The End of Affirmative Action: Exploring Alternative Strategies for Justice
The Vinci Town + Numerology
In the wake of the recent Supreme Court ruling that declared affirmative action unconstitutional, it is imperative to explore and implement alternative strategies that continue to address systemic racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination that persist in our society.
Despite the cancellation of affirmative action, the need for policies that promote equal opportunities and representation for historically disadvantaged groups remains evident, as indicated by persistent disparities in access, achievement, income, wealth, health, and representation among different societal groups.
Socioeconomic or Class-Based Preferences
Socioeconomic or class-based preferences are one alternative to affirmative action. These preferences aim to level the playing field by giving a leg up to students and job applicants from low-income backgrounds, regardless of their race or ethnicity. They can help mitigate economic inequality’s effects and provide opportunities for upward mobility.
If you support socioeconomic or class-based preferences, you may be interested in learning more about some organizations that also support them. Here are some examples:
The American Psychological Association (APA) supports implementing federal policies and programs to decrease poverty and inequality. They strive to address the needs of low-income and economically vulnerable communities. Additionally, the APA offers resources and publications that explore the impact of socioeconomic status on different aspects of human functioning, including health, education, and well-being.
The Century Foundation is a think tank focused on social justice, economic opportunity, and democratic reform. The policy proposals on using socioeconomic or class-based preferences in K-12 schools and higher education while analyzing and researching these issues and have published reports.
Jack Kent Cooke Foundation’s mission is to support talented students from low-income families by providing scholarships, grants, and other forms of assistance. Their ultimate goal is to create a level playing field for these students and ensure they can access the same educational opportunities as their more privileged peers.
Some proponents of socioeconomic or class-based preferences argue that they are more fair and effective than race-based preferences because they target the root cause of educational disparities and do not rely on racial categories that may be arbitrary or inaccurate. They also claim they can foster greater diversity and social cohesion by reducing racial resentment and promoting cross-class interactions.
Considering socioeconomic and class-related aspects can effectively address disparities in education and employment opportunities based on race. However, it’s necessary to consider the criticisms and challenges that come along with these preferences. Some argue that they may need to address the effects of past discrimination and ongoing inequalities fully. It’s crucial to acknowledge that the current selection process may unintentionally exclude qualified minority candidates who don’t fit into the low-income category while benefiting privileged white candidates who don’t face systemic barriers. We still have more work to do, but working towards our national objectives as a united front is a positive step in enhancing the system.
Universal or Holistic Approaches
Universal or holistic approaches are another alternative to affirmative action. These approaches aim to consider everyone, not just their race or ethnicity, in admissions or hiring decisions. They can consider various factors, such as academic achievement, personal experiences, leadership potential, and community involvement. By doing so, they can promote diversity and inclusion without relying on quotas or preferences based on specific groups. Some examples of holistic approaches in education are:
The Texas Top Ten Percent Plan guarantees admission to any public university in the state for students who graduate in the top ten percent of their high school class. This policy has increased the representation of underrepresented minorities in higher education without explicitly using race as a criterion.
The International Baccalaureate (IB) program is a two-year educational program primarily aimed at 16-to-19-year-olds in 140 countries worldwide. The IB program offers a rigorous curriculum that fosters critical thinking, intercultural understanding, and global citizenship among students.
The IB program also requires students to engage in community service, creative activities, and personal projects that reflect their interests and passions. Many universities recognize the International Baccalaureate (IB) program as a valid entry into higher education on a global scale.
Some of the benefits of the IB program for students are:
- Developing future-ready skills like inquiry, communication, collaboration, and self-management.
- Driving their learning pathway and developing the confidence and resilience they need to thrive and make a lasting difference.
- Building global awareness and responsibility through learning a second language and exploring different perspectives and cultures.
- Having a higher opportunity to gain admission to top prestigious universities worldwide and perform better throughout their careers.
- Place-based learning, which involves learning within places in the local community. It overlaps with many holistic learning approaches, mainly the focus on interconnectedness. Place-based learning can help students develop a sense of belonging, responsibility, and stewardship for their environment and culture.
Universal or holistic approaches can also help reduce stigma and resentment arising from affirmative action policies and avoid legal challenges that question their constitutionality.
Outreach or Recruitment Programs
Outreach or recruitment programs are a further alternative to affirmative action. These programs aim to reach out to underrepresented groups and encourage them to apply for education or employment opportunities. They can help diversify the applicant pool and create a more inclusive environment.
However, these programs are challenging. One of the significant obstacles they may face is the negative stereotypes and prejudices in society and the institutions they target.
