Empowerment in Action

Implementing the Adoptee Voice and Visibility Framework for Lasting Change

Shane Bouel
Thoughtless Delineation
4 min readFeb 29, 2024


Empowerment in Action Implementing the Adoptee Voice and Visibility Framework for Lasting Change
AI Artwork By Thoughtless Delineation

In the pursuit of justice, understanding, and societal transformation, the Adoptee Voice and Visibility Framework stands as a beacon guiding us through the intricate narratives of those affected by historic forced adoption. This framework, illuminated by the Scottish Government Historic Forced Adoption Scoping Study Final Report, seeks not only to acknowledge the unique challenges faced by adoptees but also to amplify their voices, making them central in conversations about adoption.

This introduction serves as a call to action — a recognition of the need for systemic change and a commitment to empowering adoptees in their journey towards self-discovery, resilience, and societal acceptance. Join us as we explore the profound layers of the Adoptee Voice and Visibility Framework and discuss how its implementation can pave the way for a more compassionate and equitable future for all those touched by the complexities of adoption.

1. In-Depth Analysis of Stakeholder Recommendations:
The report mentions recommendations from various stakeholders, but it could benefit from a more in-depth analysis of these recommendations. This could involve a detailed examination of the feasibility, potential impact, and challenges associated with implementing these recommendations.

2. Comparative Analysis with International Practices:
The report primarily focuses on Scotland, but a comparative analysis with international practices could provide valuable insights. This could include examining how other countries have addressed historic forced adoption, the success of their strategies, and potential lessons for adoption.

3. Quantitative Data and Statistics:
While the report provides qualitative insights, incorporating quantitative data and statistics could strengthen the analysis. This might include prevalence rates, demographic information, and the long-term impact of both adoption and forced adoption on individuals and communities.

4. Inclusion of Personal Testimonies:
Personal testimonies from individuals affected by historic forced adoption could add a powerful human element to the report. Including firsthand accounts can help policymakers and the public better understand the emotional impact and nuances of these experiences.

5. Implementation Roadmap:
While the report discusses recommendations, a more explicit implementation roadmap could enhance its practicality. This might involve outlining steps, timelines, responsible entities, and potential challenges associated with the suggested actions.

6. Engagement with Diverse Perspectives:
Ensuring that the report reflects a diversity of perspectives is essential. This includes hearing from individuals with different socio-economic backgrounds, ethnicities, and geographic locations to capture a more comprehensive understanding of the issue.

7. Long-Term Monitoring and Evaluation Plan:
Establishing a long-term monitoring and evaluation plan for the recommended actions would ensure ongoing accountability. This could involve defining key performance indicators and milestones to track the progress and impact of the initiatives over time.

8. Accessibility of Information:
Ensuring that the report is accessible to a broad audience is crucial. This involves using plain language wherever possible and providing summaries for non-expert readers. This would facilitate wider public understanding and engagement with the report’s findings.

9. Global Best Practices in Redress:
While the report acknowledges the importance of redress, delving into global best practices in redress for historic forced adoption could provide valuable insights. Understanding how other jurisdictions have approached compensation, acknowledgment, and support for affected individuals could inform Scotland’s strategy.

10. Stakeholder Consultation in Action Plans:
In the development of action plans, engaging with relevant stakeholders, including affected individuals, advocacy groups, and professionals, could enhance the robustness and inclusivity of the proposed strategies.

This heralds a new era in early childhood education and care. By embracing the profound insights and experiences of adoptees, we pave the way for a more inclusive, compassionate, and empowering future.

This endeavour is not just about frameworks and policies; it’s about fostering a culture of understanding, acceptance, and growth. As we embark on this transformative journey, let us remember that true empowerment lies in amplifying voices that have been historically marginalized.

The Adoptee Voice and Visibility Framework serves as a guiding light, reminding us that every story, every perspective, and every unique journey enriches the tapestry of our collective narrative. In the realm of early childhood education and care, this framework is more than a tool; it is a catalyst for change, a testament to the power of collaboration, and a commitment to creating spaces where every child’s identity is not only acknowledged but celebrated.

As we move forward, let the principles of the framework be woven into the very fabric of our educational landscapes. Let us stand united in our commitment to providing an environment where adoptees flourish, where their voices resonate, and where their experiences shape the foundation for lasting change.

With “Empowerment in Action,” we embark on a journey toward a future where adoptees not only find meaning and fulfilment in their lives but also become architects of their own narratives. Let this be a chapter in the ongoing story of empowerment, inclusion, and the relentless pursuit of a world where every child, regardless of their adoption journey, can thrive.

Together, let us build a legacy of understanding, compassion, and empowerment — one that echoes through the halls of education, leaving an indelible mark on the hearts and minds of generations to come.



Shane Bouel
Thoughtless Delineation

Using creativity to lift standards of ethics & morality by questioning half-truths and denouncing the conservancy of inhumane ideologies.