In general, it’s very difficult to have a star transform into a white dwarf and wind up with a planet very close in orbit around it without that planet being destroyed by a tidal disruption event. A new discovery, of a Jupiter-sized exoplanet around an old, evolved white dwarf in the WD 1856+534 system, challenges what we know about the evolution of planetary systems. (MARK GARLICK, UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON, UNIVERSITY OF WARWICK AND UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD)

Ask Ethan: Is It Really Impossible For A Jupiter-Like Planet To Orbit A White Dwarf?

We just found a system that we can’t explain. Here’s what’s going on.

Ethan Siegel
Oct 2, 2020 · 10 min read

One of the most fascinating facts about the Universe is that there’s so much of it out there. There are some 2 trillion galaxies strewn about across the observable Universe, with our own home galaxy containing somewhere around 400 billion stars all by itself. That’s 400 billion planetary systems, 400 billion opportunities for biochemical reactions, and 400 billion unique configurations just waiting for us to identify and observe them. Recently, we’ve discovered a new system — of a Jupiter-sized planet orbiting very close to a white dwarf — that challenges our notions of what ought to exist. What does this novel system mean, and why is it so puzzling? That’s what Patreon supporter Dominic Turpin wants to know, asking:

“I just read we found a Jupiter sized planet orbiting a white dwarf star. [The article] said the planet found a way to survive the supernova explosion. Is it possible the white dwarf simply captured a rogue planet after the supernova?”

There’s a lot that’s being misinterpreted here, but there is a fascinating truth: for the first time, we’ve found a giant planet orbiting a white dwarf star, and it’s extremely close to the white dwarf, completing an orbital revolution in just 34 hours. Here’s why it’s a puzzle, and what the resolution could possibly be.

Exoplanets should only be able to survive around masses of any type, whether stars, white dwarfs, neutron stars or even black holes, if the tidal forces on them are small enough to keep them from being completely torn apart. It is not yet understood how such a large, massive planet can remain intact with an orbit that brings it so close to the white dwarf observed in WD 1856+534. (NASA AMES/JPL-CALTECH/T. PYLE)

In general, there are three completely independent possible fates for stars, and they’re overwhelmingly determined by one factor: how much mass was the star born with? The most massive stars, born with eight or more times the mass of our Sun, will burn through the hydrogen in its core, swell into a red giant and burn helium in its core, and then proceed to burning carbon, neon, oxygen, and silicon before dying in a catastrophic supernova explosion. Typically, this leaves only the collapsed core behind: either a neutron star or a black hole.

Sun-like stars, with masses between ~40% and ~800% the Sun’s mass, will live a like much like our own Sun: they’ll burn through the hydrogen in their core, expand into a helium-burning red giant, and then gently blow off their outer layers while the core contracts down to form a white dwarf, primarily composed of carbon and oxygen.

On the extreme low-mass end, stars between just ~8% and ~40% of the Sun’s mass will burn hydrogen only, contracting down to form a helium-only white dwarf at the end of their lives.

When Sun-like stars reach the end of their lives, after evolving into a red giant, they will gradually blow off their outer layers to form a planetary nebula, while the burned-out core of the star contracts down to form a carbon-oxygen white dwarf. Our Sun will achieve this fate after another 7 billion years, approximately, but other stars have already achieved it billions of years ago. (NASA, ESA, AND C.R. O’DELL (VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY))

When we see a white dwarf star, we can be confident that this is a stellar remnant whose core didn’t collapse and implode, and whose progenitor star didn’t die in a supernova explosion. There may be other ways to make a white dwarf — a very massive red giant could have its outer layers stripped away, for instance, “aborting” a potential supernova — but the stellar deaths that create them are always gentle, not cataclysmic.

The puzzle is this: when a Sun-like star goes down the path towards becoming a white dwarf, it’s expected to destroy much of the solar system that has historically orbited it.

First, the star swells into a red giant, with its core contracting and heating up, hydrogen fusion occurring in a shell surrounding the core, and eventually fusing helium in the central core. During this stage, the star swells to more than a million times its initial volume and more than 100 times its initial radius, while its energy output skyrockets: red giant stars can be over a thousand times as luminous as the star was previously.

The evolution of a solar-mass star on the Hertzsprung-Russell (color-magnitude) diagram from its pre-main-sequence phase to the end of fusion. Note how, during the giant phase, the horizontal branch, the asymptotic branch, and the planetary nebula phase, the star’s luminosity can reach hundreds or even thousands of times its typical brightness during its lifetime. (WIKIMEDIA COMMONS USER SZCZUREQ)

For hundreds of millions of years, the red giant star will fuse helium into carbon in its core, gradually shedding mass as its outer layers periodically eject matter into a halo surrounding the solar system. Finally, as the end of the star’s life approaches, the outer layers — composed primarily of lighter elements like hydrogen and helium — are blown off into a planetary nebula, while the core contracts down to form a white dwarf. That’s the expected life cycle for the star itself.

