Yes, It’s Time to Build, And…

Excerpt from Look Up! Weekly #6

Marc Weinstein
Apr 28, 2020 · 6 min read

This is an excerpt from Marc Weinstein’s weekly newsletter, Look Up!, which addresses modern philosophy, consciousness, economics, and entrepreneurship.

Marc Weinstein is host of the Look Up! Podcast. He is an active writer, angel investor, entrepreneur, start-up advisor, and certified yoga instructor. Marc is a regular speaker at corporate events, universities, and conferences. Click here to view past presentations and to book Marc.

If you’d like to receive Look Up! directly to your inbox and stay informed of future podcast releases, you can sign up HERE.

Two weeks ago, Marc Andreessen, famed founder of Netscape and one of the most powerful venture capitalists in Silicon Valley issued a call to arms:

“There is only one way to honor their [our forefathers & foremothers] legacy and to create the future we want for our own children and grandchildren, and that’s to build.

I could not agree more!

Yes, it’s time to build, AND it’s time for younger generations like mine to determine in what direction we want to take this nation.

We can start with a few questions that can hopefully deepen our understanding and guide us to build in the right direction.

Why Build?
Build for Who?
Build How?
Build What? (Andreessen spent the most time on this one)

Each of these questions alone is far too much for a weekly newsletter to explore, so I’ll be breaking down each category into its own section over the next few weeks.

Start with Why

While it may seem like an exceptionally easy question to answer, the outcome of building is so important, that we cannot afford to throw nuance to the wind.

Bold claims like “we build to drive economic growth,” or “we build to create jobs,” or “we build for a brighter future,” are great for motivational speeches, but each answer will lead to a vastly different outcome. Defining our “Why Build?” will possibly determine how we measure success.

GDP Growth: Building for Building’s Sake

The growth of the Chinese economy since GaiGe KaiFang (the opening & reform of Chinese economy in 1978) has been nothing short of remarkable. Over 800 million people have risen out of poverty. The CCP believes that in order to sustain this new normal, they need to maintain economic growth. This laser focus on GDP growth has led to some strange outcomes. It seems the CCP has confused the metric with the goal.

Over the last decade tremendous malinvestment into fixed assets has led to the rise of completely useless ghost cities. Many of the banks that financed this investment are now insolvent as the State Owned Enterprises that borrowed to build, are not generating enough income to repay their loans. I won’t even mention the massive waste of energy and other natural resources used to construct these monuments to the GDP god.

As Goodhart’s Law states,

“When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.”

GDP, Financialization, & Wealth Inequality

Although GDP has many known flaws, we share a similar obsession with this metric in the west. As in China, building for the sake of driving economic growth as measured by GDP has led to serious imbalances that will continue if we don’t change course.

First, the US economy has become completely “financialized” — finance, insurance, real estate, rental and leasing accounted for 20% of our GDP in 2019. Activities like the creation of derivative products contribute to GDP growth, but create outsized risks to the broader economy, moral hazard from bailouts, and do not improve the well being of our citizens.

It is not surprising, that as the US economy has become increasingly “financialized,” wealth inequality has grown to unprecedented levels. The top 10% of Americans own 81% of the stock market and the top 1% own 38% of the wealth.

GDP growth does not address wealth inequality, and wealth inequality leads to political instability, so it is one of the greatest issues of our time.

For those of you interested in a potential counterweight to GDP that accounts for wealth inequality — I’d check out Democratic Domestic Product, which measures output per individual vs. output per dollar.

“Why Build?” may also be to increase our Gross National Happiness. GDP measures how much money we spend, but not how we are actually doing. The US is currently ranked #1 with 25% of global GDP, but #19 in terms of happiness. Nearly 40,000 Americans have died by suicide in 2019 and anxiety disorders including depression affect 40 million Americans annually, a number that will only rise with growing unemployment.

Build for the Jobs, Stupid

Meanwhile, as Andreessen points out, stimulus to individuals and small business has been delayed or outright stalled. It is unclear if/ how small business will survive or how quickly these unemployment numbers will correct. Joblessness in America may become the new normal. Many companies might choose to operate with reduced staff amidst continued economic uncertainty.

Building with the goal to create new jobs is likely necessary. But why must we focus on work for work’s sake?

In a famous encounter in the 1960s, economist Milton Friedman was visiting a canal build in Asia. He asked why the workers were using shovels rather than heavy equipment. His guide responded that this was a jobs program, to which Friedman replied, “Then why not just give them all spoons?”

Yes, we can put America back to work, but first we must ask (yes you guessed it) “why?” we must create these jobs. Perhaps we can find answers that bring meaning back to work itself.

It’s 2020, we no longer need to accept an economy focused solely on survival! Existing and living are two completely different things.

If we are to inspire future generations, we must believe that humans can do more than “get by,” but instead can find meaning in work and in life.

Build to Invest in our Future

Our collective impact on the environment is a clear example of this zero-sum trade off between current and future generations. So far, we have not proven the collective will to make changes.

For example, a recent scientific study showed that if current soil degradation rates persist, we will run out of necessary top soil for farming in 60 years. But how can we change farming practices without negatively affecting the 2m small and medium sized farmers in the US? And what about the 23 million Americans living in food insecurity (access to calories but not nutrition) today.

Another example — WTI crude oil prices went negative last week, and it’s likely that many US oil and gas companies will go bankrupt in the near future. They will be unable to compete with state-owned oil companies like those in Saudi Arabia and Russia. As these businesses fail, we have an opportunity to pivot US energy away from fossil fuels to clean energy sources.

But oil and gas businesses employ over 10 million Americans in relatively high-paying jobs. Who is to decide that these people should suffer for our future?

Building alone does not provide the answers to these challenging questions. As I know from first-hand experience, “move fast and break shit” doesn’t always work.

So Why Build?

Live your questions now, and perhaps even without knowing it, you will live along some distant day into your answers. — Rilke

It’s clear there are many important reasons for us to build, and the simplest reason of them all is because we MUST.

What other choice do we have?

Perhaps like Sisyphus, we are destined to forever roll the boulder of our collective humanity uphill.

Though there is no perfect answer, at least asking Why Build? will lead to critical reflection; reflection that may only lead to further questions, which I leave open until another day.

The Look Up! Podcast

Hosted by Marc Weinstein, the Look Up!

Marc Weinstein

Written by

Host of Look Up! Podcast, Angel Investor, Startup Advisor, & Yoga Instructor. I’m happiest when learning.

The Look Up! Podcast

Hosted by Marc Weinstein, the Look Up! Podcast explores a number of important cultural issues of our time. Including our technology addiction, digital wellness, mental health, prison reform, the opioid crisis and more.

Marc Weinstein

Written by

Host of Look Up! Podcast, Angel Investor, Startup Advisor, & Yoga Instructor. I’m happiest when learning.

The Look Up! Podcast

Hosted by Marc Weinstein, the Look Up! Podcast explores a number of important cultural issues of our time. Including our technology addiction, digital wellness, mental health, prison reform, the opioid crisis and more.

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store