# Subbaramiah Minakshisundaram

### Quick Info

Trichur (now Trissur), Kerala State, India

Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, India

### Biography

**Subbaramiah Minakshisundaram**was known as Minakshi by his colleagues and friends. He was called Jeja by his parents, Jeja meaning God, but we chose to use the name Minakshi throughout this biography. His father, from Salem, had a British Raj Government job as a sanitary engineer. His mother married by the age of eight years as a child but her first child, Minakshi the subject of this biography, was not born until she was 24 years old. Minakshi had two younger brothers. His first years were spent in Kerala where he learnt the Malayalam language but the family moved to Madras (now Chennai) because of his father's job. From that time the family spoke Tamil.

Minakshi entered the Calavala Ramanujam Chetty High School in Perambur, Madras in 1919. His two younger brothers, however, attended the Ramakrishna Mutt School, Mambalam, Madras. Minakshi continued his education at the C R C High School, graduating with the Secondary School Leaving Certificate in 1929. At the High School [2]:-

... he had constantly topped in mathematics having shown a marked aptitude for it.After graduating from the High School, Minakshi attended Pachaiyappa's College, Madras. To read about his time there, and about other events in his life, see THIS LINK.

This following description by his daughter of his bad start at the College sounds somewhat exaggerated but must contain some truth [4]:-

I remember my father once narrated that his first exam in class I he failed. He obtained zero in mathematics. In the following academic year, innocent child that he was, he went and sat in class II room. The teacher drove him away saying he failed and should go back to class I. The shock and realization was such that from then on he always topped the class. His special attention and effort in mathematics was outstanding. In the British Raj, educational standards were high, especially English which in those days was really tough. My father struggled in the Intermediate level for English. He overcame the difficulties and, of course, his English was excellent and meticulous.After the Intermediate at Pachaiyappa's College, in 1931 Minakshi entered Loyola College, Madras, to study for a B.A. (Hons) in mathematics. This College had an excellent reputation for producing First Class students in the Madras University examinations and, indeed, Minakshi was awarded First Class honours in mathematics in 1934. He did not want to stop his studies of mathematics at undergraduate level so he began research at Madras University while he earned a little working in the library of the University [9]:-

Unlike many brilliant young men of that time Minakshi desired to study mathematics more deeply and to take it as a career instead of going in for the administrative service which was more lucrative and prestigious. He was initially influenced by Professor K Ananda Rau, and as a research scholar at Madras University, began studying deeply the problems of summability of series. His passion for summability never left him and significantly his first and last papers have been on problems of summability.This first paper was

*Tauberian theorems on Dirichlet's series*(1936). In this paper he generalised a theorem first proved by his advisor Ananda Rau but his result not only generalised Rau's theorem but also improved it by removing some of Rau's restrictions. He followed this with two papers in 1937, namely

*On the extension of a theorem of Caratheodory in the theory of Fourier series*, and

*The Fourier series of a sequence of functions*. This was around the time that Minakshi was influenced by Father Charles Racine (1897-1976). Racine was born in Tomay-Charente in France, entered the Society of Jesus on 25 October 1919 and was ordained as a priest on 25 August 1929. After the award of a doctorate in mathematics in 1934 from the University of Paris, he went to India and worked at St Joseph's College, Trichy, until he became the Head of the Department of Mathematics in Loyola College, Chennai in 1939. Kollagunta Gopalaiyer Ramanathan (1920-1992) writes in [9]:-

In 1937-38 Fr Charles Racine, who had just come to India from Paris, having been trained in the famous French School in analysis, was invited by the Madras University to give a course of 'Extension lectures'. Fr Racine lectured on non-linear partial differential equations and especially on the work of Georges Giraud (1889-1943) and Maurice Gevrey (1884-1957). At about the same time Minakshi met Professor Muhammad Raziuddin Siddiqui (1908-1998) of the Osmania University, Hyderabad, who had studied with Leon Lichtenstein in Berlin and had written a thesis on non-linear parabolic and hyperbolic equations.Minakshi married Smt M Parvathi on 10 May 1937. She was born in 1924, so was only eight years old. They had three children, a son K Ramu (born 1943), a daughter K Girija (born 1945), and a second daughter K Radha.

Obtaining a university position was not easy and you can read about the difficult start to Minakshi's career at THIS LINK.

The difficult start was, however, worth the wait for in 1943 he was appointed as a Lecturer in the Department of Mathematical Physics of Andhra University. This Department, established in 1942, only a year before Minakshi joined it, was the first in South India to start post graduate and research programmes in Applied Mathematics. It was renamed the Department of Applied Mathematics in 1966.

Also in 1943 he became a member of the Indian Mathematical Society. His publication record was outstanding with three papers being published in 1942 and five in 1943. The event which was so important in Minakshi's development as a mathematician was an invitation to the Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, USA. Minakshi's daughter writes [4]:-

The Vice Chancellor [of Andhra University], in those days, was a distinguished personality who inculcated and inspired the faculty. Cattamanchi Ramalinga Reddy (1880-1951), an eminent Academician was unaware of the young mathematician in his faculty. He received a letter from the Princeton Institute for Advanced Study in 1945. The letter mentioned that Professor Robert Oppenheimer, Director of the Institute, requested to the Vice Chancellor of Andhra University that this brilliant young Subbramiah Minakshisundaram should be spared and given the opportunity to work in the Research Institute with several eminent mathematicians and physicists such as Professor Albert Einstein. Subbramiah Minakshisundaram should be permitted to work at the Institute for Advanced Study for couple of years. C R Reddy was amazed. He did not know who this brilliant young mathematician was. He called for the young Subbramiah Minakshisundaram and this began a beautiful relationship between them. Naturally with great pride C R Reddy helped my father's journey to the United States under the British Raj. My father went to the United States as a British Indian citizen. When he returned in 1948, India was a free Republic.Minakshi was at the Institute for Advanced Study from December 1946 to May 1948. Åke Pleijel, a Swedish mathematician who was almost exactly the same age as Minakshi, arrived at the Institute in September 1947. Pleijel and Minakshi collaborated on writing the paper

*Some properties of the eigenfunctions of the Laplace-operator on Riemannian manifolds*(1949). Salomon Bochner writes in a review:-

This paper offers an extension of a method of Carleman's from a Euclidean to a curvilinear setup, and the results of Carleman have been both generalized and added to; an important tool of investigation is Hilbert's parametrix.In fact, the paper contains the famous zeta function, now called the Minakshisundaram-Pleijel zeta function, which is a zeta function encoding the eigenvalues of the Laplacian of a compact Riemannian manifold.

Another important contact which he made while at the Institute for Advanced Study was Carl Ludwig Siegel.

Minakshi was promoted to a Reader in the Department of Mathematical Physics of Andhra University in 1946 so when he returned from the United States it was to the readership position. He was back in the United States in 1950 when he was invited to the Symposium on Spectral Theory and Differential Problems held at the Oklahoma Agricultural and Mathematical College in Stillwater, Oklahoma. He delivered the lecture

*Expansion in eigen-functions of the membrane problem*and this was published in the

*Proceedings*of the Symposium. While he was in the United States he attended the International Congress of Mathematicians held in Cambridge, Massachusetts, from 30 August to 6 September 1950. He was a member of the Institute for Advanced Study during August and September and renewed his contact with Carl Ludwig Siegel.

In 1950 Minakshi became a professor in the Department of Mathematical Physics of Andhra University. In the same year the head of the Department, A Narsinga Rao, retired; he had held this position for four years. In 1951 Minakshi was appointed as Head of the Department of Mathematical Physics and, in the same year, he participated in a summer seminar organized at the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Bombay. He was invited there by Komaravolu Chandrasekharan (1920-2017) who transformed the School of Mathematics of Tata Institute of Fundamental Research into a world class centre of excellence. This visit led to a collaboration between Minakshi and Chandrasekharan and they co-authored the book

*Typical Means*which was published by Oxford University Press in 1952. They write in the Preface:-

This book deals with the theory of 'typical means' and its applications to Dirichlet series and Fourier series. More than forty years have now passed since 'typical means' were first introduced by M Riesz for the summation of divergent series, and quite an extensive theory has developed during this period. We have attempted here to give a systematic account of this development. Readers of our account will hardly need to be told how much we owe to the Cambridge tract by Hardy and Riesz on the general theory of Dirichlet series.Harold Gordon Eggleston explains in [3] what 'typical means' are:-

The scope of many convergence arguments in analysis can often be extended by an appropriate interpretation of any divergent series (or integrals) that occur. Each such interpretation give rise to a method of summability. Although there re many inter-relations between different methods of summability it is usually the case that there is one method, or one type of method, tht is of outstanding importance in any particular problem. Typical Means or Riesz Means are a method devised to handle convergence problems that arise in connection with Dirichlet series.Minakshi had taken up smoking when on the long voyage back to India from the United States. He became a chain smoker and this almost certainly led to him suffering a mild heart attack in the middle of 1955. He was strongly advised by the doctors to give up smoking and rest for six weeks. After a few weeks he returned to work and, sadly, began smoking again [11]:-

He said he could be off smoking for some days but then he just couldn't think or do mathematics. Withdrawal symptoms from mathematics were more painful to him than those from smoking.On 13 August 1958, Minakshi was elected to the Indian Academy of Science. Earlier that year, in July, he had been a visitor at the Institute for Advanced Study while he was in the United States as part of an educational tour as a member of the General Education Team. He returned to India via Great Britain, taking in the International Congress of Mathematicians held in Edinburgh, Scotland, from 14 August to 21 August 1958. At the invitation of the organising committee, he gave the 30-minute lecture

*Hilbert algebras*at the Congress, and this was published in the Proceedings. Minakshi began his lecture as follows:-

Since the publication of the papers 'On Rings of Operators' by F J Murray and J von Neumann, there has been an increasing interest among mathematicians in the structure of topological algebras. Today I wish to discuss some properties of a class of algebras called Hilbert algebras.Until 1961 Minakshi continued his role as Head of the Department of Mathematical Physics. He also took on additional roles such as Warden of the University Hostels and Librarian of the University Library. You can read about an incident that occurred while he was Warden at THIS LINK.

Minakshi organized the Indian Mathematical Society Conference at Andhra University in 1961. In 1966 he was appointed a professor at the newly created Institute for Advanced Studies at Simla. He was pleased to accept this position since he felt that his administrative duties at Andhra University were preventing him from having the time to undertake mathematical research, and this was his real love. At Simla he began writing the book

*Spectral Theory of Differential Operators*. His daughter writes [4]:-

In the wonderful surroundings, the atmosphere of the foot hills of the Himalayan range, he could work peacefully with verve. The last work of life began. I was a degree student. I saw the joy of his soul as he mused and worked. He cherished this as having great value to the future of mathematics and to mankind. He knew this contribution of his was a major break through. Distinguished scholars from all over India and a few from abroad also were a part of the faculty. The Rashtrapathi Nivas in Simla housed the Institute for Advanced Studies, Simla. This used to be the summer capital of British Raj as the English could not bear the heat of Delhi!In 1967, while he was enjoying his time in Simla, he received a request from the Vice-chancellor of Andhra University to head a Post Graduate Centre in Guntur. The intention was that this Post Graduate Centre would become the Acharya Nagarjuna University in a couple of years time and Minakshi would be Vice-chancellor. His book on spectral theory was nearly complete so he accepted the new position. The heat and work load in Guntur, however, affected his health. Shortly afterwards he received a letter from Maryland University in the United States offering him the position of Head of the Research Programs of Mathematics. He decided to accept feeling that he would again be able to have time to devote to mathematical research and he agreed to take up the position at the start of the academic year 1967-68. By August he had arranged visas, passports and tickets for the United States. It was not to be, for before he was due to travel he had a massive heart attack.

