Student snapshots of Britain’s planned communities show failed neighborhoods, idealism in action in the 1970s

Long-lost lecture slides document housing projects and the students who learned from them

Brendan Seibel
Timeline
4 min readDec 11, 2017

--

Department of Town and Regional Planning undergraduates traveling on the Oxford Canal from Rugby to Oxford, 1968. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)

The cities had sprung up like feral organisms and grown into ramshackle warrens of tenements that quickly crumbled. In the aftermath of The Blitz, the British government fast-tracked plans to raze entire districts of substandard housing and thin out urban populations by building entirely new planned communities. It was a new, thought-out, and modern nation. Towers climbed high above the streets and modernist utopias took root in the countryside.

It was a time of good intentions and an unflappable belief that blueprint theories could be seamlessly applied to real life. In 1965, the University of Sheffield established a cross-disciplinary department to create a top-notch program, made up of the nation’s sharpest minds. They even lured J.R. James, the former Chief Planner from the Ministry of Housing and Local Government, to be their first professor of Town and Regional Planning.

Field trip at Tavy Bridge, Thamesmead, looking toward Oakenholt, Trewsbury and Penton Houses, circa 1970. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)

Since the late 1940s, James had worked in government overseeing a variety of social housing schemes, from wholesale planned communities called New Towns, to tower-block mini-cities in the skies. He brought decades of experience to the university as well as thousands of slides highlighting the good and bad of housing across the country and beyond. But James wasn’t content to sit back and force a roomful of bright-eyed students to stare at his photos; he also orchestrated trips into the field so that the next generation of urban planners could learn from the successes and failures of the last.

For 10 years James shared his knowledge with optimistic acolytes in lecture halls and on the streets. Future urban planners toured blighted tenements and rundown neighborhoods left untouched by the wrecking ball, visited monumental concrete tower blocks and walked their causeways, and ventured to utopian enclaves throughout the country. Just building new homes for people wasn’t enough to create a cohesive community. Students needed to walk the public spaces where neighbors interacted and drive the local roads in order to get their heads around the underlying infrastructure that tied everything together. Some housing projects had devolved into drug-infested war zones, while some has succeeded as modest homes for those of modest means. Some New Towns had become isolated hellholes of disillusionment and poverty, while others thrived and prospered. Town and Regional Planning classes surveyed, researched, and devised schemes to improve upon outdated models of development.

View of Oldham from Plum Street. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)

James died in 1980 but his legacy lives on, although for 30 years a portion of it was boxed up in a basement and presumed lost. The unearthed archive of lecture slides, maps and assorted ephemera — documentation of planned communities or inspiration for the next generation — are a time capsule of utopian visions from an era when the concrete and glass were shiny and new, the idealism untested.

Problems of expansion in New Towns. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
(left) Abandoned homes. (Tony Crook) | (right) Departmental field trip to a Glasgow tenement, 1978. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
Tony Crook and David Mather, Durham Field Course, 1971. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
Bush Fair Neighborhood Center, Harlow, Essex. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
Field course at Irvine Centre, 1978. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
(left) Open market in Harlow, Essex. | (right) Open market in Ashton-under-Lyne, Greater Manchester. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
Manchester Street, Oldham. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
Park Hill, Sheffield. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
Abbotsford Place, Glasgow. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
Department field trip at Hadrian’s Wall, 1968. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
University of Sheffield Department of Town and Regional Planning undergraduates traveling on the Oxford Canal near Rugby on a field trip in 1968. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
Tenements in Glasgow, 1978. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
Cyclists crossing Hodings Road, Harlow. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
(left) Public consultation in Cumbernauld, March, 1967. | (right) Field trip to Dover, circa 1970. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)
Children’s play area, Wells Quarry, Craigavon. (JR James/Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield)

--

--

Brendan Seibel
Timeline

Interested in the interesting. Been at @Timeline_Now, @wired, @medium, @motherboard, elsewhere.