Brazilian Space Program
From its Begining to the Future Prospects
The history of the Brazilian space program is marked by a transition from military to civilian control, leading to significant advancements in launch vehicles, satellite manufacturing, and space exploration capabilities. Initiated in 1961 under military authority, the program faced obstacles due to international concerns about missile proliferation. However, a pivotal shift occurred in 1994 when civilian control was established under the Brazilian Space Agency, liberating the program from military constraints and facilitating its development.
Brazil’s pursuit of satellite launch capabilities led to the development of sounding rockets, including the Sonda series, culminating in the successful launch of the Sonda IV which began in 1984 and lasted until 1989. The establishment of the Alcântara Launch Center, situated advantageously close to the equator, further enhanced Brazil’s appeal for launching geostationary satellites.
The milestone moment in 1993 saw the launch of Brazil’s first domestically developed satellite, the Data-Collecting Satellite (SCD-1), symbolizing the nation’s growing space prowess. Subsequent collaborations with China in the China–Brazil Earth Resources Satellite program (CBERS) demonstrated Brazil’s commitment to international partnerships for earth-imaging satellites. Embratel, responsible for the Brazilian Satellite Communication System (SBTS), played a crucial role, operating satellites in geostationary orbit for communication purposes. The military’s historical involvement, especially through the Ministry of Aeronautics and the Space Activities Center (IAE), shaped the early trajectory of the program.
Despite the division of labor between civilians and the armed forces within the Brazilian Commission for Space Activities, military dominance persisted until the early 1990s. The civilian-led National Institute for Space Research (INPE) took charge of satellite development, while the armed forces focused on launch pads and rockets. The Brazilian space program’s evolution mirrors the nation’s commitment to technological independence and international collaboration.
The establishment of the Brazilian Space Agency (Agência Espacial Brasileira — AEB) in 1994 marked a pivotal shift, aiming to place the country’s space endeavors firmly in civilian hands. This move sought to address concerns, particularly from the United States, about the military’s involvement in the Brazilian Commission for Space Activities (Cobae). The AEB, led by a civilian and operating semi-autonomously, replaced Cobae, signaling a commitment to independent space exploration and deflecting international apprehensions. While the AEB oversees the Brazilian Complete Space Mission (MECB), the Ministry of Aeronautics retains control over launch facilities and vehicles, and the National Institute for Space Research (INPE) continues to lead satellite development. The effectiveness of the AEB in coordinating various ministries remains a subject of observation. It’s a recurring problem, with so much decentralization and so many actors performing interrelated functions that should be under the same agency.
Historically tied with the United States, Brazil’s space program underwent a significant shift in the 1980s and 1990s. The creation of the MECB in 1981 reflected Brazil’s ambitious goal of achieving space technology self-sufficiency with a US$1 billion investment. The shift away from U.S. dependence included efforts to produce essential components like ammonium perchlorate, a solid fuel oxidizer. International collaboration became a cornerstone of Brazil’s space strategy, engaging with countries like Canada, the European Space Agency (ESA), Russia, France, and notably, China. Brazil’s diversified partnerships aim to foster technological exchange and reduce reliance on any single nation.
The United States’ concerns about Brazil’s space capabilities, especially regarding potential missile development, led to restrictions through the Missile Technology Control Regime (MTCR) in the late 1980s. The MTCR aimed to curb the transfer of missile technology, and Brazil’s compliance in 1994 marked a shift. Brazil’s space relations evolved, moving towards cooperation and compliance, leading to its MTCR membership in 1995. Despite earlier restrictions, Brazil’s space capabilities improved by the mid-1990s. The decision to comply with MTCR guidelines and the subsequent acceptance into the regime indicated a new era in space relations. The commitment to international non-proliferation standards showcased Brazil’s dedication to responsible space exploration, emphasizing peaceful cooperation over security concerns.
Are you enjoying the content? If so, I would greatly appreciate it if you could hit that ‘clap’ button and follow me for more articles like this. Your engagement is crucial in helping me to continue delivering quality content. Thank you for being a part of our community!
Alcântara Tragedy
The Alcântara accident, known as the tragedy that shook the Brazilian space program, occurred on August 22, 2003, resulting in the loss of the VLS-1 V03 rocket and the tragic death of 21 civilian technicians. The mission, named Operation São Luís, aimed to launch the SATEC and UNOSAT satellites into equatorial orbit.
The VLS-1, proposed in 1979, faced challenges from its early launch attempts, with failures in 1997 and 1999. Operation São Luís represented the third attempt, seeking not only mission success but also the validation of the capabilities of the Alcântara Launch Center (CLA) and the Barreira do Inferno Launch Center (CLBI).
The accident, occurring during assembly operations, resulted in an unplanned ignition that destroyed the launch vehicle on the CLA platform. The rapid spread of the fire led to the loss of 21 lives within seconds. The impact was significant, not only in human terms but also in the considerable delay of the Brazilian space program. The subsequent investigation, conducted by Brazilian authorities with Russian participation, concluded that the cause of the accident was the unplanned ignition of the A booster. Various hypotheses, such as static electricity and electrostatic discharge, were considered, but the lack of a barrier between the boosters of the first stage was identified as a critical factor.
