The Story of Mike Bullinger

A Triple Homicide Case

Monica James
The Mystery Box

--

Nadja Medley was a widow who lived alone with her daughter, Payton. According to her best friend Rebecca, Nadja had been through a lot. Mike Bullinger was the one who brought Nadja out of her sorrow when she lost her husband.

Photo from The Spectrum

Mike Bullinger was a commercial pilot living in a small town just outside soul lake city, he had just happened to walk into Nadja’s massage spa, and that was where their love story began. Rebecca said that after Nadja met mike, she started to smile more, and you could see it on her face that she was happy. Mike took really good care of Nadja and her daughter. Mike would take them out to dinner, take them hiking. Payten became very close with mike that she had even started to call him dad. During one of their hiking trips, mike taught Payton how to shoot, and they would play around on ground leg wrestling, even as mike was 60.

Photo from People

Nadja had told Rebecca that no matter how close they were during these outings, it was never the same in bed. Even as they lived very close to each other, they never spent time or slept over in each other’s houses. At a point, Nadja asked mike for help with her mortgage because her husband left her…

--

--

Monica James
The Mystery Box

law student, true crime enthusiast, aspiring writer, writing to learn, immense storyteller.