How can we make a better decision of “Death Penalty.”?

There are two people who wait to watch a hockey game in front of a bar. One person, Newt, wears a big, floppy, black sweater, and drinks a beer. Another person, Dwayne, reads a newspaper, especially the business section. Suddenly, breaking news comes on the TV to announce the government is going to implement a “Death Penalty in New York.” All of a sudden, they get very serious and they ignore the game and start to talk about the death penalty.

A: “Seriously? It’s ridiculous! Can you believe it?” Newt bellowed.

B: “Um… I think it’s the right way to protect the nation. Why are you so upset? I know what you think of that but… the government is making a big decision to protect us from criminals. They killed and threatened lots of people, even children,” Dwayne commented causally.

A: “What? Do you think they kill the criminals for us? Humans can’t judge humans. It is not different than a M-U-R-D-E-R. They try to kill the people under the guise of law,” she exclaimed harshly.

B: “Yes, but those reasons are not enough to keep all criminals in jail for their whole life,” he answered adamantly.

A: “Sorry?.. We are humans. We can make mistakes sometimes. How can they fix it when they already killed an innocent person?” she objected sarcastically.

B: “Oh… it’s not true, it does not happen,” he explained meekly.

A: “No, we have to give them a second chance to regret their mistakes themselves. They are sick, it’s a kind of disease,” she asserted sadly.

B: “I agree with you but we already know that “two wrongs don’t make a right,” he noted softly.

A: …

B: “Newt, the government doesn't have enough tax money to keep criminals. It costs more than $39 billion a year. We can help other people who really want help. For example, orphans, starving people, the homeless, and someone who needs a cure,” he responded tenderly.

A: “Yes, I know Dwayne. I mean we have an alternative solution like life sentences. It could be hard but if we don’t give up, we can find a better idea than we have now,” she announced thoughtfully.

C: “Excuse me, guys! I don’t want to interrupt but you look so serious. I think that it is quite a hard question. Nobody can make a decision easily because it is a controversial topic. And time is up!! Let’s go to watch the game! We are losing now. YOLO!” the bartender blurted energetically.

Show your support

Clapping shows how much you appreciated Nanhee Park’s story.