Detailed Analysis: MLB’s Uniform Problems With Nike

Michael Ma
SportsBizInsights
Published in
3 min readMar 26, 2024

In 2019, Majestic Athletic, a subsidiary of mainstream clothing brand Fanatics, the official on-field uniform of the MLB, was replaced by Nike. The company has been the official sponsor of MLB since 2005. Yet, MLB ditched the brand to sign a 10-year deal with Nike so it could become the league’s official on-field uniform and apparel designer. Consequently, Nike started developing City Connect jerseys that are alternate options with bolder designs and color schemes. Therefore, Nike matches MLB’s new vision of making bold moves and advancements.

For example, the Washington Nationals feature a pink color scheme plus a cherry blossom to resemble D.C’s famous cherry blossom trees. In 2023, they unveiled their newest design at the 2023 MLB All-Star Game in Seattle, the Nike Vapor Premier, which received positive feedback from players like Nolan Arenado. However, the 2024 Spring Training has brought some new problems, ranging from a pants shortage to uncomfortable jerseys, leading to players complaining about the new uniforms designed by Nike. As a result, Nike’s recent difficulties to provide quality uniforms for the MLB has received severe backlash, illustrating that not all changes in business are positive.

The Washington Nationals City Connect Jersey features a pink design with cherry blossoms. (Source: theathletic.com)

However, MLB officials state the new uniforms improve mobility by providing 25% more stretch and also will dry 28% faster. Also, The lettering, sleeve emblems, and numbering are less bulky to make uniforms more breathable and comfortable. Accordingly, there are new features players enjoy with the Nike Vapor Premier jerseys, such as the lightweight feeling. Therefore, the new uniforms seemed a great success until the discovery that some pants are relatively see-through, allowing fans to see undergarments. The whole fiasco is an business blunder for Nike and Fanatics, the current distributor of uniforms for MLB, since it makes both companies seem cheap and unreliable, hurting their brand reputation with the public. As a result, they might see sales decline with their baseball fanbase because of the distracting uniforms.

A portrait of Shohei Ohtani and Yoshinibuo Yamamoto showcasing how the new white pants are see-through. (Source: dailyhive.com)

With Opening Day, March 28th, being less than a week away for most MLB teams, there is a legitimate concern that all teams may not receive new uniforms since there are distribution problems. As a result, The San Diego Padres used last year’s white pants in their spring training opener. Similarly, other teams will probably wear last year’s pants until the problem is fixed by Nike and Fanatics. Still, there are different perspectives on the situation, with Joe Musgrove shaking off the controversy by stating that the pants are the least of the worries this spring, according to foxsports.com.

Overall, the MLB will have to figure out a solution for the pants sooner rather than later. Still, the criticism for the pants resembles the backlash MLB had last year for implementing new rules, such as the pitch clock and making the bases bigger. Yet, despite early criticism of the rule changes, the initiative is widely regarded as an unparalleled success in decades. Musgrove’s response to the situation represents how players will eventually view the pants after adapting to the problem. Ultimately, the new uniform design illuminates MLB’s ambition to make the game more popular with younger audiences and capture a larger fanbase.

--

--