The 7 Most Creative Examples of Habit-Changing Nudges
From speed camera lotteries to piano stairs: a collection of 7 nifty nudges spotted in the wild
Nudge Theory, as articulated by Nobel Prize-winning behavioral economist Richard Thaler, has spawned a universe of real-world applications. The principles of ‘choice architecture’ have since been applied by both savvy marketers and public policy makers.
“There’s no such thing as ‘neutral’ design. Small and apparently insignificant details can have major impacts on people’s behavior.” — Richard H. Thaler
A nudge helps people make better choices for themselves without restricting their freedom of choice. It accomplishes this by making it easier for people to make a certain decision. In other words, putting fruit at eye level counts as a nudge. Banning junk food does not.
Now that we’ve got the definitions out of the way, let’s get into some of the most clever nudges I could find. Starting with…
1 / There’s a fly in my urinal
Perhaps the most famous example of nudging in action took place in the early 1990s at Schiphol Airport in Amsterdam. Here, the airport’s designers used a simple trick to improve bathroom cleanliness.
By printing the above image of a housefly on the inside of urinals, the airport significantly improved user “accuracy”: spillage on the bathroom floor was reduced by 80%!
2 / Speed Camera Lottery
Now this is my favorite nudge of all time. In 2010, Volkswagen picked Kevin Richardson as the winner of its Fun Theory Contest. Richardson invented the “Speed Camera Lottery,” which uses the speeding cameras at intersections to reward those who obey the speed limit with the fees paid by those who violated it.
I find this idea simple and brilliant. It’s sticks and carrots on an entirely new level. The Speed Camera Lottery is the ultimate nudge: it doesn’t restrict choice — you can still drive as fast as you want to — but the better/safer option is made more attractive in a magnificently creative way.
I’m not the only one who thinks this idea is great, either. The Swedish National Society for Road Safety apparently liked it as well, since they worked with Kevin to experiment with the concept in Stockholm in November 2010.
During the trial, 24,857 cars passed the cameras, and the average speed dropped from 32 km/h to 25 km/h — which is exactly the speed limit of Stockholm’s main roads!
3 / Reducing cigarette litter on the streets of London
Football fans are known to have very strong opinions on who’s the #1 player of the world. Environmental organization Hubbub takes advantage of this in a brilliant way:
These voting ashtrays (or ‘Ballot Bins’) don’t stop at football though, with previous questions also including matters surrounding Formula One, tennis, and cricket. At this point, 30 UK councils are using it to tackle cigarette litter.
The innovative ashtrays have proven to reduce cigarette litter by 46%, as measured by Southend Council in 2017. In America, environmental charity Keep America Beautiful also tested the Ballot Bins in three different sites. They measured the impact after six months and found a reduction of cigarette litter on busy streets by a whopping 74%.
4 / Smaller plates = less food waste
The picture above illustrates an experiment by GreeNudge. Through reducing plate sizes in hotel restaurants by 2”, they were able to reduce food waste by as much as 22%. Importantly, guest satisfaction stayed the same — they barely noticed the difference.
5 / Bleep — Honk Reduction System
A simple intervention to reduce indiscriminate honking on Indian roads. Every time the driver honks, a red smiley button starts beeping and flashing. To turn it off, the driver has to press the button. In other words, the button makes the subconscious habit of indiscriminate honking conscious again by giving immediate feedback to the driver.
The results? Drivers reduced their honking by an average of 61% over a period of six months, because the red buzzer was such an annoyance. Apparently, 61% of honking was (more or less) habitual and unrelated to safety.
6 / 3D Child on the road: safety enhancement or recipe for disaster?
This one’s a bit more controversial. Preventable, a Canadian traffic safety organization, painted an optical illusion of a little girl chasing a ball, which begins to take shape from about 50 feet away. They placed it on a busy intersection near the Ecole Pauline Johnson in West Vancouver for a week.
Although it’s an innovative idea, some critics say that it could cause accidents. “I think it’s awful. I think it’s dangerous,” Sam Schwartz, a former traffic commissioner in New York City, told ABC News. “I think drivers are always scanning and suddenly they see this image up, they may very well panic.”
Here’s a small video clip that shows the illusion from the perspective of an approaching car driver:
I personally don’t think that playing with people’s reactions while they’re sitting in a 2,500-pound moving projectile of steel and glass is very wise, but what do you think? Is this helpful in reducing risks or will it just cause even more problems by scaring drivers and leading them to swerve?
7 / The Famous Piano Stairs: Mozart + Movement = Fun
The piano stairs encourage subway commuters to ditch the escalators and go for the healthier option: climbing the stairs. It shows that something as simple as fun is the easiest way to change people’s behavior for the better.
After the stairs were first introduced in Sweden, the idea struck a chord (pun intended) with people around the world, with a video of the concept clocking up over 23 million views on YouTube.
To round off this post, here are some other fun nudges I came across on the internet that didn’t make my Top 7:
That’s a wrap. What nudges have you encountered? Let me know in the comments below!