ESG Promises to Carbon-Cutting Progress
Corporate Climate Action Drives Economic Growth at the 2024 Aspen Ideas Festival
Companies might be downplaying ESG these days, but private capital and corporate commitments continue to play a crucial role in driving the transition to a lower-carbon economy.
The companies and countries that meet the world’s growing energy demands with clean and renewable options not only gain a competitive advantage, but also help improve environmental sustainability.
At the 2024 Aspen Ideas Festival, five key themes emerged:
- Accelerating Transition, Significant Opportunities — The transition to a lower-carbon economy is gaining momentum, thanks to both its necessity and economic potential. Increased recognition of AI’s energy requirements highlights the importance of infrastructure development for countries and companies seeking a competitive edge.
- Driving Progress through Partnerships and Policy — Multi-stakeholder collaboration and public-private partnerships are essential to accelerate the transition. Effective policy and regulatory frameworks play a pivotal role in catalyzing change.
- Addressing Social Justice and Global Equity — Ensuring an equitable transition requires supporting developing countries and integrating gender equality and human rights considerations into climate solutions.
- Falling Costs, Increasing Feasibility — Innovations in clean technologies are reducing costs and driving adoption. Favorable unit economics make embracing clean technologies and climate solutions attractive to businesses and customers.
- Adapting to Climate Impacts, Scaling Up Efforts — As severe weather events and climate impacts intensify, adaptation and resilience become critical. The transition demands a sense of urgency and large-scale action to address the climate crisis effectively.
Below we’ve summarized the highlights of the three panels:
Learn more about the 2024 Aspen Ideas Festival and how to access additional insights.
Pushback: The Perils (and Power) of Corporate Commitments
This session brought together leaders from the business and political arenas to discuss the evolving landscape of corporate social responsibility and the pushback against Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) initiatives. The panel featured Tom Wilson, CEO of Allstate; Lata Reddy, Senior Vice President of Inclusion at Prudential Financial; Pablo Koziner, Chief Commercial Officer of GE Vernova; and Jared Polis, Governor of Colorado.
Navigating the ESG Landscape
Moderator Judy Samuelson of the Aspen Institute framed the discussion by acknowledging the growing pushback against corporate ESG commitments. She highlighted the polarization around these issues and questioned how companies balance long-term societal impacts with immediate business returns.
Governor Jared Polis emphasized the intersection of government initiatives and corporate goals, specifically referencing Colorado’s ambitious environmental targets that aim for 80% renewable energy by 2030 and 100% by 2040.
If (companies) can be located in Colorado and have a cleaner grid, they need less offsets. So that’s a potential competitive advantage.
Corporate Voices and the Pushback
Tom Wilson, CEO of Allstate, addressed the balancing act that corporations must perform. They must do a good job for customers, take care of employees and provide them with opportunities, make money for shareholders, and improve communities where they operate. Wilson argued that the backlash against ESG and Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives often overlooks the fundamental role these play in business strategy.
Wilson highlighted Allstate’s proactive approach to ESG, including their investment strategy that aligns with societal goals such as reducing carbon emissions.
Our view is we get paid as investors to do things that society wants if you do them well. Society wants less carbon in the environment so we’re going to help do that, and by doing that we’re going to make money.
Inclusion and Long-term Growth
Lata Reddy of Prudential Financial shared insights on how the company’s long-standing commitment to societal issues is integral to its business model. Prudential’s focus on financial inclusion aims to make their products accessible to a broader segment of the population.
We’re trying to expand the definition of who a viable customer is to a financial services firm like ours.
She also addressed the evolving internal conversations within Prudential, noting an increase in polarization. She emphasized the importance of staying true to the company’s core mission amid external pressures.
Energy Transition and Corporate Collaboration
Pablo Koziner from GE Vernova discussed the opportunities for companies that play a role in the global energy transition.
We have 75,000 employees that are squarely focused on electrifying and decarbonizing energy in a moment that is almost unprecedented in terms of the growth that we’re seeing in these markets.
Koziner highlighted the need for robust partnerships between governments, corporations, and other stakeholders to achieve ambitious energy goals. He talked about the need for policy that enables companies to move with speed, investments in innovation, and public-private partnerships.
How can we be bold and responsible? How can we enable all of the stuff that we need by working together and bringing in other key partners so that as we grow, everyone benefits.
