Sitemap
Slackjaw

Medium humor. Large laughs.

Member-only story

FOR LOVE OR PEANUT BUTTER

Casual Sex Was Never For Me: A Case Study

I Called An Audible And My End Zone Became The Red Zone

8 min readApr 16, 2025

--

Photo by Tony Heally on Unsplash / FLOPB art by Kelly Shanley

Years ago when I was online dating, I mean yeeeears ago, when it was just OkCupid and Plenty of Fish and they were still websites you perused on your laptop, I matched with a guy named Brad.

Brad was very hot. He was a tall athletic white guy with brown hair and blue eyes and a great physique. He could have been a stand in for Channing Tatum, no joke. I wasn’t feeling particularly confident about my looks those days so when Brad matched me and then sent me a message, I was both excited and in a slight state of disbelief.

Before you say it, no, Brad was not a catfish, but I understand you going there since that’s what happened the last time I matched with someone I felt was out of my league. You can read that one here, it’s a fun one.

Brad seemed exceptionally nice for how hot he was. It probably didn’t hurt that I had opened our conversation with a question about the current 49ers roster. He was wearing a 49ers hat in his profile pic and I happen to be a huge Niner fan myself, so it was an easy conversation starter that got me an invite to come watch the playoffs at his house.

--

--

Kelly Shanley
Kelly Shanley

Written by Kelly Shanley

LA based writer/podcaster/comedian/mountain girl at heart. Outdoor lover, world traveler, loud laugher. https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/kelly-shanley

Responses (2)