Do Stars Explode or Collapse? That’s the Question

Robert Lea
Jan 11 · 4 min read

Studies of super-dense matter indicate that intermediate stars may not collapse as previously believed, but instead, give way to a massive thermonuclear explosion.

By conducting experimental research with matter 10 million times denser and 25 times denser than that found at the centre of the sun, researchers have determined the nature of the nuclear processes that occur within intermediate-mass stars.

Our understanding of the deaths of both low and high mass stars are fairly sound, but the team’s findings could change how we think about the fate of stars that lie in between. They suggest that such stars may not collapse, as previously believed, but instead end their lives in a spectacular explosion.

Light from the stellar explosion that created this energized cosmic cloud was first seen on planet Earth in October 1604, a mere 400 years ago. The supernova produced a bright new star in early 17th century skies within the constellation Ophiuchus. It was studied by astronomer Johannes Kepler and his contemporaries. Recent data has shown relative elemental abundances typical of a Type Ia supernova and further indicated that the progenitor was a white dwarf star that exploded when it accreted too much material from a companion. The explosions discussed in the publication would produce a remnant that looks like Kepler but with the presence of an oxygen-neon-iron white dwarf at the centre. Image credit: X-ray: NASA/CXC/NCSU/M. Burkey et al.; Optical: DSS

How a star evolves is very much dictated by its mass, with lower mass stars such as our own sun leaving behind a white dwarf — a stellar-core remnant composed of degenerate electron matter — and the remains of high mass stars marked by a neutron star, or if they are massive enough, a black hole. The events that transpire at the end of an intermediate-mass star’s life are considerably murkier, however. An odd predicament, as stars such as this with a mass of between 7 and 11 times that of the sun are extremely common within the Milky Way — our own galaxy.

“The final fate of intermediate-mass stars depends on a tiny detail, namely, how readily the isotope neon-20 captures electrons in the stellar core,” explains Professor Gabriel Martínez-Pinedo of GSI’s research department Theory and the Institut für Kernphysik, TU Darmstadt. “ Depending on this electron capture rate, the star will be either disrupted in a thermonuclear explosion or it will collapse to form a neutron star.”


Bringing the Stars Down to Earth

Thus by studying these isotopes in nuclear laboratories here on Earth — a far more peaceful testing ground than the interior of a star — the team realised they could shed light on the death throes of these stars. “This work started when we realized that a strongly suppressed, and hence previously ignored and experimentally unknown, transition between the ground states of neon-20 and fluorine-20 was a key piece of information needed to determine the electron capture rate in intermediate-mass stars,” says Professor Karlheinz Langanke, Research Director of GSI and FAIR.

Electron capture here demonstrated with Carbon-11, plays an important role in the fate of intermediate-mass stars. Image credit: JLab

By studying the decay rate of fluorine-20 and combining this with theoretical calculations, the team were able to tease out a value for the electron capture rate. Electron capture is a process in which an electron is drawn into an atomic nucleus. This results in the transformation of a proton to a neutron and a neutrino — the latter of which is ejected. As elements are characterised by the number of protons in their nucleus, the end result is the transformation of one element to another. This usually means the transformation of an unstable isotope to a more stable one.

The team's measurements — taken in the Accelerator Laboratory of the University of Jyväskylä — revealed a strong transition between the ground states of neon-20 and fluorine-20. This leads to electron capture in neon-20 occurring in much lighter densities than physicists had previously believed was possible. For intermediete-mass stars, this means that process is much more likely to occur and thus lead to a thermonuclear explosion rather than collapse into a neutron star.

“It is amazing to find out that a single transition can have such a strong impact on the evolution of a big object like a star,” remarks Dag Fahlin Strömberg, who was responsible for large parts of project’s simulations.

The team’s results have wider implications for the abundance and evolution of certain chemical elements in the galaxy because thermonuclear explosions eject far more material into their surroundings than gravitational collapse does. This ejected material is rich in titanium-50, chromium-54, and iron-60, meaning that the unusual titanium and chromium isotopic ratios found in some meteorites, and the discovery of iron-60 in deep-sea sediments could be produced by intermediate-mass stars. Should this be the case, it means that intermediate stars may have exploded in our galactic neighbourhood in both its relatively recent history — the last few million years — and its distant past — billions of years ago.

Should the team’s research be correct, a thermonuclear explosion seems the most likely end fate of mosy intermediete-mass stars. This would result in a Type Ia supernova leaving behind a unique type of white dwarf, known as an oxygen-neon-iron white dwarf. Thus, confirming the team’s conclusion relies on the detection of these white dwarfs. Their subsequent study should then grant insight into the mechanism that triggers the explosion.

Whilst waiting for those developments, the team has no intentions of resting on their laurels, however. There is still the question of what role convection within the star plays in the explosion to tackle. Also, current and planned nuclear accelerators here on Earth are set to investigate various isotopes and their properties in order to better understand their roles in these cosmic events.



Rob is freelance science journalist from the UK, specialising in physics, astronomy, cosmology, quantum mechanics and obscure comic books.

Did you like this article? Subscribe to The Cosmic Companion Newsletter!

The Cosmic Companion

Exploring the wonders of the Cosmos, one mystery at a time

Robert Lea

Written by

Freelance science journalist. BSc Physics. Space. Astronomy. Astrophysics. Quantum Physics. SciComm. ABSW member. WCSJ Fellow 2019. IOP Fellow.

The Cosmic Companion

Exploring the wonders of the Cosmos, one mystery at a time

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade