Image for post
Image for post
Photo by Christina Wocintechchat at Unsplash

Why Software Testing Is So Important

It’s not because you’re being diligent

Chris Fox
Chris Fox
Dec 23, 2019 · 5 min read

Bizarro World Software Development

Anyone reading public discussions about software development might not even know that the main objective is the production of executables. One could be forgiven for having the impression that the sole objective of software development is unit testing.

Articles about coding practices are few and occasional; articles about testing strategies are legion. And they tend to be either strangely exuberant (a happy team sitting in each others’ laps and writing tests) or scolding (anything other than 100% code coverage is slipshod and undisciplined).

It didn’t use to be like this. We used to focus on development, and while we did enough testing of our own work we knew, and knew clearly, that this was just the beginning, that a team of dedicated SDETs would do the real testing, based on a functional specification and unprejudiced by knowledge of the code.

Nomenclature

BlackBox Testing: testing an executable using a functional specification as a guide, without knowledge of the code or the implementation design, based on behaviour and tested in the user interface (EXE) or a test harness (DLL).

WhiteBox Testing: same as BlackBox but with knowledge of the code and thereby prejudiced. Generally done by the developer and perfunctory, not recommended for conclusive testing

Unit Testing: testing code functions directly, passing them sample data sets, usually done by the developer and mistakenly regarded as conclusive, a lot of work, often credited with magical powers and regarded by many as defining the entry point documentation. See Test-Driven Development

Traditional Testing

Traditional software testing is BlackBox. The developer either writes or is given a functional specification, implements it, tests it enough to know that basic functionality is sound and likely edge cases work, then delivers it to BlackBox testers, one or more, who specialize in testing. In ideal cases, a developer and SDET work closely together and do as much as possible to bypass the bug database and triage tedium. Fix the bugs, keep management out of it

Admittedly in past times, many companies did not do enough of this. Since my work often went live on servers within hours of bug discovery, it was important to test thoroughly and I sometimes spent half my day in my tester’s office. We worked together well.

But some companies regarded testing as a box to check and nothing more.

Test-Driven Development

Arguing with my manager in 2008 about writing unit tests for my release-ready application, too small to be decomposed into units, the conversation got crazier and crazier and it went into lunacy territory when he mentioned a new thing called “test-driven development.”

The first thing that came into my mind was that we always learn things during development that we hadn’t anticipated in design, so tests written before implementation would either be incomplete or require constant revisiting, which is a waste of time compared to writing them after implementation is finished. Not catastrophically so, but backwards.

TDD is nearly useless. Because of an inflated faith in its effectiveness most developers write tests for the simplest and most straightforward cases and count on the Awesomeness of Unit Testing to fill in their unrecognized gaps.

But TDD has come to dominate the industry despite this, and now testing has replaced development itself as the core of … software development. I’ve already written about this elsewhere and won’t repeat it here:

but in discussions in reaction to this and other articles, I’ve learned that things are a lot, lot worse than I thought.

Why Johnny Can’t Code

Long before the personal computer revolution, the few companies developing software had already noticed that some programmers were much more productive than others and produced superior code. It wasn’t any difference in intelligence, it wasn’t faster typing, it wasn’t longer hours. Research showed that the key to this superior performance was the ability to enter periods of prolonged and unbroken concentration, which was called Flow. See the Resources for more on this, or read my other article:

The reason Microsoft was such a great place to work until it grew large and top-heavy was that this recognition was fundamental to their corporate culture; we had private offices and minimal interruptions.

It didn’t last. Maximizing shareholder value meant doubling or quadrupling office occupancy, we were called to more and more meetings.

The important point here is that being able to concentrate is essential to doing good work.

Because Johnny Can’t Concentrate

I like working alone. I like closing the door to my unshared office, turning out the lights, putting on the headphones playing brooding ambient music, focusing in and coding for hours. I can do weeks of work and have everything work with few or no bugs when everything is done. I can concentrate.

But concentration has gone out of style in software.

The reason you’re so obsessed with testing is because you can’t concentrate, so you can’t write good code.

  • You start your day with an utterly pointless daily scrum (a neologism for a status update; we used to do these in email), scheduled for 8:30 or 9 AM, so your day begins after a mind-numbing slog of a rush-hour commute that leaves you weary from the start.
  • Your day is constantly interrupted by recurring meetings.
  • You are told to respond promptly to emails so you leave popups enabled and break from work to respond to them.
  • You take frequent breaks for “team” events and online gaming.

And worst of all, you’ve never learned to concentrate in the first place. You watch TV and you switch channels every few seconds, you spend hours on social networks where 280 characters strain your attention span, it takes you months to read a novel if you read at all, you play games where response times are instant so you never have to wait for anything longer than microwaving macaroni and even then you dance from foot to foot going “come on, come on.”

You never had a chance, you poor sap. So you write tons of tests.

People Who Concentrate are Toxic

I’ve been told this many times now. Seriously.

On a freelancing agency blog, a manager (who hastened to brag about his hiring authority) told me that he wouldn’t hire someone like me who worked alone because “individualistic” programmers bring toxicity to the “team” and end up demoted and terminated.

On Twitter, a purported developer told me that people who are “obsessed with focus” are mentally unstable and that “people skills” are more important than productivity.

Uh, yeah.

Well then I proudly cop to not being a team player, to being a lone wolf, and I don’t get to put my feet up on the team table with the others and I don’t get invited to the alcohol-fueled team morale events. Fine with me.

But I write solid code, I can handle huge amounts of responsibility, I can manage vast amounts of detail because I can concentrate for a very long time.

And I’m never working anywhere they won’t let me do that.

Our industry is a mess.

Resources

Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience

The Startup

Medium's largest active publication, followed by +775K people. Follow to join our community.

Chris Fox

Written by

Chris Fox

American Software Developer living in Vietnam. Classical musician (guitar, woodwinds), weightlifter, multilingual, misanthrope • XY

The Startup

Medium's largest active publication, followed by +775K people. Follow to join our community.

Chris Fox

Written by

Chris Fox

American Software Developer living in Vietnam. Classical musician (guitar, woodwinds), weightlifter, multilingual, misanthrope • XY

The Startup

Medium's largest active publication, followed by +775K people. Follow to join our community.

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store