The Controversial Figure of Donald Trump: Analyzing the Impact

Wayne Ince
The Polis
Published in
6 min readJan 19, 2024

Photo Credit: Author | image created using Adobe PSexpress.

In recent years, few figures have captivated the world like Donald Trump. Donald Trump has captivated the world in recent years, from his unexpected rise to power to the controversies surrounding his presidency. This article delves into the multifaceted nature of his influence, examining the cult of personality surrounding him and the political questions raised by his deification. By unpacking the complexities of Trump’s presence in American politics, we can better understand the challenges facing democracy today.

Examining the Cult of Personality Surrounding Donald Trump

Donald Trump’s ability to capture the public’s attention resembles a mesmerizing flame, attracting people like moths. To a considerable extent, his opponents find it compellingly difficult to avert their gaze while observing his fits of rage, much like witnessing a vehicular accident. His larger-than-life persona and ability to steer the narrative have cultivated a devoted following that views him as a savior, guiding the country toward prosperity.

However, it is important to recognize that everyone does not share this perception. Critics, like myself, argue that his larger-than-life persona is merely a facade, designed to distract from his controversial policies and actions. His ability to steer the narrative is more about manipulation and control rather than genuine leadership. I assert that the idea of him being a savior is misguided, as his policies often benefit the wealthy elite at the expense of marginalized communities. Instead of guiding the country toward prosperity, I argue his actions exacerbate social and economic inequalities. Therefore, it is crucial to evaluate his actions and policies critically instead of blindly following his perceived cult persona.

Therefore, it is crucial for all his critics to analyze the dangers of such unwavering cult-like loyalty. Mindlessly idolizing a leader like Donald Trump can hinder critical thinking and suppress dissent, threatening the very essence of our democratic values.

One aspect of Trump’s mesmerizing appeal is his skillful use of social media. With over 88 million followers, his Twitter now X, account has become a platform for him to address with his supporters, bypassing traditional media channels. This direct line of communication creates a sense of intimacy and connection, further solidifying the cult-like following.

Statistics reveal the extent of Trump’s influence on his supporters. A Gallup poll conducted in 2020 found that 94% of Republicans approved his handling of the economy. This unwavering support, akin to a rock-solid foundation, underscores the deeply ingrained belief in Trump’s ability to deliver prosperity. However, other fundamental values, such as social justice and environmental sustainability, may become compromised in pursuing growth.

It is important to note that the cult of personality surrounding Trump is not unique in history. Charismatic leaders have emerged, captivating the masses with their promises of change and prosperity. However, history has also shown that blind devotion to a leader can have disastrous consequences. The rise of authoritarian regimes and the erosion of democratic institutions serve as cautionary tales, reminding us of the dangers of unchecked loyalty.

Unpacking the Political Questions Raised by the Ascension to Godhood of Donald Trump

The glorification of Donald Trump raises critical questions about the role of leadership and the state of democracy. His ascendancy to mythic status within his angry and mostly anti-immigrant base challenges the foundations of a healthy political system. Democracy thrives on open debate and the exchange of ideas, yet a figure like Trump can polarize the nation, stifling the discourse necessary for progress. Does anyone remember when we used to discuss and debate actual issues like the price of gas, instead of focusing on a criminally indicted former president and his many law-breaking and anti-ethical actions?

A striking example of this polarization is clear in the 2020 presidential election. Exit polls revealed Trump got 71% of the white Evangelical vote, showcasing a dedicated base that saw him as a defender of their values. However, this unwavering allegiance to a leader who aligns with specific religious views raises concerns about the separation of church and state, a principle fundamental to democracy. However, I doubt that he genuinely upholds evangelical values. It seems more like he puts on a public display of it, solely to gain votes wherever he can.

The worship of Trump has caused a deeper division between his supporters and those who are against him. Each side demonizes the other as the political landscape becomes increasingly polarized. The Republican congress, with hardly any effort, has abandoned working on bills to aid Americans, including their own supporters. This toxic environment hampers the ability to find common ground and work towards solutions that benefit the nation.

Examining the impact of Trump’s deification also requires considering the international stage. The cult of personality surrounding him has reverberated globally, shaping perceptions of the United States and its role in the world. Allies and adversaries alike have closely watched the rise of Trump, questioning the stability and reliability of American leadership. This has implications for foreign policy, trade relations, and global cooperation.

In conclusion, the cult of personality surrounding Donald Trump has profoundly affected American politics and society. We must critically analyze the consequences of such unwavering loyalty, despite not being able to deny his ability to captivate and inspire a devoted following. The idolization of a leader can undermine democratic principles, create division within a nation, and have significant consequences at home and abroad.

The Essential Elements Missing in the U.S. Democracy

Identifying the Key Components Every Democracy Needs

A democracy, like a well-functioning engine, requires several essential components to operate effectively. Central to this is a robust system of checks and balances, ensuring no single individual can amass unchecked power. However, the Trump era exposed vulnerabilities within the American democratic system, highlighting the need for greater accountability and transparency.

Data supports this assertion, as research published by the Pew Research Center shows a decline in public trust in government during Trump’s presidency. Only 17% of Americans surveyed expressed confidence in the federal government to do what is right “just about always” or “most of the time.” Safeguarding the democratic institutions upon which society relies requires addressing this erosion of trust.

One crucial element missing in the U.S. democracy is a comprehensive and accessible education system. Informed citizens are the lifeblood of any democracy, as they possess the knowledge and critical thinking skills necessary to make informed decisions. However, disparities have plagued the American education system, with unequal access to quality education based on socioeconomic status and geographical location. Dealing with revisionist history plays an important part in providing all children with a diversity of learning. Addressing these disparities and ensuring equal educational opportunities is essential for a thriving democracy.

Assessing the Deficiencies in the U.S. Democratic System

While the United States prides itself on being a beacon of democracy, the Trump era revealed structural weaknesses that leave the nation vulnerable. One such weakness lies in the influence of special interest groups and the role of money in politics. The metaphorical grip of corporate influence can choke the voices of everyday citizens, distorting the democratic process.

Studies substantiate this concern, unveiling a correlation between campaign contributions and policy outcomes. The Princeton University study by Martin Gilens and Benjamin I. Page found that the preferences of the wealthy elite and interest groups exerted a more substantial influence on policy outcomes than the preferences of average citizens.

This stark inequality undermines the principle of “one person, one vote,” challenging the very essence of democracy.

Another critical element missing in the U.S. democratic system is a comprehensive system of electoral reform. With its winner-takes-all approach and lack of proportional representation, the current electoral system often leads to a two-party dominance, limiting the diversity of voices and perspectives in the political landscape. Implementing electoral reforms, such as ranked-choice voting or proportional representation, can enhance the inclusivity and fairness of the democratic process, allowing for a more accurate representation of the electorate’s preferences.

Conclusion

Electoral reform is a hot topic in the United States, especially after the controversial election of Donald Trump in 2016. Many people argue that the current electoral system, where the candidate with the most electoral votes wins, is outdated and does not accurately represent the will of the people. Some believe that a popular vote system would be a fairer way of electing the president, while others argue that the Electoral College was put in place for a reason and should not be changed. Regardless of one’s stance, it is clear that the possible election of Donald Trump has sparked renewed interest in electoral reform and the discussion continues to be a contentious issue in American politics.

--

--

Wayne Ince
The Polis

I write about social justice, mental health , politics, and marginalized communities. PHI THETA KAPPA. Published author in National Magazine Veterans Voices