Luiz Bevilacqua, the president of the Brazilian Space Agency (AEB), ironically informed of the accident during a press conference about an agreement with Ukraine, emphasized the magnitude of the tragedy. The event sparked calls for an independent investigation, although the families of the victims eventually received compensations approved by the Chamber of Deputies. The aftermath of the accident involved the reconstruction of the integration tower, costing significantly more than its original construction. The Alcântara base continued its reconstruction until 2023, facing budgetary and technical challenges. The VLS-1 rocket program was terminated in 2016 in favor of the VLM, marking the end of an era.
The Alcântara tragedy served as a turning point, leading to a profound reassessment of safety procedures and operational protocols. The impact of this disaster reverberated far beyond the immediate human toll, delivering a severe blow to the overall momentum and progress of Brazil’s space initiatives. The ramifications of the Alcântara accident were particularly profound in terms of time lost, as the Brazilian space program faced a staggering delay of more than two decades. The setback hindered the nation’s ability to advance its technological capabilities, explore new frontiers, and contribute meaningfully to the global space community. The once-promising momentum that had been building within the program came to an abrupt halt, forcing a reevaluation of priorities and strategies for the future. In the aftermath of the tragedy, the painstaking process of rebuilding the damaged infrastructure and revitalizing the space program commenced. The extensive delays and resource-intensive reconstruction efforts significantly hampered the original goals and timelines set by Brazil for its space exploration endeavors. The nation had to grapple not only with the loss of lives and equipment but also with the intangible setback of shattered aspirations and the erosion of confidence in its space capabilities.
At this point, I’d like to move away from the analytical perspective of the text and get into a personal aspect. Although I was a child at the time, I completely remember the national repercussions of the accident in Alcântara. Ever since I was already interested in rockets and astronauts, even though I didn’t really understand anything about space programs and exploration. The Alcantara accident was a watershed, after which Brazil lost the confidence it had in itself, lost the confidence that it has the capabilities to venture into space and develop its own path with investment in science and technology. Since then, all efforts to rebuild, to start again, to try again have been minimal, the government is not interested and the Brazilian people have lost the vision that “yes it is possible”. Despite having one of the best geographical locations for launches, the country left its space program scrapped, with little sign of progress over the following decades. For me, this situation is humiliating. I dream that one day I’ll be able to see a 100% Brazilian venture exploring space and making a success of it. I can only imagine the pride felt by the Indians and Japanese when they saw their names written on the podium of the countries that have landed on the moon, hope one day i’ll feel it too. Anyway, let’s get back to the article
International Issues
The 2011 Wikileaks revelation shed light on the U.S. government’s active efforts to impede Brazil’s native space launch vehicle program, unraveling a diplomatic tussle that unfolded in January 2009. In a classified telegram dispatched from the U.S. Department of State to the embassy in Brasilia, a stark message was articulated: “We do not support Brazil’s native space launch vehicle program.” This revelation underscored the explicit U.S. stance against the creation and production of rockets in Brazil.
The telegram further elucidated the American position, emphasizing a clear apprehension about the transfer of rocket technologies to Brazil, especially from partners like Ukraine. The U.S. government’s directive sought to dissuade Ukrainian authorities from contributing to Brazil’s space endeavors and explicitly communicated a lack of support for Brazil’s indigenous space launch vehicle program. The crux of the matter revolved around the perceived risk of technology proliferation, prompting the U.S. to advocate against such collaborative initiatives. Additionally, the United States extended its restrictions beyond discouraging foreign partners’ involvement. A confidential document brought to light that the U.S. policy also barred the launch of U.S. satellites, or those with U.S. components, from the Alcântara Launch Center. The rationale behind this restriction was rooted in a longstanding policy that aimed to prevent the propulsion of U.S. space rockets from Brazilian soil. This comprehensive embargo painted a picture of diplomatic tensions and strategic considerations.
Since then, various conspiracy theories have emerged claiming that the US sabotaged the launch of the VLS, resulting in the explosion of the Alcantara base, but no proof of this has ever been found.
First Brazilian in Space
On October 18, 2005, the Brazilian Space Agency (AEB) and the Russian Federal Space Agency (Roscosmos) signed a contract for brazilian astronaut Marcos Pontes to be transported aboard the Russian spacecraft Soyuz. This marked the realization of the first Brazilian manned space mission, named the Centenary Mission, commemorating the hundredth anniversary of Santos Dumont’s flight.
The crew, consisting of Pontes, American astronaut Jeffrey Williams, and Russian commander Pavel Vinogradov, launched on March 29, 2006, at 11:30 PM (Brazilian time), from the Baikonur Cosmodrome in Kazakhstan. They traveled aboard the Soyuz TMA-8 spacecraft to the International Space Station (ISS), carrying 15 kilograms of cargo from the Brazilian Space Agency. This payload included eight scientific experiments developed by Brazilian universities and research centers, although these experiments did not yield significant advancements for Brazilian science. Among them were studies on the effects of radiation on bacteria and the growth of a bean plant. The mission, successfully completed, lasted about 10 days, with two days on the Soyuz and eight on the ISS.