But what happens to the planets orbiting that star, or to the remainder of that solar system?

When the star first becomes a red giant, the innermost planets get engulfed and swallowed: Mercury and Venus will definitely go this route when the Sun becomes a red giant, and Earth likely will as well. The radiation is so intense that the icy bodies of the solar system, like Kuiper belt objects, will largely sublimate away, leaving only their rocky cores behind. And any gas giants that are too close to a giant star like this may even have their atmospheres evaporated away, leaving only their exposed planetary cores.

When large, massive, gas giant exoplanets come too close to their parent star, the outer gas envelope can be mostly or entirely stripped away. What remains might be an exposed planetary core, not much bigger than Earth but comparable in mass to a world like Neptune or Uranus. (MARK GARLICK / UNIVERSITY OF WARWICK)

Additionally, gravitational instabilities can be induced in the orbits of the remaining planets. Many models that seek to simulate the far future of our Solar System show at least one of our inner planets getting ejected, while the mass loss that occurs towards the end of the star’s life can cause the outer planets to spiral away from the star and potentially even become gravitationally unbound. The final stages of a solar system, just like the early stages, can result in the creation of many rogue planets.

But this doesn’t necessarily mean that no planets can ever orbit close in to a white dwarf. One of the other things that happens is that the material that was once part of the central star, as it gets ejected, can collide with the orbiting planets, acting like a source of friction. Just as an orbital satellite coasting through the tenuous upper atmosphere will slowly lose momentum (both linear and angular momentum) and fall back to Earth, the planets orbiting a dying Sun-like star will experience a similar effect, spiraling in towards the central star over time, so long as the matter blown off around the dying star intersects the planet-in-question’s orbit.

Near the end of a Sun-like star’s life, it begins to blow off its outer layers into the depths of space, forming a protoplanetary nebula like the Egg Nebula, seen here. Its outer layers have not yet been heated to sufficient temperatures by the central, contracting star to create a true planetary nebula just yet, but the matter is clearly present, and will create frictional forces on any planets that remain in orbit around the star up to this point. (NASA AND THE HUBBLE HERITAGE TEAM (STSCI / AURA), HUBBLE SPACE TELESCOPE / ACS)

All of that is just theory, of course. But in astrophysics, as in all physical sciences, the theoretical predictions we make are only useful when they’re confronted with observations and measurements about the actual Universe itself. Although we’ve managed to detect thousands of exoplanets around stars, we know of very few around stellar corpses like white dwarfs. We’ve detected a few planets orbiting pulsing neutron stars from the time-delay of the arriving pulses, but the evidence of planets around white dwarfs has largely been indirect:

  • from rocky material in a white dwarf’s atmosphere,
  • via warm debris disks around the stellar remnant,
  • or from rocky (or icy) debris that’s likely from a tidally destroyed former planet that hasn’t quite been swallowed.

But one of the big questions that this has led to is whether a planet can survive, intact, to orbit close in to a white dwarf. White dwarfs are as massive as entire stars, but only about the physical size of a rocky planet like Earth. Each time you halve your orbital distance around a white dwarf, the tidal forces on you increase by a factor of 8; could a planet survive orbiting so close to such a massive object?

When objects get too close in orbit around another mass, such as a white dwarf (or a red giant evolving towards a white dwarf), tidal forces increase as the object inspirals. Eventually, those forces will tear the object apart into a ring and/or debris disk. For a planet to survive intact close in around a white dwarf star is a challenge for theoretical models. (NASA/JPL-CALTECH)

That’s where the newest study (free version available here) comes in: for the first time, a candidate (i.e., not independently confirmed) planet has been found orbiting a white dwarf. The star system itself is known as WD 1856+534, and is located only 80 light-years away. Based on its temperature, it became a white dwarf approximately 6 billion years ago, back before our Solar System even formed. And, after being targeted by NASA’s Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS), a characteristic and periodic dimming was found, signaling the presence of a transiting exoplanet.

Transits are expected to be rare around white dwarfs, as the odds of getting a serendipitous alignment — where the planet actually passes in front of a small-sized stellar remnant — are very low. Over 1,000 white dwarfs were surveyed by TESS, and WD 1856+534 was the first one to show evidence of this periodic dimming. Based on the data obtained, the planet is very close to the white dwarf, completing an orbit every 1.4 days (34 hours), but being quite large: approximately the size of Jupiter, taking 6-to-8 minutes to complete a full transit.

