When Social Media Goes Quiet: A Marketing Strategy Guide Using the ‘5 Whys’

A Previous Case Study from the Smarketer GTM Strategy Lab Weekly Newsletter

A few weeks ago in our Smarketer GTM Strategy Lab newsletter, we tackled a perplexing issue that many brands face — the sudden silence of social media metrics. Today, we’re revisiting that case study to share a detailed analysis and my go-to method for solving such conundrums.

The Case Study Sent to My Subscribers: The Curious Case of The Sluggish Social Media

Once the talk of the digital town, Bella’s Boutique, a much-loved online jewelry store, has been facing a social media slump over the past quarter:

1. Instagram’s follower growth shrunk from 25% to a meagre 5%
2. Facebook reach took a 20% hit
3. Grumbles about shipping delays shot up by 15%

What’s more interesting is this lull coincided with the introduction of a new social media maestro and switching from an in-house to an outsourced video content creation model. Yet, Bella’s Boutique still manages to outshine its rivals on the social media battleground.

Key Questions Asked

1. What’s causing Bella’s Boutique’s social media to crawl?
2. What additional intel could help put the finger on the pain points?
3. How can the new social media hotshot handle the rising tide of negative comments?
4. What’s your game plan to put the zing back into their social media growth?

The Framework: Why ‘5 Whys’ is Your New Best Friend

Before we dive into the nitty-gritty, let’s talk about frameworks. Trust me; you don’t want to tackle a problem without a game plan. The ‘5 Whys’ is your roadmap to problem-solving. It helps you get to the core of the issue. Let’s put it to use.

• Why did growth slow? Maybe the new strategy wasn’t as cool as everyone thought.
• Why did the strategy fail? Not enough testing. Rookie mistake.
• Why wasn’t there enough testing? The new manager might have been a bit out of their depth.
• Why the hurry? No one was on the same page about goals. Yikes!
• Why the confusion? Leadership was missing in action during the transition.

The Comeback: Three Steps to Social Media Stardom

1. Optimize Content: Don’t just throw content out there. Test it, refine it, and make sure it vibes with each platform’s algorithm.
2. Engage, Engage, Engage: Respond to comments, dish out deals, and find influencers who fit your brand like a glove.
3. Strategy Reset: Get those KPIs in check. Stay agile, and don’t be afraid to venture into new platforms.

Wrapping Up: Your Marketing Strategy Makeover

With a focus on data-driven decisions and genuine community engagement, Bella’s could reign supreme once again. Remember, the key to unlocking your potential lies in strategic thinking and a killer framework like the ‘5 Whys.’

Feeling inspired? Visit smarketer.in to subscribe to my newsletter for more weekly wisdom from the Smarketer GTM Strategy Lab to help you slay in the business game.