For People Who Want to Write Better Headlines But Aren’t Sure How…

Tom Ruwitch
The Marketing Advocate
2 min readOct 12, 2023
Photo by Mark König on Unsplash

Once upon a time, I tried to cook a batch of paella.

It didn’t go well.

The mussels were chewy. The chicken was dry. The rice was a sticky mess. So frustrating!

I fancy myself a decent cook. But decent doesn’t cut it when you strive to master a complicated dish.

Today, aspiring home chefs can turn to the internet for answers. Search YouTube for “How to Cook Paella,” and you’ll find hundreds of how-to videos.

But back in the stone age, home chefs relied on cookbooks (gasp!) for guidance…

…which makes me think of a great copywriter named Mel Martin…

…who wrote a hugely profitable ad for a mail-order cookbook…

…with a headline that marketers continue to study and swipe decades after Mel wrote it.

Here’s that headline: “For people who are almost (but not quite) satisfied with their own cooking — and can’t figure out what’s missing”

And here’s the ad…

There’s a ton of marketing genius in this ad.

For you who want to write better headlines or subject lines or social media teasers…

…here’s one big takeaway:

Describe the Person You’re Targeting

Mel Martin’s headline worked because readers saw it, and thought, “Yep…that’s me.”

The headline says, in effect:

…I know you, frustrated home chef…

…I know what you’re going through…

…And, if you keep reading, I’ll show you what you’re missing.

That’s irresistible, and that’s a formula that can work for any marketer.

Meet prospects where they are.

Show them you know them.

Demonstrate you know what they’re going through.

If prospects read your copy and say, “Yep, that’s me…,” they’ll lean in and pay attention.

If you liked this story…

…and want more like it, you can sign-up to receive MY lightbulb-moment-making 💡, laugh-inducing 🤣, never-boring ⚡️ emails.

Daily(ish) goodness delivered straight to your inbox. (This thing you just read began life as a humble little email before sprouting wings, leaving the nest, and flying here to Medium-ville).

Hesitant to get daily(ish) with me? Well…before you flee, see what the enlightened, amused, never-bored masses say. Discover why they wake up with me Monday through Friday mornings. As the old saying goes… “Some balked when I told them I send daily(ish) emails, but then they read a few…”

--

--

Tom Ruwitch
The Marketing Advocate

Storytelling standout, helping transform content from boring to brilliant, marketing from frustrating to fruitful, & results from pitiful to profitable