Take Back Our Party, Chapter 3: Bad Politics

James Kwak
Dec 19, 2019 · 2 min read

Chapter 2 of Take Back Our Party made the case that the market-centric policies of the Democratic establishment have failed to do anything about — and in many cases have exacerbated — the rise of inequality. Chapter 3 continues the indictment, arguing that the “growth and opportunity” doctrine of Clinton and Obama has also failed as politics.

The New Democrats chose to identify themselves as the party of jobs and growth because they did not want to be seen as the party of redistribution and welfare. But in copying the Republican message of market-driven growth, they also lost the ability to differentiate themselves from those same Republicans. While conservatives promised that slashing regulations and cutting taxes would unleash the ingenuity of the private sector, the Democratic message was roundabout and equivocal: yes, markets are the source of prosperity, but sometimes they suffer from market failures, so cleverly designed government policies are required to make them work properly, etc. We may be right about the economics, but as politics it fails to establish a compelling choice.

But the bigger problem is that by not doing anything about inequality for so many years, the Democratic leadership frittered away the brand equity that the party had built up since the days of Franklin Roosevelt and the New Deal. Once upon a time, lower-income voters assumed that, at least on economic issues, the Democratic Party stood for them. As Bill Clinton and then Barack Obama did little that was recognizably, specifically for workers, they stopped believing that the party cared about them. Which brought us to 2016, when Donald Trump vastly outperformed Mitt Romney among low-income voters.

For more, the entire chapter is up at The American Prospect, as usual.

Take Back Our Party: Restoring the Democratic Legacy

A new book by James Kwak: What’s wrong with the Democratic Party and how to change it

James Kwak

Written by

Books: Take Back Our Party, Economism, 13 Bankers, White House Burning. Professor @UConnLaw. Chair @southerncenter. Co-founder @Guidewire_PandC.

Take Back Our Party: Restoring the Democratic Legacy

A new book by James Kwak: What’s wrong with the Democratic Party and how to change it

More From Medium

More on Democratic Party from Take Back Our Party: Restoring the Democratic Legacy

More on Democratic Party from Take Back Our Party: Restoring the Democratic Legacy

About that Democratic Primary …

More on Inequality from Take Back Our Party: Restoring the Democratic Legacy

More on Inequality from Take Back Our Party: Restoring the Democratic Legacy

Take Back Our Party, Chapter 4: Our Democratic Party

More on Democratic Party from Take Back Our Party: Restoring the Democratic Legacy

More on Democratic Party from Take Back Our Party: Restoring the Democratic Legacy

The Crisis of the Democratic Establishment

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade