How to Support Nonperformers Towards a Graceful Exit
Addressing nonperformance issues is critical for maintaining team effectiveness. This blog outlines strategies to aid nonperforming employees in exiting gracefully.
Many managers have to go through situations where they have to work with nonperformers and make them aware of concerns.
It is not an easy job. It involves a lot of emotions and has an impact on the rest of the team members.
Going through a situation of making a nonperformer gracefully exit the team is a painful situation.
But if done right, all the parties involved will have a better experience. It will be respectful of each other’s skills and the time they have put in.
Here are 5 steps that must be followed to aid a nonperformer in exiting the team and organization gracefully.
The Problems
Let’s look at the common problems that will occur when a member is asked to exit the team due to performance issues.
Problem#1: Emotional reaction
The team member may react emotionally to such a situation.
This can create tension and stress within the team, and in turn, affect the overall morale.
Problem#2: Legal challenges
If there is no proper documentation or low HR team involvement, it can lead to legal complications.
Ensuring compliance with labor laws and company policies is of utmost importance.
Problem#3: Team dynamics
An exit of a team member due to performance issues affects team productivity.
Hence managing the situation carefully is essential so that the effect is minimised.
The Steps
As a manager, here are the 5 steps that must be carried out to aid the team member in a graceful exit.
Step#1: Meeting and Documentation
By now the performance issues should have been documented clearly.
The documentation should have captured the areas where the team member has displayed performance issues and how they have impacted the team.
Once the decision has been made to let go of the team member due to performance issues, it is important to have a 1on1 meeting to inform and summarize the previously documented concerns.
As a manager, once the meeting is conducted and the decision has been informed then minutes of the meeting should be sent with a Cc to the HR team.
This will create the required paper trail and help avoid any legal problems.
Step#2: HR team inclusion
Once the meeting is conducted with the team member, an HR member should be brought in to take this forward.
The HR team will request any documentation, minutes of meetings, and any artifacts that will help them initiate the process and check the policies.
HR team might schedule a meeting with the team member, to check whether there are any unanswered concerns.
HR team may also explain the process, policies, and timeline for such cases.
Step#3: Next steps
Once the decision is made and HR is added to the loop, it is time to agree on the next steps.
The next steps should include,
1. identifying topics for knowledge transfer
2. identifying the last working day
3. settlement discussions with HR
4. completing any assigned work
As a manager, helping the member to get through these meetings without too much hassle is important. This will ensure there are no communication gaps.
Step#4: Plan knowledge transfer
Once the topic is identified in step#3, create a plan with the member and get it closed.
The sessions should be recorded. Also, ensure the team members taking the transfer have enough time to digest the information and clarify any questions.
This will help in easing the transition pressure.
The team members who are taking the transfer should slowly shadow the tasks that are getting completed by the one who is exiting. This will ensure continuity.
Step#5: Say Goodbye
Just because the team member is asked to exit due to nonperformance, it does not mean to celebrate the exit.
As a manager give feedback and remind about the area of improvement. Also, have a farewell meeting with the member to make a feel-good gesture.
This will ensure that the individual will not have a negative view of the company or the team.
As much as possible, as a manager, appreciate that member’s work during the farewell meeting and keep the discussion limited to remembering some good times.
The rest of the team
As a manager, while you are busy following the above steps and coordinating with HR for all the processes, don’t forget the rest of the team members.
It is important to communicate what is happening that is relevant, clarify any doubts, and remove rumors.
So try to,
a. maintain morale with the rest of the team as much as possible,
b. address any concerns the rest of the team members may have,
c. create a forum for open communication,
d. don’t share confidential information, restrict to the situation,
e. keep the focus on outcomes and upcoming work.
This will ensure that the rest of the team continues to focus on the assigned work without getting distracted.
Handling nonperforming employees with empathy and a structured approach is crucial for maintaining team morale and productivity.
By following the steps outlined above, managers can ensure a fair and respectful process, leading to a smoother transition for all involved.
If you like such blogs, follow The New Manager publication.
