A rational person’s 1-minute guide to why rational thinking often fails to persuade people

We believe so strongly in the idea that logic, evidence, and data are the only acceptable tools for persuasion, that we feel bewildered and frustrated whenever we interact with someone who doesn’t hold these same values.

Frustration leads to less than kind communication, because it’s very difficult to be frustrated and kind at the same time.

Those who are repeatedly belittled and trapped by self-identified logical/rational thinkers will create new values and beliefs to protect themselves because nobody likes feeling belittled and trapped.

And those values and beliefs will not be exactly illogical, just designed to reject anything valued as fact/logic by the opposition.

Enter: denialism. Which also happens to be the first stage of grief.

For those who value and believe in the power of rationality as a thinking tool, it becomes rational to revisit rationality as a method of persuasion, because it fails to produce results.

It’s time to toss that hypothesis and look for a better one, just like we’re asking others to do.

Can we move past denialism on this topic, through anger, and right into bargaining, depression, and eventually acceptance? I think so.

In fewer words:

http://xkcd.com/1901/

Agree or disagree?

--

--

--

Learn the life-changing art of productive disagreement.

Recommended from Medium

The cost of ending a covenant relationship has more than a monetary value

How to talk to people you can’t identify with

Hello, I’m David Cromwell from Thoughts of Cromwell.

Hello, Can You Hear Me?

How I Spent Days Behind Closed Doors Though I Loved Going Out

The Perils of Modern Romance

To Teenagers ‘in love’ with adults…

3 Situations Where “It’s Not You, It’s Me” is the Most Honest Answer

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Buster Benson

Buster Benson

Author of Why Are We Yelling? The Art of Productive Disagreement. I run new.750words.com. Previously product at Patreon, Slack, Twitter, and Amazon.

More from Medium

The Valley

How Volunteers Can Help Middle School Students (And Why They Need To)

The problem you are having in your workplace: New Grad Edition

The Infinite Way