These can affect potential applicants’ and decision-makers perceptions, attitudes, and behaviors. Therefore, it is vital to address these stereotypes and prejudices through education, awareness, dialogue, and role models. Outreach or recruitment programs should focus on increasing the number of diverse applicants and creating a culture of respect and appreciation for diversity and inclusion.
Support or Retention Programs
Support or retention programs are another alternatives to affirmative action. These programs aim to help disadvantaged individuals succeed in education or employment by providing them with the necessary resources and support. They can include academic advising, tutoring, mentoring, career counseling, financial aid, and other services.
Some examples of support programs are the Student Support Services Program (SSSP), which provides academic and personal support to low-income, first-generation, or disabled college students; the Minority Access to Research Careers (MARC) program, which offers research training and mentoring to underrepresented minority students who want to pursue careers in biomedical sciences; and the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA), which helps job seekers access employment, education, training, and support services.
Support or retention programs can benefit individuals and the institutions that offer them. Individuals can improve their academic performance, self-confidence, motivation, and career prospects. For institutions, they can increase the diversity, retention, and graduation rates of their students or employees. Support or retention programs can also foster a more inclusive and supportive environment.
Reform or Transformation Programs
Reform or transformation programs are a more radical alternative to affirmative action. These programs aim to change the structures and systems perpetuating inequality and discrimination rather than simply addressing their symptoms. They can involve changes in policies, practices, cultures, and attitudes at all levels of society.
First Conclusion
In this conclusion, I acknowledge that I do not have a definitive answer to whether affirmative action should end. Our country must show unwavering determination and sharp insight to tackle this complex and controversial issue.
We still have a long way to go to achieve justice and equality for all people, regardless of their race, gender, or other identities. Affirmative action was one of the strategies to address systemic discrimination and promote diversity and inclusion, but it was not the only one. In this paper, I have explored alternative strategies that can continue advancing these goals. These strategies could be better, but they offer promising possibilities for creating a more equitable and inclusive society.
Hopefully this paper has inspired you to think critically and creatively about how we can continue fighting for change, supporting each other, and challenging our biases and prejudices. The journey toward justice and equality is still ongoing, but it is also not hopeless. We are all part of it and can make a difference.
Now!!
I invite you to explore another aspect of our company’s mission: helping people discover their potential through numerology. Numerology is a fascinating and ancient system that reveals the hidden meanings and patterns of numbers in our lives. By learning about your numerology profile, you can gain insights into your personality, talents, challenges, and opportunities. You can also learn how to align yourself with the natural cycles and vibrations of the universe and how to manifest your goals and dreams. To learn more about numerology, please visit our website and sign up for a free reading using ‘The Vinci Mail’ . Thank you for reading this paper, and I hope you enjoy your numerology journey!
Transition:
As we transition from this paper’s factual and analytical part, let’s delve into a more inspirational and symbolic perspective. Numbers, like words, have meanings and can tell stories. In numerology, each number has a specific vibration or energy that can influence our understanding of events and situations. Let’s explore the numerological significance of the alternatives to affirmative action.
Numerological Analysis
Numerology attributes the number 5 to change, freedom, and adventure. This dynamic number motivates us to embrace change and seek new experiences. This paper has explored five alternatives to affirmative action, including socioeconomic or class-based preferences, universal or holistic approaches, outreach or recruitment programs, support or retention programs, and reform or transformation programs. These options represent different paths toward change and progress.
The number 2 represents the importance of teamwork, balance, and cooperation. It motivates us to work together and find shared goals. To come up with solutions to affirmative action, it’s essential for different groups and stakeholders — including educators, employers, policymakers, and community members — to cooperate and work together.
The number 9 represents completion, wisdom, and humanitarianism. It encourages us to learn from our experiences and use our wisdom for the benefit of others. The end of affirmative action is not a defeat but a completion of one phase and the beginning of another. It is an opportunity for us to apply our lessons and use our wisdom to create new strategies for justice and equality.
Final Conclusion
In the post-affirmative action era, we are called leaders, innovators, and advocates for justice and equality. The numbers remind us that we have the power to create change and make a difference. Let’s continue to explore the possibilities, embrace the challenges, and celebrate the progress we make. The journey towards justice and equality continues, and we are all part of it. Let’s make it count.
We’d love to hear your thoughts. Email us at artvinci@thevincitown.com and join the conversation. For more engaging content, follow us on Twitter @TheVinciTown. Interested in diving deeper? Check out our other blogs below for more stories:
Sustainable Choices: A Day’s Impact
Mike Tyson vs. Evander Holyfield: The Bite Fight
Bernie Madoff: A Numerological Exploration of His Life and Crimes
