What is a Speaking Indictment?

A speaking indictment is a formal accusation in a criminal case that goes beyond the bare minimum requirements. While a typical indictment just lays out the charges, a speaking indictment includes additional details about the alleged wrongdoing. This can involve things like:

• Specifics about the time, date, and location of the crime
• A narrative describing the defendant’s actions
• Evidence that supports the charges

There are pros and cons to speaking indictments. Prosecutors argue they give the defendant a clearer picture of the accusations against them, making it easier to prepare a defense. They can also be a way to pre-empt certain defense strategies. However, critics argue they can be prejudicial by putting out a lot of negative information before a trial, and they can be misused to essentially try the case in the media before it goes to court.

United States vs. Donald Trump Speaking Indictment

Mueller's 'speaking indictments' offer clues to strategy