After treatment at Vellore Christian hospital he lived for a while with his mother, then his brother and then with his daughter K Radha and his grandchildren. Although his health was now extremely delicate, he was desperate to return to his own home in Vizag. His family discouraged him but he was determined to go. At this time he was still employed by Andhra University and receiving his salary. Since he was not well enough to carry out his duties, he decided to resign. The Vice-chancellor of Andhra University tried hard to persuade him not to resign and made an offer of a special car to take him to the university for two hours on two days a week. Minakshi, however, insisted that he resign. At 10 p.m. on 13 August 1968 he had another heart attack. His daughter writes [4]:-

I was by his side. My father was looking at me as life passed out of him. He could not speak because of the pain. The expression in his eyes was powerful and he seemed to will something through me.G S R Sarma, Minakshi's nephew, writes about his mathematical work in [11]:-

Let me just add a few observations of personal admiration on my uncle's remarkable work and accomplishments. He started off on classical lines during and after his doctoral thesis devising new ideas and techniques on Fourier series, summability methods for classically divergent series, Tauberian theorems and eigenvalue problems which were all adjudged to be among the best of the times and are still cited and used. They also laid the foundations for his even greater accomplishments at Princeton. His work eventually fertilized fields like Spectral Geometry and Quantum Gravity, frontier areas of research even today.

### References (show)

- S Thangavelu (ed.),
*Subbramiah Minakshisundaram, Collected Works of S Minakshisundaram*(Ramanujan Mathematical Society, 2012). - Biography of Subramiah Minakshisundram. http://minakshisundaram.org/biography/
- H G Eggleston, Review: Typical Means, by K Chandrasekharan and S Minakshisundaram,
*Mathematical Gazette***38**(323 (1954, 61-62. - K Girija,
*Dr S Minakshisundaram: A Daughter's Tribute*. http://minakshisundaram.blogspot.com/search/label/Daughter%27s%20Tribute%20By%20Girija - C Musli,
*On S Minakshisundaram*. http://minakshisundaram.blogspot.com/p/on-sms-by-musili.htm - Professor S Minakshisundaram, Deceased Fellow,
*Indian National Science Academy*. http://insaindia.res.in/detail/N58-0457 - S M Parvathi,
*A Tribute to the Memory of SMS (my husband)*. http://minakshisundaram.blogspot.com/search/label/Tribute%20to%20the%20Memory%20of%20SMS%20By%20Parvathi - M S Raghunathan, Artless innocents and ivory-tower sophisticates: Some personalities on the Indian Mathematical Science,
*Current Science***85**(2003), 526-536. - K G Ramanathan,
*S Minakshisundaram*. http://minakshisundaram.blogspot.com/p/sms-by-kg-ramanathan.html - K G Ramanathan, S Minakshisundaram,
*J. Indian Math. Soc.***32**(1970), 135-140. - G S R Sarma,
*S Minakshisundaram: Some personal Reminiscences*. http://minakshisundaram.blogspot.com/search/label/Some%20Personal%20Reminiscences1 - S Thangavelu, S Minakshisundaram: A Glimpse into his Life and Work,
*Resonance***8**(2003), 41-50. - V Vajjhala,
*A Tribute to Prof S Minakshisundaram*. http://minakshisundaram.blogspot.com/search/label/Vidyanidhi%20Vajjhala - F Williams,
*A Brief Reflection on Work of Prof S Minakshisundaram*. http://minakshisundaram.blogspot.com/search/label/By%20Prof.Floyd%20L.Williams

### Additional Resources (show)

Other pages about Subbaramiah Minakshisundaram:

Other websites about Subbaramiah Minakshisundaram:

Written by J J O'Connor and E F Robertson

Last Update November 2019

Last Update November 2019