Broken Silence is Deafening

Priya Shukla
The Prosaic Mosaic
Published in
3 min readJan 29, 2018

This week, #TimesUp for Larry Nassar

Credit: Volkan Olmez, Unsplash

The dozens of young women assaulted by Larry Nassar (especially Rachael Denhollander, whose courage instigated it all) and Judge Aquilina, who sentenced him, have been on my mind this past week.

The heart-breaking and gut-wrenching testimonies that 156 women provided was yet another reminder of the systemic entrenchment of sexual assault and harassment. It is appalling that Jerry Sandusky’s abuse and Joe Paterno’s complicity were not a sufficient enough wake-up call, and Nassar’s situation is grotesquely similar — over a dozen officials enabled his heinous behavior. It is clear that where some universities will indeed take a closer look at Title IX complaints, others will likely continue to turn a blind eye in pursuit of prestige.

And then there is Judge Aquilina, who is being heralded for originating a new form of justice, allowing each victim to confront their abuser and individually acknowledging the power of their testimony. Yet, it didn’t take long for her to be described as “histrionic” and accused of “judicial grandstanding”, criticisms that a male judge would likely never receive. The irony of the sexism against Judge Aquilina against the background of dozens of sexual assault victims is simply astounding.

However, she made one misstep that clearly stemmed from her disgust for Nassar — she declared “If the U.S. Constitution didn’t forbid cruel and unusual punishment … I would allow someone or many people to do to him what he did to others.” While it is impossible to imagine any type of justice that would level the score between Nassar and his victims, it is integral that we do not lose our humanity as we consider the monstrosity of Nassar and his ilk.

Still, the humiliation, pain, and loss that Rachael Denhollander endured by making her story public and the extent to which she prepared for being disbelieved drives home that WE MUST BELIEVE WOMEN, even when it forces us to question what we know and trust.

Dive deeper into #MeToo with …

You Should Also Check Out…

--

--

Priya Shukla
The Prosaic Mosaic

Ocean and Climate Scientist; PhD Student at UC Davis studying the effects of climate change on shellfish aquaculture. https://blogs.forbes.com/priyashukla/