What is the most stressful part of high school? Over 50% report applying to college!
Written by The Ivy Institute, a college admissions consulting firm.
The transition from high school to college is a pivotal moment in a young individual’s life, yet it is often marred by the immense stress associated with college applications. Recently, the National Association for College Admission Counseling (NACAC) conducted a revealing survey, commissioned from The Harris Poll and released just days ago, that delves into the depths of this anxiety.
Shockingly, the results highlight that more than half of the approximately 1,000 surveyed students regard the process of applying to college as the most stress-inducing academic experience they have encountered thus far. Additionally, this comprehensive survey seeks to uncover students’ perceptions concerning the fairness of college admissions, a topic that has gained newfound prominence following a recent Supreme Court ruling challenging the constitutionality of race-conscious admissions.
For students, the process of applying to college is often a daunting experience, characterized by the need to unravel the intricacies of various admissions policies and navigate through an avalanche of paperwork. The survey, commissioned by NACAC, has cast a stark light on this anxiety. It has revealed that more than half of the respondents, drawn from a diverse pool of 1,000 students, consider the act of applying to college as the most nerve-wracking academic endeavor they have confronted to date. This finding underscores the complexity of the application process and highlights the omnipresent fear that one minor error in the application could irrevocably harm their chances of admission.
The recent Supreme Court ruling on race-conscious admissions policies has added an extra layer of complexity to the college admissions landscape. While the ruling directly impacts only a fraction of educational institutions, there are widespread concerns about its potential repercussions on the accessibility of higher education for marginalized students. This ruling has ignited discussions regarding the urgency for colleges to revamp their application processes to ensure fairness.
In the wake of the Supreme Court’s decision, the issue of fairness and diversity in college admissions has come to the forefront. It has sparked profound debates about the policies and practices governing the acceptance or rejection of students into higher education institutions. As colleges grapple with the implications of this ruling, they must also grapple with the broader implications it holds for the future of higher education.
David Hawkins, NACAC’s Chief Education and Policy Officer, has emphasized the pressing need to overhaul the application process. The goal is to prioritize a student’s academic performance in K-12 education while simplifying the application procedure. Certain elements of admissions, such as legacy preferences, tend to disproportionately favor white and affluent applicants. Simplifying the application process may be an arduous undertaking, but it is an indispensable one. The ultimate aim is to alleviate the burdens placed on students who are already grappling with a labyrinthine system.
Simplifying the college application process is no trifling matter, but it is an imperative one. To establish an admissions system that is fair and just, colleges must take into account the myriad factors that contribute to a student’s ability to thrive in higher education. By refocusing on academic performance and streamlining the application process, institutions can level the playing field for all applicants.
The survey findings illuminate that applying to college is perceived by more than three-quarters of the students as a pivotal juncture in their lives. However, this perspective diverges among racial groups. While 71% of white students regard applying to college as a momentous life event, 82% of Hispanic students and 85% of Asian students share this sentiment. For Black, Hispanic, and Asian students, the application process carries not only immense significance but also considerably more stress.
The act of applying to college often serves as a reflection of a student’s dreams and aspirations. It encapsulates years of unwavering dedication and hard work throughout high school. However, the weight of this moment can be particularly burdensome, especially for students hailing from underrepresented backgrounds who must grapple with additional barriers and challenges in the application process.
One striking revelation from the survey is that 42% of students perceive college admissions as inherently biased. While this viewpoint is held by a minority, it serves as an unequivocal wake-up call. A majority of students view the admissions process as significantly skewed, with privileges predominantly favoring the affluent and privileged. Consequently, there is an urgent need to shift the focus of admissions discussions away from the selective institutions that frequently dominate headlines and towards the broader higher education landscape.
The perception of an inherently biased admissions process raises critical questions about fairness and equity in higher education. It challenges the conventional belief that admissions decisions are solely based on merit and academic achievement. As colleges strive to foster more diverse and inclusive student bodies, they must also grapple with the concerns expressed by students regarding the fairness of the admissions process.
A significant majority of surveyed students — nearly three-quarters — emphasize the utmost importance of having diverse student bodies in higher education. Furthermore, close to 60% express their support for race-conscious policies, which had been a staple of college admissions for decades until the recent Supreme Court decision. Prior to this ruling, colleges were allowed to consider race as a factor in admissions but were prohibited from imposing racial quotas of any kind.
The call for diverse student bodies is not merely a call for colleges to embrace a wide spectrum of human experiences and perspectives, but also a recognition of the pivotal role that diversity plays in creating a vibrant and enriching learning environment. Students acknowledge the value of engaging with peers from various backgrounds, as it enhances their educational journey and prepares them for a globally interconnected world.
The COVID-19 pandemic has catalyzed significant changes in the admissions landscape, with a notable rise in test-optional policies. The flexibility to apply without SAT and ACT scores has not only resulted in an increased number of applications but has also diversified the candidate pool. Remarkably, almost 80% of students express that these policies would encourage them to apply to an institution.
The pandemic compelled colleges to reevaluate their reliance on standardized tests as a primary criterion for admissions. Test-optional policies have ushered in a transformation by providing students with greater flexibility and leveling the playing field. They have opened the doors of higher education to a more diverse array of applicants, heralding a new era in college admissions.
The survey commissioned by NACAC offers a poignant insight into the labyrinthine world of college admissions. It uncovers the pervasive stress that students endure during this critical phase of their educational journey. Furthermore, it underscores the imperative for colleges to reevaluate their admissions processes, with an emphasis on equity and inclusivity. As the higher education landscape continues to evolve, addressing the concerns expressed by students and striving for fairness in college admissions will undoubtedly be at the forefront of discussions in the years to come.
About the Author:
The Ivy Institute of College Admissions Consultants
www.theivyinst.org
The Ivy Institute is a team of expert college admissions consultants from the Ivy League and top colleges. If you have questions about the admissions process or your chances of acceptance to an Ivy League or top college, we are here to help. Our experienced consultants will provide valuable insights and guidance tailored to your specific profile and aspirations.
Don’t hesitate to reach out to us, today, at www.theivyinst.org/contact to speak with one of our college admissions consultants!
