“The value of an idea lies in the using of it.” ~ Thomas Edison was right…
So my advice is to NOT share your startup idea with anyone, unless, of course, you want to succeed. You’ve got an idea for the next big thing, a new iPhone application that could change the world, and you’re looking for developers and/or looking to raise capital. You are not entirely certain where to turn so you reach out to local entrepreneurs who have ‘been there and done that’. I get calls like these all of the time. Prior to 2008 most entrepreneurs here in North Texas were scared to share their ideas without getting an NDA in place beforehand. This put them at a HUGE disadvantage over their peers on the West Coast where collaboration and community have a long and distinguished history. Slowly but surely, the startup community in North Texas has morphed and has become very collaborative and supportive. But, every once in a while you’ll run into someone who is still clinging to the old, secretive ways of the past.
In fact, just yesterday I got a message from an acquaintance who told me he was working on a an app and asked me to put him in touch with local investors. I suggested he send me his deck and I’d make a few introductions. His response? He wouldn’t send it unless I signed an NDA (he obviously doesn’t read my blog). He explained that someone with experience could steal the idea in a second. I’m not sure why, but I felt really offended at the time — it felt weird to have someone asking for a favor AND at the same time explain that he didn’t trust me.
At the end of the day ideas are worthless — execution is priceless. When you’re starting a company you need as much help as possible. You need mentors, advisers, peers, partners, investors, vendors and friends. If you keep your ideas a secret it will be impossible for anyone to actually help you. Could someone steal your idea? Of course, but as I’ve said before your potential competitors are more likely to become partners. You’re far more passionate about your idea that anyone else — and most people want to partner with people with passion. Additionally, keeping your idea a secret may actually create more competitors. I explained my thinking in a post a few years ago, but Chris Dixon does a much better job explaining it than I did in his post, “Why you shouldn’t keep your startup idea secret.“