Negotiation: The Most Underrated HR Skill!

Mamnun Ahmed
The HR Beat
Published in
6 min readAug 19, 2023
A design saying, Negotiation as an HR

“Everything is negotiable. Whether or not the negotiation is easy is another thing.” -Carrie Fisher

Negotiation is a skill often linked to people who work in sales and marketing. They use it to close deals and win customers. But negotiation is also an important skill for people who are working in human resources (HR). They use it to handle the internal workings and dynamics of an organization.
HR workers are always negotiating with different parties (stakeholders), like employees, managers, leaders, candidates, and vendors. They talk about things like conflict resolution, pay, perks, training, and growth and development. They bargain to get the best results for the company and its employees while keeping good relationships and trust.

Today, we’ll talk about how important negotiations are in HR, the different kinds of negotiations HR workers have to deal with, and the strategies that can help them get better at them.

Why Negotiation Matters in HR

Negotiation is not only about reaching an agreement or a compromise. It is also about building rapport and trust, which are essential for effective HR management. By negotiating well, HR professionals can influence positive change and innovation within the organization.

HR workers need to be able to negotiate because it lets them:

  • Align the interests and expectations of different stakeholders;
  • Resolve disagreements and conflicts in a constructive way;
  • Create value and opportunities for the organization and its people;
  • Improve collaboration and cooperation between teams and departments;
  • Foster a culture of respect and mutual understanding.

Negotiation in HR Function

HR professionals face different types of negotiation scenarios in their daily work. Some of the common ones are:

  • Recruitment: HR professionals need to negotiate with candidates about things like salary, benefits, relocation, start date, etc. when they want to hire new people. They have to balance the needs and wants of the candidate with the organization’s funds and rules. They also need to convince the candidate to join the organization by emphasizing its value proposition and culture.
  • Performance Management; The Balancing Act: When doing performance reviews, HR workers need to negotiate with employees about their goals, feedback, ratings, rewards, etc. They need to acknowledge the employee’s accomplishments and efforts while also pointing out where they can improve. They also need to talk with managers about the employee’s performance goals and job development plans.
  • Employee Relations: When dealing with employee problems like grievances, complaints, disputes, etc., HR professionals need to negotiate with the people involved to find a fair and peaceful answer. They need to act as mediators and guides, getting everyone to talk and try to understand each other. They also have to make sure that the rules and policies of the organization are followed.
  • Training and Development; A Symphony of Growth: When planning and implementing training and development programs for employees, HR professionals need to negotiate with training providers on the content, cost, schedule, etc. of the courses. They need to ensure that the training meets the learning objectives and needs of the employees and the organization. They also need to negotiate with managers and employees on their participation and commitment to the training.
  • Benefits Administration; Crafting Well-Being: When creating and managing employee benefits packages like health insurance, retirement plans, etc., HR workers need to negotiate with benefits providers about the plans’ terms and conditions. They have to make sure that the benefits are competitive and full while keeping within the organization’s budget. They also have to talk with workers about how they sign up for and use the benefits.
Two People Shaking Hands
Successful Negotiation in HR

Refining Your HR Negotiation Skills

To be a great HR negotiator, you need to learn a few key skills:

Active Listening: For a negotiation to go well, both sides must understand each other’s wants and concerns. Paying attention and showing understanding can help people find things they have in common.

Effective Communication: Communication must be clear and to the point. Your negotiating position will be stronger if you present information in a reasonable and convincing way.

Preparation: Gather useful data and information before you start negotiating. This gives you the power to make good choices and make strong arguments.

Flexibility: When you negotiate, you often have to make concessions. Be willing to look into other options that could work for everyone.

Conflict Resolution: Learn how to handle disagreements in a positive way. It is very important to be able to turn arguments into useful conversations.

Leveraging Relationships: Build strong connections with stakeholders to create a trusting workplace. This can make talks go more smoothly.

Learning All the Time: The art of negotiating is always changing. Find training and other tools to keep up with the latest methods.

Real-life examples of how to negotiate successfully

Scenario A: (From Employee's Perspective)

Getting a raise from the HR manager after being promoted. Imagine being given a more important job and trying to get a pay raise. Here’s how to make your way through the conversation:

1. Do research and get ready: Make a list of your successes and information about the market salary.

2. Start by expressing gratitude for the promotion.

3. Give your expectations: Talk about how much money you want, backed up by study and your performance.

4. Listen and try to understand the HR manager’s point of view.

5. Suggest some alternatives: If the offer isn’t good enough, suggest extra pay or open hours.

6. Think About It: Don’t make choices quickly; ask for time to think.

7. Confirm Agreement: When you make a deal, thank the other person and write down the details.

Scenario B: (From an HR’s perspective)
Talking with your team leader or boss about a project deadline, Imagine that you have a tight schedule for a project and need more time to finish it. Use these strategies:

1. “Progress Report”: Tell your team leader or boss in a few words how things are going.

2. Point out the challenges: Describe the problems that could make the project fail.

3. Propose a New Timeline: Suggest an alternative date that is reasonable.

4. Show the benefits: Explain how an increase makes things better and more efficient.

5. Listen and deal with it: figure out what’s bothering them and answer properly.

6. Keep in touch: If your request is approved, keep them updated; if it isn’t, look for other options.

Scenario C: (From Emoployee’s Perspective)

How to talk to your boss about taking a few days off for a family trip. Let’s say you want to get time off work for a family trip. Here’s how to handle the negotiation:

1. Plan ahead: Pick a good time and tell your manager ahead of time.

2. Share Why It’s Important: Tell why the holiday is important to you.

3. Work Organization: Make sure work won’t be affected, and if it is, offer answers.

4. Be flexible: Offer to make up for lost time or to be there in case of an emergency.

5. Listen to feedback: If they say no, respect their choice and try to understand why.

6. “Gratitude or Adjustment”: If accepted, say “thank you”; if not, try to figure out why.

Scenario D: (HR’s Perspective)

Talking with a possible customer about the terms of a contract. Imagine you are a human resources expert trying to close a deal. Use these techniques:

1. Build rapport: Get to know them and understand what they need.

2. Value Proposition: Make sure the benefits of your plan are clear.

3. Address concerns: Think about what people might ask and give answers.

4. Ask for their comments and talk to them about their worries.

5. Come up with creative solutions: If they want to make changes, find a middle ground that works for both of them.

6. Agreement Confirmation: When you reach a deal, thank the other person and make it official.

In these real-life situations, discussion shows how useful it can be in many different areas. By learning how to negotiate, you’ll improve your HR skills and create a place where people can work together, understand each other, and be successful.

HR’s success is based on its ability to negotiate, which is an art that makes a peaceful workplace out of different people’s goals. HR workers who know how to negotiate make their jobs more than just administrative tasks. Instead, they become powerful forces that shape a culture of collaboration, empathy, and growth. As they make their way through the maze of internal negotiations, these HR heroes not only find solutions to problems but also create an environment where people’s goals come together and the company succeeds.

--

--

Mamnun Ahmed
The HR Beat

I write about Marketing, Psychology, Startup and many more. If you like my works you can Buy Me a Coffee: buymeacoffee.com/MamnunAhmed