Violent hashtag frequencies in Parler

a data scientist
Jan 12 · 7 min read

I ran a crawler to collect posts and comments on the Parler social network for months before Amazon shut them down. Parler hosted a wide range of discourse that happened to include hate speech, conspiracy theories, threats of violence, and disinformation.

Users could only search posts on Parler (called “Parleys”) by hashtags, not by the text content within the post itself. This led users to liberally apply hashtags within any Parley that they wished to disseminate widely, providing valuable metadata to researchers like myself.

For example, here is a random Parley from January 6th in Washington D.C.

#trump had to allow #mikepence to sign his own death warrant…..
#TraitorPence #GITMO #firingsquad

#ALLorNOTHING #2theEND #wildDC #magarally #wildprotest
#saveamericarally #trumprally #dc #ArrestPence #traitorVP

#JAN6 the new #911….. #makethempay #retribution

This is the first part of a multi-part series where I analyze the data I collected from Parler. In the next part, I use this data along with FEC filings to make a case for why Georgia representative Marjorie Taylor Greene may have committed campaign finance violations.

1/20/2021 Now that I have a larger and more representative dataset on my computer thanks to archiveteam, I’m going to update all the visuals and responsibly disclose all the code used to generate them before writing any further. Thank you to the countless kind people out there for your encouragement and advice.

Hanging politicians goes viral on Parler

Image for post
Image for post
Relative frequency of hashtags that call for execution by hanging — e.g. “pelosi4gallows”, “hangtraitors”, “bringbackpublicexecutions”, etc. Yes, those are real hashtags that were widely used.

The notion of murdering politicians was discussed on Parler for months before the 2020 US election, often in response to perceived injustices perpetrated by that politician. The frequency of hashtags involving hanging/execution more than doubles after the 2020 US election (blue vertical line above), more than triples on the day of the Electoral College vote (green line), and is an order of magnitude higher on the day of the Capitol riot (red line).

Parler may have allowed the idea of attacking and hanging politicians to spread virally on the platform, most likely by negligence. It is my opinion that the notion of hanging, which was gaining acceptance in online discourse, manifested itself in the gallows erected outside the US Capitol on January 6th. I believe the gallows are a reference to the white supremacist literature The Turner Diaries, in which a “Day of the Rope” features politicians hung en masse. It was pointed out to me by a well-informed reader that there are other possible meanings behind the gallows, so I have revised to clarify this as only an opinion.

A reference to the “Day of the Rope” where dissenters from white supremacist groupthink are systematically murdered, followed in the story by violent reprisals against non-whites and nuclear armageddon.

Below is a word cloud of hashtags associated with posts that explicitly mention murdering specific politicians (Nancy Pelosi, Joe Biden, AOC, and even lesser-known Democrats like Eric Swalwell).

Image for post
Image for post
Hashtags that show up more frequently have a larger font, and it should be no surprise that many of the 45th president’s campaign slogans are so closely associated.

In the graph below, hashtags are connected and placed closer together when they are frequently mentioned together. Tags are grouped into communities that are frequently mentioned together, and edges span across communities to indicate association between various topics of discussion.

Image for post
Image for post
Visualizing discussion topics on Parler and how various discussions are linked by analyzing hashtag correlation.

Exploring the dataset

I use the Wolfram Language for analysis, which allows me to sample and search the dataset around particular topics of discussion. As I randomly perused based on hashtags in the discussion graph above, I realized how difficult moderating this kind of conversation would be. For example, consider the post below:

Image for post
Image for post

The author of the post is sharing a book on guerilla warfare that is available on Amazon. I can look up the post author by their user ID, and from their other posts and comments it is obvious that they are trying to incite guerilla warriors to attack the “deep state”. Amazon is wise to not provide a platform for this information to disseminate digitally, but is it simply pushing people back to the printing press?

Wait right here. I’m about to imply something significant in the next section, and I need to do it with the largest possible dataset I have available to work with (thanks archiveteam!). I’m fairly confident my conclusion will not change, but it is within the realm of possibility. Therefore, please take this next part with a grain of salt until I update these results with the full scrape of Parler.

