Why the Best Leaders Lose Great Employees

For highly educated executive positions, the cost of turnover can be up to 213% of the annual salary.

Obviously we have a lot of tangible and compelling reasons to keep our employees happy, productive and profitable.

So when you discover that your company is experiencing a high turnover rate, you need to get to the bottom of it. You need to stop the bleeding.

A Gallup poll pointed to one overwhelming reason employees quit their jobs:to get away from their manager. As WSJ announced:

People don’t leave jobs, they leave managers.

And it’s true. In their poll of 7,200 American adults, Gallup discovered that about half had left a job at some point in their life to get away from a manager they didn’t like. Communication was pegged the most influential factor in whether an employee got on with their boss or not.

Now, you would think that if good employees leave jobs over bad managers, the opposite must then be true, right? You might think it makes sense that if you’re a great manager, you’ll have no problem keeping your best employees.

But you would be wrong.

New research from the University of Illinois shows that even great leadershipdoesn’t necessarily mean you’ll be able to stop your most amazing people walking out the door.

In a new paper entitled Boundaryless LMX: Examining LMX’s Impact on External Career Outcomes and Alumni Goodwill, researchers Sumita Raghuram et al found that employees leave good and bad bosses at about the same rates.

Two of the study’s authors, Ravi S. Gajendran and Deepak Somaya, shared their findings in an HBR column. They explained:

What we discovered was surprising. Good leadership doesn’t reduce employee turnover precisely because of good leadership.

Wait a second… so being a good leader still means employees are going to leave you? What gives?!

The researches concluded:

Supportive managers empower employees to take on challenging assignments with greater responsibilities, which sets employees up to be strong external job candidates. So employees quit for better opportunities elsewhere — better pay, more responsibility, and so on.

They also note that employees who liked their bosses tend to think more positively of their former employers, so good leadership is still an important tool for goodwill. That goodwill can result in opportunities and productive relationships in future.

So, if being a great manager won’t help you keep your best employees, what will?

Reduce the impact of toxic people in the workplace by better managing them, or getting them out of your ranks. Make your workplace a fun, stimulating place for employees to be at their best (Barbara Corcoran shares a few of her best tips for creating happy workplaces here).

And remember that good management will still help you attract the best talent in future — even if they’re destined to move on to greater things and don’t stick around quite as long as you’d like.

Be a Unicorn in a Sea of Donkeys

Get my very best Unicorn marketing & entrepreneurship growth hacks.

Sign up to have them sent to your email directly!

About The Author

Larry Kim is the CEO of Mobile Monkey and founder of WordStream. You can connect with him on Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn and Instagram.

Originally published on Inc.com