Splashback: How Flushing Toilets Could Be a Hidden Killer in American Hospitals
Flushing toilets produce a cloud of droplets that could carry potentially lethal pathogens, say engineers who have studied the fluid dynamics of splashback for the first time
Clostridium difficile bacteria is an ordinary component of healthy gut flora. But it can sometimes become deadly.
When the normal bacteria are wiped out by antibiotics, C difficile can preferentially repopulate the gut and take over. When that happens, the toxins produced by the bacteria can become life threatening. Indeed, some 14,000 people die in American hospitals each year because of this.
An important question is how transmission occurs and today Giovanni Traverso at Harvard Medical School and a few pals investigate a mode of transmission that has so far received little attention.
This is by droplets from flushing toilets, which do not have lids in American hospitals. The fear is that flushing causes bacteria-bearing droplets to fly out of the bowl and into the atmosphere where any passer-by can touch or inhale them.
To study this problem, these guys take a unique approach. They’ve videoed a toilet bowl from the side at a rate of between 1000 and 2000 frames per second to see how droplets emerge as it is flushed.
And they’ve compiled their results into a video which they’ve submitted to the Gallery of Fluid Motion 2013, organised by the Fluid Dynamics Division of the American Physical Society.
This video is worth watching (hi-res video 80.8MB, lo-res video 9.6MB). It shows large droplets flying out of the bowl, which have the capability of contaminating surfaces nearby. And it shows how a cloud of small droplets forms above the bowl which has the potential to be inhaled. All this happens with a standard high pressure hospital flush with a water pressure of 80 psi.
Hospitals may also be contributing to the problem unwittingly. C difficile spores are particularly hard to kill. A ten minute soaking in bleach usually does the trick but anything less leaves the spores in a viable state. So hospitals sometimes clean toilets by adding detergent to the water in the bowl.
This has unintended consequences, however. Traverso and co show how the detergent reduces the surface tension of the water, significantly increases the production of small and large droplets during a flush and does not kill C difficile spores anyway.
“Current hospital practices enhance airborne transmission,” they conclude.
That should stimulate some much needed debate about this form of transmission and how to prevent, or minimise, it.
Any and all suggestions welcome as comments here.
Ref: arxiv.org/abs/1310.5511 : Fluid Fragmentation From Hospital Toilets
