is really true and what is sincerly belived but is just a myth.

Member-only story

Scientific “Proof”: Non Religious people are evil

David Gamble
Science and Critical Thinking
8 min readJan 22, 2025

--

Allegory with a portrait of a Venetian senator is a 1580s painting by Jacopo Tintoretto. It depicts the morality of earthly things.

Sociologist Philip Truscott of Southwest Baptist University has published a “scientific” paper titled “Rape, Suicide, and the Rise of Religious Nones. Within it he argues that being non-religious makes you far more probably a rapist and also prone to suicide.

Spoiler: Don’t panic, his paper is pure BS, and the “journal” he has published it in, “the journal of sociology and christianity“. It is not an unbiased source.

OK, let’s dive right into it.

The Abstract

It reads (yes sorry, it is long)…

One of the most widely quoted concepts in late twentieth century criminology was the general theory of crime which proposed that insufficiency of self-control is the most important predictor of criminal behavior. The presence or absence of social bonds promoting self-control is an important element of this theory. This article argues that the decline of one important societal bond, religious affiliation, is impacting the incidence of rape. Since the 2010s, there has been a positive correlation between the proportion of the population declaring no religious affiliation (the “None” rate) in the 50 USA states and the campus rape rate. This correlation was significant in the four years from 2016 (r=0.464, p. 0.001) to 2019 (r=0.393, p. 0.005). Beginning in 2018…

--

--

Science and Critical Thinking
Science and Critical Thinking

Published in Science and Critical Thinking

In the post-truth age, we are awash with many dubious claims; gods, ghosts, aliens, conspiracies, and other mysterious things. Here we strive to work out what is really true and what is sincerly belived but is just a myth.

David Gamble
David Gamble

Written by David Gamble

Blogger and writer with a keen interest in science, skepticism, critical thinking, and many other weird and whacky topics.

Responses (13)