Religious Experiences. Fact But Inexplicable.
Religious experiences exist. Many people go to great lengths to seek them out. They can be life-changing moments. What’s it all about?
Religious experiences are at the heart of movies. Last night I was zapping the TV channels and ran across an action fiction which I later learned was entitled Babylon AD. As I write the section on religion as a means of how humans reason to bring peace and prosperity to Earth, it struck a chord. There were two religions fighting over a virgin who died on giving birth. What will imaginative minds come up with next?!
Religion is used and abused. Even if it is supposedly founded on a Just and Righteous All-Powerful and All-Seeing God, religion, as taught and practiced by humans has all the shortfalls of the other methods of reasoning observation, philosophy, and science. We’ve seen the tip of the iceberg of its extravagance. But there are positive sides as well, thankfully.
There is much controversy around the Bible. This book is the bestseller of all time. It is the most maligned, and the most respected at the same time, by millions of people on both sides of these strong feelings.
Why talk about the Bible? From an Abrahamic point of view, which is far and away the majority influence in the West the book represents the stepping stone of their religion. No matter where they place themselves on the chessboard of belief.
We are going to be discussing Dr. Jordan Peterson’s approach to the Bible as well as certain of his conclusions. Why him? Because he tackles the book positively as an unsolved mystery. He focuses on pieces of the Bible and takes them apart with ax stroke precision. He is extremely quick-minded, very knowledgeable, and brings the Bible down to a clinical level being the psychologist he is.
He refers to religious experiences, that can be brought on by psychedelic drugs when he points out that you can be controlled by things beyond your conscious mind. It’s like a plurality of personalities that the ancient peoples thought of as gods. Like rage could be Mars, and these stories get passed on and the book of Genesis is an attempt to preserve them and to understand what humans are. This video gives the details and is certainly worth watching, as is the series.
Thoughts appear in your head and we don’t have a sophisticated way of explaining that. There are things inside you that are happening that control you instead of the other way around. He asks some deep basic questions. There are manifestations of spirits, so to speak, inside you that determine the manner in which you walk through life. And you don’t control it. And what does? Is it random? You know, there are people who have claimed that dreams are merely the consequence of random neuronal firing, which is a theory I think is absolutely absurd. Because there’s nothing random about dreams. They’re very, very structured and very, very complex.
I know that the evidence for genuine religious experience is incontrovertible. It can’t be denied or disputed. But it’s not explicable. And so I don’t want to explain it away, I want to just leave it, as a fact.
As I wind up Audit of the Universe with how humans reason I wanted to devote space to Peterson because of how frank he is. I consider those last couple of sentences of his as remarkable. He clearly admits the existence of religious experiences and that, for the time being, they are inexplicable. That’s quite an admission coming from a rational scientist. The Explanation has already written Origin of the Universe, Origin of Humankind, and Origin of Woman about where humans came from and especially what consciousness and mind are all about. These mysteries can be explained, and that is the goal The Explanation has set itself.
Peterson is very open and realistic. Unlike theoretical scientists who work in labs, he’s a clinical psychologist who has a practice of talking at length and gaining the confidence of his patients. He’s talked to sincere people who share with him what’s going on in the deepest part of their bodies, brains, and minds.
One of the reasons I like his Bible expositions is that unlike many Bible detractors who focus on one small story, he goes into the underlying foundation and draws very relevant conclusions.
And it’s (the Bible) pretty barbaric, you know, I mean the story of Abraham and Isaac, there’s a good example of that because Abraham is called on to actually sacrifice his own son, which doesn’t really seem like something that a reasonable God would ask you to do, right? God in the Old Testament is frequently cruel and arbitrary and demanding and paradoxical, which is one of the things that really gives the book life because it wasn’t edited by a committee, you know, a committee that was concerned with not offending anyone, that’s for sure.
Peterson sees definite parallels of human behavior, mythology, and historical stories in the Bible that reflect who and what humans really are. For him, it is somewhat of a mystical book that contains half human dreams and the other half, articulated knowledge. It’s a human effort to record the story of humankind.