The next viral hashtag

In the aftermath of the January 6th insurrection, there was one particular class of hashtags that appeared to be mentioned more often.

Image for post
Image for post
The use of hashtags calling for civil war increased by around 30% after the failed insurrection at the Capitol.

The hashtags related to civil war are frequently associated with the Boogaloo movement and the campaign of Donald Trump. It is possible we will see the real-world effects of this radicalization within the coming months.

Image for post
Image for post
Using the Wolfram Language to visualize relative frequency of hashtags with the given keywords. You can see toward the end that posts about hanging politicians are being replaced by posts calling for civil war.
Image for post
Image for post
Community associations of hashtags — these groups of tags are frequently mentioned together. Yellow and green are references to the Boogaloo movement, purple hashtags typically involve violence and anti-establishment topics, while red tags are typically associated with Donald Trump.

In a world of 24-hour news cycles and the proliferation of online disinformation, hashtags are ostensibly correlated to whatever is popular on the Internet at a particular time. On Parler, most users would just “echo” the posts of others — the Parler equivalent of a retweet.

The hash tags and post IDs allow misinformation to be “contact traced” across the network. In a future post, I will share my ideas on ways to measure the contagiousness of an idea and to quantify how radicalized a user has become.

Image for post
Image for post
Word cloud for hashtags on posts that explicitly call for civil war in America.

The QAnon conspiracy

There are a substantial number of Americans (including two sitting US congresswomen) who believe there is a vast global conspiracy by a cabal of Satan-worshipping pedophiles to consolidate power, and that Donald Trump is secretly trying to bring them down. One distinct feature of the QAnon conspiracy is how new layers of rationalization are continuously added through widely disseminated videos — unlike the moon landing conspiracies, QAnon’s purported conspiracy is ongoing, and continuously adapting to current events. As the theory evolves, it provides opportunities for anyone on the Internet to insert more dangerous ideas into it.

Image for post
Image for post
QAnon posts on Parler are frequently associated with COVID denial and a belief that Bill Gates/George Soros orchestrated the pandemic, with the “evidence” often presented in poorly-edited videos.

This is a popular QAnon post taken from a random sample of the dataset. It has been viewed over 181,000 times, reposted over a thousand times, upvoted over a thousand times, and has 319 comments attached to it.

Image for post
Image for post
George Soros is a billionaire investor, Holocaust survivor, and well-known financier of liberal causes.

What’s next

You can now read part 2 in which the data indicates that a political campaign and a super PAC shoveled over a quarter million dollars into Parler in the span of one month after the election.

The Internet Archive is putting together a far more comprehensive dataset of posts, images, comments, users, and media from Parler which I recommend to data scientists looking to take up this project. My future plans for this project are:

  • Perform NLP and sentiment analysis on the comments that users leave on posts, and identify which hashtags are associated with which sentiments
  • Analysis of disinformation sites, the rate at which they propagate across the Parler social network, and the hashtags most frequently associated with each one
  • Quantifying the radicalization of a user by showing a statistically-significant trend toward more violent ideas and hashtags
  • Clean up the data and make it publicly accessible to researchers

You can contact me about this post and to request access to the dataset by messaging me on Twitter or emailing contact@adatascienti.st. I am trying to stay anonymous so these stories aren’t about me — they should be about the data. If you read anything else I write and find a partisan lean to it, please call me out on it, as it defeats the whole point of writing these if I’m just speaking to an echo chamber of my own.

Please don’t make the problem worse

I do not think the average Parler user deserves to be victimized, called a fascist, or have their privacy taken from them. I will not be taking part in anything like that.

The people who committed crimes should be treated as criminals. However, there were some pretty sociopathic people on Parler who need compassion and possibly mental help, not further provocation. I believe we need to study how technology enabled a group of people to radicalize each other and reinforced an echo chamber where conspiracies and racism could flourish.

Disclaimer: since Parler has never enforced their Terms of Service with regards to violent speech, I slept fine at night ignoring their ToS with regards to automated scraping of the site.

The Startup

Medium's largest active publication, followed by +771K people. Follow to join our community.

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store