Television | Comics

Evil Supermen: Homelander, Omni-Man, and Our Relationship with Power

Scott Gladstein
The Ugly Monster
14 min readJun 27, 2024

--

Image compiled by Scott Gladstein | Credits: DC Entertainment, Marvel Comics, Amazon, Dynamite Entertainment, Image Comics, and Sony Pictures

Superman is a power fantasy, and our re-imagining of him in evil forms shows our world’s changing relationship to people in power.

It’s easy to look at Superman today and make fun of him. The “Big Blue Boyscout” is an aberration in the era of satire, tongue-in-cheek Marvel flicks, and deconstructionist takes on the superhero genre. That’s probably why we have so many “Evil Supermen”: Homelander, Omni-Man, Brightburn, and to a lesser extent characters like Hyperion, Hancock, and the like.

I think our relationship with Superman’s power is reflective of the abuse of power we see in our society. Everything from cops beating people in the streets in riot gear, to regular and flagrant corporate crimes, to governmental atrocities committed for personal enrichment. Because of this we’ve invented dark, twisted, horrible versions of Superman, our biggest shared cultural power fantasy embodied in a character, to examine this.

The Dark Age of Comics

The Dark Knight Returns and Watchmen © DC Comics

--

--

Scott Gladstein
The Ugly Monster

Game Developer (Little Red Goblin Games LLC), MBA, Absurdist, Nerd, Indie Dude, Comic Reviewer, and SCA Rapier Fencer.