Exploring The Paper Palace, Reese Witherspoon’s Captivating Book Club Pick

Janvi Trivedi
The Book Guide
Published in
3 min readJun 27, 2023

Enjoy this book on Audible with free Credits, read it on Kindle, or simply get it from Amazon.

Reese Witherspoon’s Book Club Pick, The Paper Palace: A Deep Dive into Secrets, Love, and the Shadows Within.

When The Paper Palace by Miranda Cowley Heller hit the shelves, it instantly became the talk of the town, just like many other captivating novels handpicked by Reese Witherspoon for her book club. As I delved into its pages, I found myself immersed in the tumultuous journey of Elle, a woman torn between her long-standing friendship with Jonas and the commitments of her marriage. Heller weaves a complex tale, blending flashbacks from their shared history with the present, leaving me questioning whether their actions are acts of infidelity or a result of fate.

I must forewarn everyone that The Paper Palace delves into the weighty subject matter, embracing Kurt Vonnegut’s advice of making the main character as miserable as possible. Elle’s life is marred by medical crises from birth, her parents’ unhappiness, and a series of traumatic events. At times, I couldn’t help but wonder if all these hardships were necessary for the progression of the story. For instance, Elle’s botched operation as a baby seemed disconnected from the narrative’s later stages.

While the novel’s length feels just right, it could have benefited from some trimming to offer respite from the emotional heaviness. In fact, I found myself needing to take breaks midway through the book due to the darkness Elle endures.

Structured through a skillful blend of flashbacks and present-day scenes, The Paper Palace takes us on a journey spanning a couple of days as Elle, Jonas, and their respective spouses find themselves in Elle’s family holiday home, known as The Paper Palace. Elle’s recollections, along with fragments of her parents’ and grandparents’ lives, aim to paint a complete picture of the events leading up to the pivotal decision she must make. Should she remain loyal to her husband, Peter, or succumb to the long-suppressed love for Jonas, hindered by the weight of their shared past?

The flashbacks are tightly woven, presenting poignant moments that reveal the complex dynamics of an extremely unhappy family over the course of half a century. It is within these layers of characterization that the novel truly shines.

However, there were instances when the language used in the book felt exaggerated, bordering on pretentious. These fleeting moments reminded me of the privileged lives depicted within the story. Discussing this with a friend, she mentioned that it recalls to the style of early-twentieth-century American writers, which might resonate differently with various readers. Personally, I couldn’t shake the cinematic ambiance throughout the book, a trait likely influenced by the author’s background. I could easily envision The Paper Palace being adapted into a compelling TV series, reminiscent of Big Little Lies.

So don’t be fooled by the sunshine-filled Reese Witherspoon logo on the cover. The Paper Palace is not your typical light beach read. Share it with your book club, but be prepared to confront the shadows lurking within its pages.

Enjoy this book on Audible with free Credits, read it on Kindle, or simply get it from Amazon.

Feel free to express your thoughts in comments, for more reviews and book summaries please follow our publication.

--

--