According to Brazilian Air Force physician Luiz Cláudio Lutiis, who monitored the health of the Brazilian astronaut, the management of the Brazilian Space Agency (AEB) “did not assist where it should and hindered where it could” in preparing for the first spaceflight of a Brazilian astronaut. Lutiis stated that without NASA’s assistance, the astronaut would have been isolated from the world, and their only decent communication was maintained through the Internet with NASA’s help.
Future prospects
Brazil’s recently signing of the Artemis Accords on June 15, 2021, marked a significant milestone as the country became the 12th nation and the first in Latin America to join this international space exploration initiative. The signing ceremony, held at Planalto Palace, included key figures such as Former President Bolsonaro, Minister of Foreign Affairs Carlos Franca, and the then Minister of Science Technology and Innovation Marcos Pontes, (the only brazilian who went into space). The Artemis Accords, spearheaded by NASA, outline a collaborative vision based on the principles of the Outer Space Treaty of 1967, aiming to establish a secure and transparent environment that encourages exploration, scientific endeavors, and commercial activities for the benefit of humanity. With twelve nations already signatories, the U.S.-led Artemis Program seeks to build a robust global coalition for exploring the Moon, Mars, and other celestial bodies.
In addition to participating in the Artemis Accords, Brazil and the United States have deepened their collaboration on the peaceful use of outer space. A significant development is the Technology Safeguards Agreement (TSA), which received approval from the Brazilian Lower House on October 22, 2019. The TSA outlines safeguards for U.S.-licensed technology supporting satellite launches from the Alcantara Space Center in Brazil. This agreement not only opens avenues for commercial space cooperation but also positions the Alcantara Space Center to enter the global market for commercial space launches. The collaboration features American companies, including Hyperion, Orion AST, and Virgin Orbit, operating out of the Alcantara launch center. My critical view is that Alcantara has basically become a launch base for hire.
Moreover, the Brazilian Space Agency has been actively engaged with NASA through programs such a Scintillation Prediction Observation Research Task (SPORT), with plans to jointly launch a research satellite developed by NASA and the Brazilian Space Agency. This satellite will investigate ionospheric phenomena and scintillation, aiming to understand disruptions to advanced technologies like satellites and GPS signals. Furthermore, various agreements between the U.S. Department of Defense and Brazil highlight the depth of space cooperation, covering areas such as Space Situational Awareness, Research Design Testing & Evaluation, Major NATO Non-Ally Designation, and Space Weather Sharing. Brazil’s engagement in high-level Space Engagement Talks with the U.S. Space Force and other U.S. agencies underscores the commitment to fostering international collaboration in space endeavors.
In February 2021, the City of Rio de Janeiro renewed its institutional cooperation agreement with NASA, reinforcing a partnership that spans five more years. This agreement focuses on sharing data, models, scientific knowledge, and operational expertise. It also involves the development of a new urban flood forecasting model, enhancing the city’s ability to respond to extreme weather events promptly.
The Alcântara Space Center holds immense potential beyond technical considerations. The Brazilian Space Agency (AEB) envisions that maximizing the use of this center can bring about transformative changes in the social and economic fabric of Alcântara city, the State of Maranhão, and Brazil as a whole. The private sector’s involvement can stimulate economic development, creating jobs and fostering growth in various fields. The positive economic impact is evident from the Brazil-Ukraine joint venture launch complex, showcasing a substantial increase in Alcântara city’s GDP per capita. AEB believes that private sector activities can emulate the transformative effects witnessed in regions like Florida due to the Kennedy Space Center. AEB and the Brazilian Air Force’s Cooperation Agreement in 2019 paved the way for private use of the Alcântara Space Center, aiming to initiate private company launch operations in 2021.
Brazil’s strategic southern hemisphere location, with the CEA being the closest to the equator globally, provides a competitive edge, offering fuel economy advantages and access to polar and equatorial orbits. Brazil’s aerospace industry is well-positioned to engage in global value chains, contributing to positioning services, Earth observation, data analytics, and space situational awareness activities.
Despite the challenges faced the Brazilian space sector remains confident. It sees the present as an opportunity to prepare envisioning it as the commencement of a promising new era for space activities in Brazil. Although I see a promising future for Brazilian space exploration, with the country as a hub for launches, I miss the commitment to launch a national project, even though I see that in the eyes of the government it is much more advantageous and profitable to just launch other people’s projects.
If you liked this text and you like the work I’ve been doing here, I recommend my book, Shaping the world. In it I conduct a historical analysis from the feudal world to the post-Napoleonic era, addressing how these events have a direct impact on our current world, with its crises and ideologies. Take a look, it’s worth it, the book is available on the amazon platform in physical version and for kindle, and available free of charge to subscribers of the kindle unlimited platform.
