The Strange Evolution of Self Obsession on Reddit

The self-proclaimed frontpage of the internet has grown exponentially in just a few years. But could Reddit’s increasing self-obsession be sowing the seeds of its eventual decline? 

Reddit is a social news and entertainment website to which users submit content in the form of links to webpages, pictures, movies and so on. Other users then vote to determine which submissions get the most prominence on the site.

If you’re not familiar with Reddit, where have you been! It describes itself as the “front page of the internet” and since it launched in 2005, the site has grown into one of the biggest and most influential on web. According to the web-ranking service, Alexa, Reddit is the 69th most popular site on the planet with more than 110 million unique visitors per month.

So in just a few years Reddit has grown from a small community of users to one of the busiest places on the web. That raises an interesting question: how has this community, and the way it behaves, changed during this period of rapid growth? How has Reddit’s character evolved?

Today we get an answer thanks to the work of Philipp Singer at Graz University of Technology in Austria and a few pals who have performed the largest ever study of Reddit’s evolution.

Their conclusion makes for interesting reading. They say Reddit has changed from a gateway to the web into a community that is increasingly obsessed with itself.

Singer and co’s work raises important questions about Reddit’s future—could the site’s self-obsession be sowing the seeds of its eventual demise?

Singer and co began by collecting all the submissions to Reddit between 2008 and 2012, along with the number of up and down votes, the author, date and so on. That’s a total of almost 60 million submissions to 126,000 subreddits from 5 million different authors.

They then set out to answer two questions. First: how has the diversity of submissions to Reddit changed in those five years? Second: how have voting patterns have changed; or in other words how have users changed the way they allocate their attention to different types of content?

The results reveal a dramatic change over time. Reddit content is allocated to topics called subreddits. In 2008, 213 subreddits were receiving at least one submission each month. By 2012, that number had risen to 32,202 subreddits.

What’s more, in 2008, the 20 biggest subreddits received 80 per cent of the submissions. By 2012, the top 20 were receiving only 40 per cent of the submissions. That’s a huge increase in diversity.

This increase in the number of subreddits is a reflection of the formation of numerous well-defined communities focused on certain themes, many of them with their own rules, cultures and submission ethics.

Singer and co are duly impressed. They say that on the face of it, Reddit’s increased diversity seems to mirror the diversity on the web itself. “In sum, the subreddit diversification fits sufficiently well with the claim of Reddit representing (the best) content from all over the Web,” they say.

But deeper analysis reveals something else. These guys go on to study the types of submissions that users post. “For Reddit to be in fact a “frontpage” for — or a gateway to — content from all over the Web, one would expect an increasing diversity among the link targets,” they say

But that hasn’t happened. Instead, the submissions are increasingly of two types—images and text posts hosted on Reddit itself (such as r/askReddit). These have become the main type of content submitted to Reddit.

In particular, image links point almost exclusively to a site called Imgur.com, which was created in 2009 specifically to host images for Reddit users. There is a strong sense in which Imgur is the image-hosting extension of Reddit.

Singer and co conclude that there has been a fundamental shift on Reddit from focusing on external content to focusing on content hosted by Reddit (and Imgur) itself. “Reddit has been experiencing an increasing, fundamental shift from “out-reference” to more “self-reference,” they say.

That has a significant impact on the way people use the site. “Compared to the early phase of Reddit, visitors are nowadays much more likely to end up consuming self-referential content instead of finding their way through the proverbial gateway back out into the Web,” say Singer and co.

That’s an interesting survey that raises important questions about how Reddit might evolve in the future. One problem with self-referential content is that only frequent Reddit users can understand it. While that might increase the sense of belonging to a community, it also raises a potential barrier for newcomers.

Singer and co are careful not to draw any conclusions about the future of Reddit. But others might ask whether Reddit’s increasing obsession with itself should be a concern.

Reddit has enjoyed phenomenal exponential growth in recent years while other social news sites have suffered catastrophic decline, particularly Digg.com. One lesson from these collapses is that seemingly small factors can have a dramatic impact on websites.

Reddit is unlikely to be any different.

Ref: arxiv.org/abs/1402.1386 : Evolution of Reddit: From the Front Page of the Internet to a Self-referential Community?