The Radical Center
Published in

The Radical Center

To Plan or Be Planned

Planning is what every person does on a daily basis. There is no question even homeless camps, street trading, and such are planned. People always plan. The question is whether the spontaneous plans of millions can come together in ways to allow development or whether central planning, imposed by some authority with coercive powers, is required.

We are constantly supplied with goods and services spontaneously produced. Every day food flows from agricultural areas around the world to vendors ranging from major supermarkets to corner shops. Each link in that chain of production and distribution makes plans according to their own subjective standards and desires. No one mandates what is produced, where it is produced, for how much it will sell, how it will be distributed, who shall distribute it, when they shall distribute it, or to whom they shall to distribute it. Yet throughout the country food is found in abundant supplies.

The coordination of the market takes place when individual planners are allowed to make decisions, based on their own self-interest. Each individual in the production chain is seeking to maximize their own profit. To do so they cooperate with others, each of whom is also pursuing their own self-interest. Yet in the end each of them improves their own standard of living. And in so doing they improve the lives of every other person in that chain of production from the farmer to the consumer.

This is what Adam Smith meant when he said markets appear to be guided by an “invisible hand.”

Each individual has a “harmony of interests” with all the individuals in the chain of production even though they do not know, or will never meet, the vast majority of them. Herbert Spencer put it this way:

“The houses they live in, their furniture, clothes, fuel, food — all are brought into existence by the spontaneous efforts of citizens supplying one another’s wants. …The roads, the railways, the trains, the telegraphs are products of combined exertions prompted by desires for profit and maintenance. The villages and towns they pass exhibit the accretions due to private actions. The districts devoted to one or other manufacture have been so devoted by men who were simply seeking incomes to live upon. The enormous distributing organization with its vast warehouses and retail shops lining the streets, carrying everywhere innumerable kinds of commodities has arisen without the planning of any one.”

Economic development is simply another type of market, or more precisely, a combination of markets. Development takes place, often in spite of centralized planning, provided the conditions for trade are present. The basic conditions, which all markets need to succeed, are simple.

First, there is the requirement of property rights. Individuals who do not have security of title in the property they “own” will not develop that property to its highest potential. Not only must the individual have secure title to the property, but also necessary is they be allowed to trade property when it suits their purposes to do so. A home, which cannot be sold, is also not as likely to be maintained as well as a home that can. The primary function, some say only function of government is to protect the rights of individuals and one fundamental right is the right to own, develop and trade property.

Second, is the need for contracts. Individuals need to know a contract, when entered into, will be enforced. Every functioning society or market needs “promises” or the situation where people will actually do what they promise. No one has the inherent right to a specific contract with a specific person but they do have contractual rights. This means they can contract with one another for specific purposes. Once that contract is entered into it is the “right” of the parties to the contract to see it fulfilled. The enforcement of contracts is a necessary component of a free society.

Third, the question of externalities must be addressed. Common law has a rich and long tradition of dealing with questions of externalities. Liberals have long taken the position the common law is sufficient to handle these problems and centralized planning, as a means of coping with externalities, will lead to more problems than it can solve.

Fourth, the rule of law is required. Some misinterpret the rule of law to mean a law must be passed before government may or may not take a specific action. But the rule of law goes much deeper than that. Yes, it does mean rules imposed on individuals must also apply to the state as well. But, it also means the laws of good governance (which are inherent in human nature and are thus not legislation) must be followed as well. There are natural limitations on the ability of governments to do whatever they wish. These limitations are not imposed by legislation but are natural, or part of the nature of reality. The Greeks, who originated the concept of the rule of law, meant by law, those principles of nature which are imposed on everyone including governments.

The creation of an environment conducive to development is absolutely necessary for development to take place. This not only means government must fulfill its legitimate functions of protecting rights but it must also limit its activities so as not to impede development. The latter talent is one few governments seem willing to hone.

Please consider donating a small amount monthly to cover costs. Even $1 a month adds up. Donate on our page at Patreon at whatever level you feel comfortable.



Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
James Peron

James Peron

James Peron is the president of the Moorfield Storey Institute, was the founding editor of Esteem a LGBT publication in South Africa under apartheid.