The Role of Leadership
The discussion also touched on the importance of leadership in navigating these complex issues. Wilson shared an example of Allstate’s initiative to work exclusively with minority-owned firms for a bond deal, challenging the status quo in the financial markets.
You just got to decide and go. I think leadership is about getting other people to willingly go someplace they wouldn’t go by themselves.
Governor Polis concluded by reflecting on the role of public confidence and effective management in addressing divisive social issues, suggesting that effective politicians could offer valuable insights to the corporate sector.
Conclusion
This panel at the Aspen Ideas Festival underscored the necessity for corporations to maintain their commitments to ESG and DEI principles despite political and social pushback. The leaders agreed that these commitments are not just ethical imperatives but are crucial for long-term business success. As companies navigate this challenging landscape, the integration of bold leadership, strategic partnerships, and a clear focus on long-term goals will be essential. The discussion highlighted the power of corporate commitments to drive positive change and the need for continuous, transparent dialogue to build trust and resilience in today’s polarized environment.
Not a Drill — Transitioning to a Lower-Carbon World
Moderated by Charles Duhigg, a writer for The New Yorker, the panel also featured Tom Wilson alongside Elaine Genser, Partnership Advisor at the U.N. Joint SDG Fund; Maryanne Hancock, CEO of Y Analytics; and Gernot Wagner, a climate economist at Columbia Business School. The discussion offered a blend of pragmatic insights and innovative solutions for a sustainable future.
The Inevitability of Transition
Tom Wilson set the stage by asserting the inevitability of the transition to a lower-carbon economy. He emphasized the importance of organization and rapid action to mitigate ongoing severe weather catastrophes, which he believes will persist despite efforts to reduce carbon emissions. His perspective underscores the dual challenge of managing immediate climate risks while working towards long-term solutions.
Multi-Stakeholder Engagement
Elaine Genser highlighted the critical role of multi-stakeholder engagement in driving meaningful change. Drawing from her extensive experience with the U.N. and World Bank, she noted the need for political interest from governments, corporations, and communities. While acknowledging the complexity of aligning diverse country interests, Genser remained optimistic about the potential for coordinated action. She pointed to recent climate disasters in Brazil, where floods displaced 600,000 people, to illustrate the urgent need for collaborative efforts that encompass gender equity and human rights alongside environmental goals.
Economic Viability and Adaptive Finance
Maryanne Hancock brought a financial perspective to the table, emphasizing the economic viability of renewable energy, pointing out:
Renewable energy at this point is one of the least costly types of energy in 90% of the world right now, for 90% of the population right now. Seventy-four percent of the new generation capacity that’s going in the global South right now is renewable, not just because people think it’s a really important thing to do for the planet (but) because unit economics have gotten us there over the past two decades.
Hancock called for a greater focus on adaptive finance to address immediate climate impacts, such as the recent heatwaves and floods. She stressed the importance of leveraging unit economics to scale climate solutions rapidly, citing the investment in Tata EV in India as an example of low-cost electric vehicles transforming markets outside the U.S.
The Price of Carbon and Policy Innovation
Gernot Wagner talked about the economic mechanisms necessary for a successful transition, advocating for accurate carbon pricing to reflect its true social cost. He argued that the price of carbon should be high to account for the damage we cause. Wagner illustrated the disparity between the low voluntary carbon offsets available to consumers and the substantial costs needed to address climate impacts effectively. He praised policy initiatives like the Inflation Reduction Act and carbon pricing in Europe, which set precedents for integrating environmental costs into economic decisions.
Integrating Human Rights and Climate Justice
Elaine Genser and Maryanne Hancock emphasized the necessity of integrating climate justice, gender equality, and human rights into climate action. According to Genser:
It is important to have all aspects in everything that you do — either gender, human rights, and climate advocacy — just because you don’t have the the ability to go back later for some of those things and in some of those countries. So it needs to be built in every single program, in every every single thing that you do (because) to go back later costs much more.
Optimism for the Future
Despite the daunting challenges, the panelists expressed a cautiously optimistic outlook for the future. Wilson envisioned a “huge economic boom” resulting from the transition, while Genser pointed to the rapid advancements in climate solutions. Wagner and Hancock both highlighted the economic opportunities inherent in addressing climate change. As Wagner concludes:
(The) most expensive thing is not to act, right? Dozens of trillions of dollars (versus) acting, yeah, single-digit trillion dollars worth of costs… The economics, jobs, opportunity is what makes me optimistic
Navigating Tomorrow’s Economy: Conversation with Larry Fink
In Part 1 of this session, Scott Strazik, CEO of GE Vernova, interviews Larry Fink, CEO of BlackRock, about how new priorities and technologies are paving the way for a dynamic future economy.
Fink, who no longer uses the term ESG, still believes that addressing climate change is not only an environmental imperative but also an economic necessity.
The Growth Dilemma: A Call for Pragmatic Solutions
Larry Fink opened the discussion by highlighting the “growth dilemma” faced by G7 countries, characterized by high levels of debt relative to GDP. According to Fink, the G7 has a debt to GDP of 124%, which means they have more debt than their GDP, and historically, around 50% of GDP was considered safe. He stressed the importance of economic growth, not just debt reduction, as a solution.
I really do believe if we don’t start focusing on how do we grow, we’re in real trouble.
Fink pointed out that the U.S. deficit has grew by $23 trillion from 2000 (when the deficit was $8 trillion) to 2023. He emphasized the need for a growth agenda focused on rebuilding infrastructure, digitization, and decarbonization. He believes that these initiatives can significantly enhance productivity and drive economic growth.
Harnessing Private Capital and Technological Advancements
A recurring theme in Fink’s remarks was the potential of private capital and technological advancements to fuel economic growth. He noted that there are trillions of dollars of private capital ready to be deployed in decarbonization and digitization projects. Fink talked about the importance of public-private partnerships in achieving these goals, citing the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) as a prime example. He pointed out that 90% of IRA projects are in red states due to faster permitting processes, illustrating how pragmatic policies can accelerate infrastructure development.
Scott Strazik echoed Fink’s sentiments, particularly on the intersection of energy demand and decarbonization. Strazik highlighted GE Vernova’s role in generating 25% of the world’s electricity daily and stressed the importance of investing in renewable energy sources and modernizing the electric grid. Strazik stated:
This investment cycle we’re about to go into is the best chance to really transform the system and decarbonize it simultaneously, but there’s fear (that) with more demand, it’s going to be harder to decarbonize the system.
AI: Catalyst for Growth and Productivity
Both leaders recognized the transformative potential of AI in driving productivity and economic growth. Fink described AI as a “double catalyst,” capable of revolutionizing industries while also creating new investment opportunities.
However, Fink acknowledged the fears associated with AI, particularly job displacement. He emphasized the need to balance technological advancements with policies that support workforce transition and retraining. Highlighting the long-term benefits of technological innovation, Fink said:
Technology does change jobs, but over time it creates new jobs. And the problem is that transition. And also there’s geographic differences, too, so how do you blend that and balance that out.
Direct Air Capture
Fink is a proponent of direct air capture, which captures carbon dioxide from the air and stores it underground. BlackRock has invested in Occidental Petroleum’s direct air capture project, which aims to build 30 facilities for doing this. Even though it costs over a billion dollars for one factory, Fink believes that the technology has the potential to significantly reduce CO2 emissions. He emphasized that projects like this, supported by the IRA, can provide substantial returns for investors while contributing to decarbonization efforts.
The Need for Pragmatic Permitting and Policy Support
Fink emphazed the need for pragmatic permitting processes and supportive policies to enable rapid infrastructure development. He stressed that more speedy permitting processes are essential to deploy private capital effectively and drive growth. State and country governments with favorable permitting environments are likely to be the big winners in the coming years.
A Vision for a Growth-Oriented Future
The speakers painted an optimistic picture of the future, driven by technological advancements, private capital, and pragmatic policies. Fink and Strazik emphasized the importance of a growth-oriented agenda that leverages innovation and infrastructure investment to address global challenges.
Learn More about the 2024 Aspen Ideas Festival
The 20th anniversary of the Aspen Ideas Festival took place from June 23–29, 2024. The festival, themed “Bright Minds for Dart Times,” featured over 300 speakers and 100+ sessions that covered a wide array of topics.
You can watch recorded sessions on the Aspen Institute’s website and YouTube channel.
StartingUpGood supports fresh entrepreneurial approaches to social impact. FOLLOW US on social media:
Check out SDGCounting for the latest news on tracking the progress of the Sustainable Development Goals. #SDGs #GlobalGoals.
Disclaimer: This article uses Otter.ai and YouTube to develop transcripts and various LLMs to help summarize and proof-read. All content for the article was hand-curated and checked for quality.