I wrote about Stephen Hawking and how he was thankful for the imperfections needed to establish the Universe we have today. In a similar fashion, while Peterson doesn’t believe the Bible, he recognizes there are remarkable phenomena about the contents of this book. He’s a rationalist, so he’s looking for scientific provability, for Biblical statements. We know that can’t be done, hence its unacceptability. Despite that, his truthful analysis brings forth some eye-opening facts:
- It’s strange that such a book should be the focus of attention of so many people over such a lengthy period. Not to mention the real effect it’s had on so many lives.
- The fact that the Bible got assembled into something resembling a story is quite remarkable.
- I know that the evidence for genuine religious experience is incontrovertible. But it’s inexplicable. I wrote this above, but it bears repeating.
- And many people edited it, and many people assembled it over a vast stretch of time. And we have very few documents like that. And so just because we have a document like that is sufficient reason to look at it as a remarkable phenomenon and try to understand what it is that it’s trying to communicate, let’s say.
- It’s also the world’s first hyperlinked text, which is that again. And it’s very much worth thinking about for quite a long time.
- What happens in the Old Testament, at least in part, is that that consciousness is associated with the divine. Now you think, well, is that a reasonable proposition? That’s a very complicated question, but at least we might know that there’s something to the claim. Because there is a miracle of experience and existence, that’s dependent on consciousness.
- And so that’s why I think, in Genesis 1, it relates the idea that human beings are made in the image of the divine, men and women, which is interesting too, because the feminists are always criticizing Christianity, for example, as being inexorably patriarchal. Of course, they criticize everything like that [LAUGHTER], so it’s hardly a stroke of bloody brilliance. But I think it’s an absolute miracle that right at the beginning of the document, it says straightforwardly, with no hesitation whatsoever, that the divine spark, which we’re associating with the word that brings forth being, is manifest in men and women equally. That’s a very cool thing.
- You can act as if the future is a reality. There’s a spirit of tradition that enables you to act as if the future is something that can be bargained with. That’s why you make sacrifices. Sacrifices were acted out for a very long period of time and now they’re psychological. We know that you can sacrifice something valuable in the present and expect that you’re negotiating with something that represents the transcendent future. And that’s an amazing human discovery. Like, no other creature can do that, to act as if the future is real. To note that you can bargain with reality itself and that you can do it successfully. It’s unbelievable.
At the end of the video, in answering a question, Peterson states the following. This is very revealing. Probably there should be less religion and more open-mindedness to what the Bible is trying to tell us.
I can’t tell if I’m an advocate of the religious viewpoint or its worst possible critic. Because I am doing my best to make it rational, and there’s a reductionistic element to that. But I think that I’m doing that while also leaving the door open to things that I don’t understand. Because that there’s more to this story than I understand or can understand. And I’m laying out what I can understand and I’m making it rational, but I do not believe for an instant that that exhausts the realm. It’s like there are ways of interpreting these stories that work in the conceptual universe we inhabit right now. But there’s a lot of things that we don’t understand.
One thing I found about digging into these stories is that the deeper you dig, the more you find. This is like an accelerating Universe… it should be the opposite… the more you dig out gold the less there remains… here it’s the inverse! And that’s one of the things that convinced me that there was more to them than I had originally suspected. Because things would click, and I’d think, wow, that’s really something. And then I would take it apart further, and I’d think, oh, well, I thought THAT was something, but this is even more remarkable. It just keeps opening and opening.
This book and the experiences it evokes in readers, believers, and disbelievers are maybe deeper than we’ve realized. The Explanation will be taking a much closer look into its content and meaning.
Religious experiences are real. Where do they come from and their meaning are questions few, if any, can answer. Yet people can base their lives on such revelation.
This article is an excerpt from chapter 5.17 of the book Audit of Humankind.
A wise man once said, Teach you me, what I do not know.
Let’s get started with The Explanation.
- Inventory of the Universe
- Audit of the Universe
- Audit of Humankind
- Origin of the Universe (Commentary on Genesis 1)
- Origin of Humankind (Commentary on Genesis 1:26–2:7)
- Origin of Woman (Commentary on Genesis 2:8–25)
- Agony of Humankind (Commentary on Genesis 3)
You can read all the books of The Explanation series online. Buy the books at your favorite store. Sam blogs weekly at TheExplanation.com The Explanation masters Biblical Hebrew to help you unlock more in-depth Bible meaning. Free tools to read and study the Bible online.