Redlisting dog trainers: Bunny edition
Published in
2 min readNov 30, 2022
I have spent too much time watching dog training videos on Youtube and Facebook. And then I spent too much time testing their ideas on my dog. Therefore, here a quick guide to reject dog trainers out of hand, without further experiments. Check the following ten criteria, if more than three of them apply, go find a different trainer.
- The dogfight teaser: The trainer makes videos with titles that contain the words ‘dangerous’, ‘aggression’, ‘dominant’. The videos shows in the first thirty seconds a vicious, attacking dog.
- The quick solution: The trainer promises to solve a behavioural problem in a very short amount of time, say, one hour, or ten minutes, or one minute.
- Being the boss: The trainer uses language or methods that imply that you have to be the boss of your dog. Alternative: You have to dominate your dog. You have to be the alpha person. You have to be the leader, all the time. You have to make all decisions.
- Speaking of the Alpha Male: Dog trainer is a man with a very manly figure, who uses very manly language.
- The horror toolbox: The trainer uses prong collars, choke collars, slip leads, e-collars, or head halters as a matter of course, routinely. Occasional use might be okay (but somehow that never happens).
- Comparing with Others: The trainer spends a lot of time bashing and insulting other trainers. Usually not specific ones, but entire philosophies. Usually by inventing a strawman.
- Being an asshole: The trainer claims to be the best, or among the best of dog trainers. Or at least very good at what they do.
- The anti-science stance: The trainer openly discredits any recent scientific work on dog training or dog behaviour. Alternatively, the trainer is proudly ignoring the science and insists that experience is more important.
- The wild animal: The trainer talks a lot about what wolves do, or more in general, what large apex predators do.
- Ignoring the dog: The trainer only talks about solving the problems a human has with the dog, like pulling, or jumping, or barking. Never about the problems that a dog has, i.e. why the dog is pulling, jumping, barking. The dog’s problems are irrelevant. What the dog feels is not a part of the discussion.