Exoplanets and exomoons have been observed by measuring the light coming from distant stars, and observing periodic flux dips where the light of the parent star is partially blocked by the transiting planet for a brief amount of time. The system WD 1856+534 shows the largest flux dip ever observed at 56%, indicating a giant planet transiting across a compact stellar remnant. (NASA’S GODDARD SPACE FLIGHT CENTER/SVS/KATRINA JACKSON)

The dimming of the white dwarf is enormous, as two sets of 2019 observations showed that the light output was reduced by 56% during transits, as opposed to typically less than 1% for most transits around normal stars. Normally, we’d be able to follow-up and confirm the existence of the planet and measure its mass by observing the spectral lines of the star and how those lines redshift and blueshift over time, but this particular white dwarf is unusually featureless. As the authors write:

“the spectrum of WD 1856 is classified as type DC, a featureless continuum with no strong optical absorption or emission features. Optical and near-infrared spectra from the MMT Telescope, Lick Shane Telescope, Gemini-North telescope, and Hobby Eberly Telescope confirmed this classification. The lack of strong spectroscopic absorption features precludes precise Doppler observations.”

There’s no excess long-wavelength radiation, telling us that this isn’t an ultra-cool star or brown dwarf on its own; it’s almost certainly a giant planet, but one that’s survived intact, devoid of any detectable debris, orbiting extraordinarily close to a compact stellar remnant.

In the common envelope scenario, a star that evolves into a red giant can have its mass either siphoned off or ejected entirely by the presence of a binary companion, which will then spiral in closer to the parent star. Still, this scenario, as theoretically attractive as it may be, is insufficient on its own to explain the observed white dwarf-giant exoplanet system around WD 1856+534. (M. WEISS, CXC, NASA)

Current theoretical ideas that are used to explain other known systems all run into problems when applied to this white dwarf-giant exoplanet system. The common envelope theory — where a giant star engulfs a lower-mass companion, ejecting the envelope while the companion spirals in — this white dwarf-giant planet system has by far the lowest mass/longest orbital period combination of any sych system. Put simply, the mass of the exoplanet is too small to eject the envelope of the giant star that gave rise to the white dwarf.

The “captured rogue planet” scenario fares no better, as a system of pre-existing masses would need to be ejected (similar to how Triton ejected Neptune’s pre-existing moons) to bring the planet into a circular orbit, and the same “common envelope” problems still arise.

Instead, the most viable known scenario is through dynamic instabilities that arise over long cosmic times. Simulations indicate that a planet like this observed exoplanet could be thrown into highly eccentric orbits which come very close to the parent star, and then circularize over billions of years. Given the white dwarf’s advanced age, this is a plausible pathway towards forming this system.

When lower-mass, Sun-like stars run out of fuel, they blow off their outer layers in a planetary nebula, but the center contracts down to form a white dwarf. The recent discovery of a close-in, intact exoplanet around a white dwarf without evidence of dust or ice particles in the white dwarf’s atmosphere and without a debris disk is a puzzle for science. (MARK GARLICK / UNIVERSITY OF WARWICK)

But there are two interesting caveats to all of this that we have to remember, above and beyond everything that’s already been brought up. First off, this white dwarf is extremely low in mass: about 52% the mass of the Sun. Stars that yield white dwarfs this low in mass, naturally, live longer than the current age of the Universe. This suggests some sort of dynamical interaction was at play, ejecting a portion of the progenitor star’s mass. And second off, we don’t have any information about what this star systems configuration was billions of years ago.

Could there have been a binary companion that siphoned off a large portion of the star’s mass during the giant phase, and was subsequently ejected? Or, perhaps, was the white dwarf-exoplanet combination ejected from a previously larger system? In our modern Universe, we have only a snapshot of what things looks like when the light from these astronomical systems arrives. Their history is forever lost to us, and it will take a large set of observations to teach us exactly what exoplanetary systems truly exist around these stellar remnants.

We’re seeing the tip of the iceberg: a scientific field in its infancy. Over the coming years and decades, it will be the data we’ve yet to obtain that will teach us what types of planetary systems remain — and how abundant they are — when Sun-like stars meet their inevitable demise.

Starts With A Bang!

The Universe is out there, waiting for you to discover it.

Ethan Siegel

Written by

The Universe is: Expanding, cooling, and dark. It starts with a bang! #Cosmology Science writer, astrophysicist, science communicator & NASA columnist.

Starts With A Bang!

The Universe is out there, waiting for you to discover it.

Ethan Siegel

Written by

The Universe is: Expanding, cooling, and dark. It starts with a bang! #Cosmology Science writer, astrophysicist, science communicator & NASA columnist.

Starts With A Bang!

The Universe is out there, waiting for you to discover it.

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store