Member-only story
The Yemeni Signal Chat Leak: A Mistake or a Masterstroke?
Reactions Within the Signal Group Involving Members of US Administration Add Layers of Complexity
The Signal chat leak of US military plans to carry out airstrikes in Yemen is a perfect illustration of how the line between transparency and security is always a fine one. What appeared on first glance to be an accidental leak of sensitive data now has broader implications of motive, management and what rules apply under various sets of circumstances regarding maintaining the privacy of classified material.
From my perspective, responses in the chat group scan gamut of the event. Participants included prominent figures such as Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth and National Security Adviser Mike Waltz. When the breach was discovered, one member expressed alarm, asking, “This was never supposed to happen here. How was someone outside added to this group?”
Another shifted focus toward containment efforts, stating, “Let’s not focus on how – damage control is priority now.” However, skepticism about the accidental nature of the leak arose, with another member suggesting, “This feels deliberate. There’s no way this kind of lapse just happens.”
